Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:46:58.451Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Experimental investigation of the three-dimensional flow structure around a pair of cubes immersed in the inner part of a turbulent channel flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 May 2021

Jian Gao
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N. Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
Karuna Agarwal
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N. Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
Joseph Katz*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N. Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: katz@jhu.edu

Abstract

The origin and evolution of the three-dimensional flow structures around a pair of roughness cubes embedded in the inner part of a turbulent channel flow (${\textit{Re}}_{\tau \infty }=2300$, where ${\textit{Re}}_{\tau \infty}$ is the friction Reynolds number of the incoming turbulent channel flow) are measured using microscopic dual-view tomographic holography. The cubes’ height, $a=1$ mm, corresponds to 91 wall units or 3.9 % of the half-channel height. They are aligned in the spanwise direction and separated by a, 1.5a and 2.5a. This paper focuses on the mean flow structure, and the data resolution allows detailed characterization of the open separated regions upstream, along the sides, on top of and behind the cubes, as well as measurements of wall shear stresses from velocity gradients. The flow features a horseshoe vortex, a vortical canopy engulfing each cube, a near wake arch-like vortex and multiple interacting streamwise vortices. Most of the boundary layer vorticity is entrained into the horseshoe vortex. The canopy, consisting of wall-normal vorticity to the sides, and spanwise vorticity on top of the cube, originates from the front surface. The streamwise vortices originate from realignment of the other components along the corners of the front surface. Merging of streamwise structures around and behind each cube causes formation of a large streamwise vortex rotating in the same direction as the inner horseshoe leg, with remnants of the outer leg under it. This merging occurs earlier and the entire flow structure becomes more asymmetric with decreasing spacing. Peaks and minima in the distributions of the wall shear stress are associated with the formation of and interactions among the near-wall vortices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The experimental set-up, including the channel, the pair of cubes with varying spacing mounted on the bottom wall and the local particle injection system. Adapted with permission from Gao & Katz (2018) © The Optical Society.

Figure 1

Table 1.Precise dimensions ($a_{ij}$) of and spacing ($\lambda _{i}$) between the cubes.

Figure 2

Figure 2.The M-DTH set-up consisting of two inclined microscopic inline holography systems, with the sample volume located in the region where the beams intersect. The three FOVs are shown on the bottom right. Adapted with permission from Gao & Katz (2018) © The Optical Society.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Characteristic primary flow structure around one of the cubes for $\lambda =2.5a$. (a) Iso-surface of $\varLambda _2=-$0.1$U^2_c/a^2$; and (b) vortex lines colour coded with the vorticity magnitude. (c–e) Selected in-plane streamlines: (c) $x$–$z$ plane at $y/a_{3y}=0.5$, (d) $x$–$y$ plane at $z/a_{3z}=-1.79$ and (e) $y$–$z$ plane at $x/a_{3x}=0.5$. Blue lines: contour of $\varLambda _2=-0.1U^2_c/a^2$ showing the intersections with the vortical canopy, arch-like and horseshoe vortices.

Figure 4

Figure 4.In-plane streamlines in a series of $x$–$z$ planes superimposed on colour contour of $\varOmega _ya/U_c$ for (a,d,g,j,m) $\lambda =1.0a$; (b,e,h,k,n) $\lambda =1.5a$; and (c,f,i,l,o) $\lambda =2.5a$. The planes are located at (a–c) $y/a=0.025$; (d–f) $y/a_{iy}=0.15$; (g–i) $y/a_{iy}=0.50$; (j–l) $y/a_{iy}=0.75$; (m–o) $y/a_{iy}=1.02$. The size of FOV in each column, represented by individual panel size, has been adjusted such that the cubes in each row are aligned and of the same size, to aid comparison among the three cases.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Streamlines in the $x$–$y$ mid-planes superimposed on the colour contour of (a,c,e) $\varOmega _za/U_c$ and (b,d, f) $U/U_c$. (a,b) $\lambda =1.0a$; (c,d) $\lambda =1.5a$; and (e, f) $\lambda =2.5a$. These mid-planes are located at (a,b) $z/a_{1z}=-0.96$; (c,d) $z/a_{2z}=-1.27$; (e, f) $z/a_{3z}=-1.79$. The size of FOV in each row, represented by individual panel size, has been adjusted such that the cubes in each column are aligned and of the same size, to aid comparison among the three cases.

