Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T04:47:13.940Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Exploring the turbulent velocity gradients at different scales from the perspective of the strain-rate eigenframe

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 January 2021

Josin Tom
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USA
Maurizio Carbone
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USADipartimento di Ingegneria Meccanica e Aerospaziale, Politecnico di Torino, Corso Duca degli Abruzzi, 24 10129 Torino, Italy
Andrew D. Bragg*
Affiliation:
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: andrew.bragg@duke.edu

Abstract

Expressing the evolution equations for the filtered velocity gradient tensor (FVGT) in the strain-rate eigenframe provides an insightful way to disentangle and understand various processes such as strain self-amplification, vortex stretching and tilting, and to consider their properties at different scales in the flow. Using data from direct numerical simulation of the forced Navier–Stokes equation, we consider the relative importance of local and non-local terms in the FVGT eigenframe equations across the scales using statistical analysis. The eigenframe rotation rate (that drives vorticity tilting) is shown to exhibit highly non-Gaussian fluctuations even at large scales due to kinematic effects, but dynamically, the anisotropic pressure Hessian plays a key role. The anisotropic pressure Hessian conditioned on the eigenvalues and principal vorticity components exhibits highly nonlinear behaviour at low values of normalized local gradients, with important modelling implications. We derive a generalization of the Lumley triangle that allows us to show that the pressure Hessian has a preference for two-component axisymmetric configurations at small scales, with a transition to a more isotropic state at larger scales. Correlations between the sub-grid stress and other terms in the eigenframe equations are considered, highlighting the coupling between the sub-grid and nonlinear amplification terms, with the sub-grid term playing an important role in regularizing the system. These results provide useful guidelines for improving Lagrangian models of the FVGT, since current models fail to capture a number of subtle features observed in our results.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Flow parameters for the DNS study (all dimensional parameters are in arbitrary units). The simulation was performed in parallel on $N_{{proc}}$ processors and all statistics are averaged over $T$, the duration of the run; $R_{\lambda } \equiv u'\lambda /\nu \equiv 2K/\sqrt {5/3\nu \langle \epsilon \rangle }$ is the Taylor microscale Reynolds Number, $u' \equiv \sqrt {2K/3}$ is the root mean square of fluctuating fluid velocity, $K$ is the turbulent kinetic energy, $\lambda$ is the Taylor microscale, $\nu$ is the fluid kinematic viscosity, $\langle \epsilon \rangle \equiv 2 \nu \int _{0}^{\kappa _{max}} \kappa ^2 E(\kappa )\,\textrm {d}\kappa$ is the mean turbulent kinetic energy dissipation rate, $\kappa$ is the wavenumber in Fourier space and $E(\kappa )$ is the energy spectrum. The integral length scale is defined as $\mathcal {L} \equiv (3{\rm \pi} /2K) \int _{0}^{\kappa _{max}} (E(\kappa )/\kappa )\,\textrm {d}\kappa$, $\eta \equiv (\nu ^{3}/\langle \epsilon \rangle )^{1/4}$ is the Kolmogorov length scale, $\tau _{\eta } \equiv \sqrt {\nu /\langle \epsilon \rangle }$ is the Kolmogorov time scale, $u_{\eta } \equiv (\langle \epsilon \rangle \nu )^{3/4}$ is the Kolmogorov velocity scale and $\tau _{\mathcal {L}} \equiv \mathcal {L}/u'$ is the large-eddy turnover time. The maximum resolved wavenumber is $\kappa _{{max}} = \sqrt {2}N/3$, $\kappa _{{max}}\eta$ is the small-scale resolution, $L$ is the domain size and $N$ is the number of grid points in each direction.

Figure 1

Figure 1.(a) Average and (b) variance of the terms in (2.10b), normalized by the scale-dependent time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _F/\eta$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.

Figure 2

Figure 2.(a) Average and (b) variance of the terms in (4.2), normalized by the scale-dependent time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _F/\eta$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Average of the filtered strain-rate eigenvalues conditioned on the second and third principal invariants of the filtered velocity gradient tensor. Panels (a–c) show conditional averages $\langle \tilde {\tau }\lambda _{1}|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\rangle$, $\langle \tilde {\tau }\lambda _{2}|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\rangle$ and $\langle \tilde {\tau }\lambda _{3}|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\rangle$, respectively, for $\ell _F/\eta =7.0$ and (d–f) show the corresponding quantities for $\ell _F/\eta =67.3$. The colour map is in linear scale, and the thick black lines represent the Vieillefosse tails. Note that average values greater/smaller than the largest/smallest value in the colour bar are clipped to the colour corresponding to largest/smallest value in the colour bar.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Average of the square of the vorticity components conditioned on the second and third principal invariants of the filtered velocity gradient tensor. Panels (a–c) show conditional averages $\left \langle (\tilde {\tau }\omega _1^{*})^2|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\right \rangle$, $\left \langle (\tilde {\tau }\omega _2^{*})^2|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\right \rangle$ and $\left \langle (\tilde {\tau }\omega _3^{*})^2|{\tilde {\tau }}^3 R, {\tilde {\tau }}^2 Q\right \rangle$, respectively, for $\ell _F/\eta =7.0$ and (d–f) show the corresponding quantities at $\ell _F/\eta =67.3$. The colour map is in $\log _{10}$ scale and the thick black lines represent the Vieillefosse tails. Note that average values greater/smaller than the largest/smallest value in the colour bar are clipped to the colour corresponding to largest/smallest value in the colour bar.