Figure 6

Table 2.The scaled 3-D coordinates ($x/a_{ix}$, $y/a_{iy}$, $z/a_{iz}$) of the front surface stagnation point (ST), the centres of the cube surfaces ($C_{s}^{F}$, $C_{s}^{I}$, $C_{s}^{O}$ and $C_{s}^{T}$), the singular points marked in figures 4–6 as well as the streamwise extent of the separation regions in front of ($X_{sep}^{F}$) and behind ($X_{sep}^{A}$) the cube. The superscripts $F$, $I$, $O$, $T$, $A$ and $B$ refer to the front, inner, outer and top surfaces as well as the arch vortex, and the vicinity of the bottom wall, respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 6.The flow structure very close to the surfaces of the cube: streamlines in surface-parallel planes and velocity vectors in surface-normal mid-planes superimposed on colour contour of the streamwise velocity; (a–c) 15 $\mathrm {\mu }$m from the outer surface, (d–f) 15 $\mathrm {\mu }$m from the inner surface and (g–i) 20 $\mathrm {\mu }$m from the top surface. For (a,d,g) $\lambda =1.0a$, (b,e,h) $\lambda =1.5a$ and (c,f,i) $\lambda =2.5a$. The dash-dot lines correspond to $U=0$. The spanwise coordinates of the outer and inner surfaces ($z^{O}_i/a_{iz}$ and $z^{I}_i/a_{iz}$, respectively) are provided in table 2.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Selected 3-D streamlines, which are entrained into the open-type separation regions for $\lambda =2.5a$ along the cube's (a,d,g) inner side, (b,e,h) outer side (note the change in orientation) and (c,f,i) top. For (a–c) 3-D perspectives looking at the surface, (d–f) spanwise view and (g–i) top view. The streamlines are colour coded with the distance from the relevant surface.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Selected 3-D streamlines, which are entrained into the open-type separation region behind the cube for the $\lambda =2.5a$. (a) A 3-D perspective, (b) top view and (c) spanwise view. The streamlines are colour coded with the distance from the bottom wall.

Figure 10

Figure 9.A series of $y$–$z$ planes showing the distributions of $\varOmega _xa/U_c$ superimposed on $V$–$W$ vectors for (a,d,g,j,m,p,s) $\lambda =1.0a$, (b,e,h,k,n,q,t) $\lambda =1.5a$ and (c,f,i,l,o,r,u) $\lambda =2.5a$. The plane locations are $x/a_{ix}=$ (a–c) $-$0.24, (d–f) $-$0.06, (g–i) 0.04, (j–l) 0.24, (m–o) 0.48, (p–r) 0.90 and (s–u) 1.08. The increment between contour lines is 0.2. The 0-contour line is omitted for clarity. The size of FOV in each column, represented by individual panel size, has been adjusted such that the cubes in each row are aligned and of the same size, to aid comparison among the three cases.

Figure 11

Figure 10.A series of $y$–$z$ planes showing the distributions of $\varOmega _xa/U_c$ and in-plane velocity vectors highlighting the evolution of streamwise vortices behind the cubes for (a,d,g,j,m,p) $\lambda =1.0a$, (b,e,h,k,n,q) $\lambda =1.5a$ and (c,f,i,l,o,r) $\lambda =2.5a$. The planes are located at $x/a_{ix}=$ (a–c) 1.38, (d–f) 1.74, (g–i) 2.16, (j–l) 2.58 and (m–o) 3.78. Increment between contour lines is 0.1. The 0-contour line is omitted for clarity. (p–r) Corresponding smoothed iso-surfaces of $\varOmega _xa/U_c=\pm 0.16$ between and downstream of the cubes. The size of FOV in each column, represented by individual panel size, has been adjusted such that the cubes in each row are aligned and of the same size, to aid comparison among the three cases.

Figure 12

Figure 11.The structure of vorticity at $x/a_{2x}=-0.03$ for $\lambda =1.5a$. (a–c) Colour contours of (a) $\varOmega _x$, (b) $\varOmega _y$ and (c) $\varOmega _z$ superimposed on the in-plane streamlines. (d–f) Colour contours of vortex straining terms affecting the streamwise vorticity: (d) $\Omega_x \partial U/\partial x + \Omega_y \partial U/ \partial y + \Omega_z \partial U/ \partial z$, (e) $\Omega_y \partial U/ \partial y$ and ( f) $\Omega_z \partial U/ \partial z$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.The $x$–$y$ mid-plane for $\lambda =1.5a$, showing colour contours of vortex straining terms affecting $\varOmega _z$: (a) $\varOmega _x {\partial W}/{\partial x}+\varOmega _y{\partial W}/{\partial y}+\varOmega _z {\partial W}/{\partial z}$ and (b) $\varOmega _z {\partial W}/{\partial z}$, both superimposed on contour lines of $\varOmega _z$. Incremental difference between lines is $\varOmega _za/U_c$=0.5.

Figure 14

Figure 13.The $x$–$z$ mid-plane for $\lambda =1.5a$, showing colour contours of vortex straining terms affecting $\varOmega _y$: (a) $\varOmega _x {\partial V}/{\partial x}+\varOmega _y {\partial V}/{\partial y}+\varOmega _z {\partial V}/{\partial z}$ and (b) $\varOmega _y {\partial V}/{\partial y}$ both superimposed on contour lines of $\varOmega _y$. Incremental difference between lines is $\varOmega _ya/U_c=0.5$; solid lines: $\varOmega _y>0$; and dashed lines: $\varOmega _y<0$. (c) Contours of $\varOmega _y{\partial V}/{\partial y}$ superimposed on in-plane velocity vectors in a $y$–$z$ plane located at $x/a_{2x}=0.24$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.The structure of streamwise vorticity in the $x$–$z$ plane located at $y/a_{2y}=0.18$ for $\lambda =1.5a$: (a) colour contour of $\varOmega _x$ superimposed on the in-plane streamlines; and (b–e) the corresponding colour contours of vortex straining terms affecting $\varOmega _x$: (b) $\varOmega _x{\partial U}/{\partial x}+\varOmega _y{\partial U}/{\partial y}+\varOmega _z{\partial U}/{\partial z}$ superimposed on contour line of $\varOmega _x$; (c) $\varOmega _x{\partial U}/{\partial x}$ superimposed on contour line of $\varOmega _x$; (d) $\varOmega _y{\partial U}/{\partial y}$ superimposed on contour line of $\varOmega _y$; and (e) $\varOmega _z{\partial U}/{\partial z}$ superimposed on contour line of $\varOmega _z$.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Colour contours and contour lines of the distributions of (a–c) $\tau ^+_{xy}$, and (d–f) $\tau ^+_{yz}$ on the bottom wall. For (a,d) $\lambda =1.0a$, (b,e) $\lambda =1.5a$ and (c, f) $\lambda =2.5a$. Increment between lines is 0.3. Thick lines show the locations of maximum vorticity magnitude for black – $\varOmega _z$ in the horseshoe head, red – $\varOmega _x$ of the horseshoe legs and blue – $\varOmega _x$ of secondary streamwise vortices $B^{I}$ and $B^{O}$ in figure 9.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Colour contours and contour lines of $\tau ^+_{xy}$ on the bottom wall: (a–c) upstream, and (d–f) in and downstream of the gap between the cubes. For (a,d) $\lambda =1.0a$, (b,e) $\lambda =1.5a$ and (c, f) $\lambda =2.5a$. Increment between lines is 0.3. Purple line in (d) is the location of maximum magnitude of $\varOmega _x$ in the merged large pair of streamwise vortices.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Profiles of (a) $U^+$, and (b) $V^+$ at $x=-3a$, both at $z=0$ and in spanwise planes aligned with the cube centre.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Evolution of (a) $U/U_c$, and (b) $V/U_c$ profiles along $z=0$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.(a) The areas in the inner and outer sides of the cube used for evaluating the blockage. At $x<0$ and $x/a>1$, this area extends from the centre of the cube (black solid line), and at 0$\leq x/a\leq 1$, it extends outward from the side surface of the cube (black dashed line). (b–d) Axial profiles of (b) the streamwise bulk velocity, (c) wall-normal velocity averaged over the upper edge of the sample area (blue line in a) and (d) spanwise velocity averaged over the lateral edge of the sample area (red line in a). Here, $U'_b$ (${=}0.53U_c$) is the bulk velocity in the fully developed channel flow far upstream of the cubes calculated for the same area from data available in Zhang et al. (2017).