Figure 5

Figure 5.(a–c) Second moment of the components of the RE, pressure, viscous and sub-grid contributions to the strain-rate eigenframe rotation rate, together with the overall rotation rate. (d–f) The PDF of the square of the differences in the eigenvalues, which appear in the equation for the rotation rate of the eigenframe (2.10c).

Figure 6

Figure 6.Second moment of the contributions to the eigenframe rotation rate conditioned on the difference in the eigenvalues. Panels (a,c,e) correspond to $\ell _F/\eta = 7.0$ and (b,d,f) to $\ell _F/\eta = 209.4$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.(a–c) Second moment of the RE, pressure, viscous and sub-grid contributions to the vorticity tilting term, together with the second moment of the total vorticity tilting term. (d–f) The PDF of the vorticity tilting term in (2.12).

Figure 8

Figure 8.The PDF of the diagonal components of the pressure Hessian in the eigenframe normalized using scale-dependent time scale $\tilde {\tau }$. Panels (a,c,e) show results for the full pressure Hessian, and (b,d,f) are for the anisotropic part of the pressure Hessian.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Average of the diagonal components of the anisotropic pressure Hessian in the eigenframe conditioned on (a,c,e) the corresponding eigenvalues squared, and (b,d,f) the corresponding vorticity components squared. Insets highlight the results for small values of $\tilde {\tau }^2 {\lambda _i}^2$ and $\tilde {\tau }^2 {\omega _i^{*}}^2$.

Figure 10

Figure 10.(a,c,e) Average and (b,d,f) second moment of the diagonal components of the anisotropic pressure Hessian conditioned on the isotropic part of the filtered pressure Hessian (which is equal to $2/3$ times the second principal invariant of the velocity gradient $Q$), for various filtering lengths $\ell _F/\eta$. Insets in (a,c,e) highlight the results for small values of $2\tilde {\tau }^2 Q/3$.

Figure 11

Figure 11.The PDF of $s^*$ for (a) the anisotropic pressure Hessian, and (b) the strain rate. Dashed lines indicate the probability distribution for a random uncorrelated field.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Joint PDF of the dimensionless invariants $\zeta$ and $\chi$ of the pressure Hessian (defined in (4.10a,b)) at filtering lengths (a) $\ell _F/\eta = 7.0$, (b) $\ell _F/\eta = 14.8$, (c) $\ell _F/\eta = 31.6$ and (d) $\ell _F/\eta = 67.3$. Square markers correspond to two-component axisymmetric configurations, and diamond markers correspond to one-component configurations. The colours correspond to the values of the PDF, and the lines are isocontours of PDF shown in increments of 0.05 between 0 and 2. Note that PDF values greater/smaller than the largest/smallest value in the colour bar are clipped to the colour corresponding to largest/smallest value in the colour bar.

Figure 13

Figure 13.(a,c,e) Average of the diagonal components of the filtered viscous stress in the eigenframe conditioned on the corresponding eigenvalues (see (2.10b)), for various filtering lengths $\ell _F/\eta$. (b,d,f) Average of the anti-symmetric part of the viscous stress components in the eigenframe conditioned on the corresponding vorticity component (see (2.12)).

Figure 14

Figure 14.Correlation coefficient between the filtered strain rate and the symmetric part of the viscous stress, and between the filtered vorticity and the anti-symmetric part of the viscous stress. The correlation coefficient $\psi$ is shown as a function of the filtering length $\ell _F/\eta$.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Correlation coefficient, $\psi (X,Y)$ between (a) the sub-grid stress and pressure Hessian and between (b) the sub-grid stress and the symmetric part of the viscous stress, plotted as a function of the filtering length $\ell _F/\eta$.

Figure 16

Figure 16.Correlation coefficient, $\psi (X,Y)$, between the sub-grid contribution $-H_{i(i)}^{\tau *} \lambda _{(i)}$ and the strain self-amplification term $-\lambda _i^3$, and between the sub-grid contribution $-H_{i(i)}^{\tau *} \lambda _{(i)}$ and viscous stress contribution $-H_{i(i)}^{\nu *} \lambda _{(i)}$, plotted as a function of the filtering length $\ell _F/\eta$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.Correlation coefficient, $\psi (X,Y)$ between the sub-grid contribution $-\varOmega _i^{\tau *} \omega _{(i)}^{*}$ and the vortex-stretching term $\lambda _{(i)} {\omega _i^{*}}^2$, and between the sub-grid contribution $-\varOmega _i^{\tau *} \omega _{(i)}^{*}$ and the viscous stress contribution $-\varOmega _i^{\nu *} \omega _{(i)}^{*}$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Gaussian filter results of (a) average and (b) variance of the terms in (2.10b), normalized by the time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _f/\eta$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.

Figure 19

Figure 19.Gaussian filter results of (a) average and (b) variance of the terms in (4.2), normalized by the time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _f/\eta$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Gaussian filter results of correlation coefficient, $\psi (X,Y)$ between (a) the sub-grid stress and pressure Hessian and between (b) the sub-grid stress and the symmetric part of the viscous stress, plotted as a function of the filtering length $\ell _f/\eta$.

Figure 21

Figure 21.(a) Average and (b) variance of the terms in (2.10b), normalized by the time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _F/\eta$ for $Re_{\lambda } = 224$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.

Figure 22

Figure 22.(a) Average and (b) variance of the terms in (4.2), normalized by the time scale $\tilde {\tau }$, and plotted as a function of the filtering scale $\ell _F/\eta$ for $Re_{\lambda } = 224$. Different colours distinguish the various terms, while different line types and symbols refer to different components of those terms.