Tony (A. J.) Woodman's major contribution to scholarship on ancient historiography and poetry is fittingly honoured by this collection. An impressive array of contributors acknowledge Woodman's influence on their own scholarship, and offer a stimulating range of articles reflecting the range of his interests in ancient rhetoric, poetry and historiography. The four sections take their titles, of course, from works by Woodman, and there is ample evidence of the ‘friendship and esteem’ with which the work has been dedicated.
There is no full bibliography of Woodman's published works since, as the editors point out, his continued rate of publication would soon make it out of date. A more profound absence is a contribution from Ronald Martin, who collaborated with Woodman on commentaries on Tacitus' Annals and sadly died in 2008. His planned article on Cicero and Tacitus would have been an important addition on the rhetorical shaping of historiography, a theme that unites much of the collection. Woodman's scholarship is reflected in a wide range of methods he himself has employed such as structural analysis, running commentary, philology and textual criticism, and investigation of topoi and intertextuality. The book displays considerable agreement amongst its contributors, who present the fruits of research drawing on Woodman's literary understanding of history and historically contextualized readings of poetry.
In an appropriate gesture to an influential and active scholar, the collection places measured, methodical treatments of neglected subjects (such as Cairns's debunking of misconceptions about Rome's secret name and tutelary deity or Oakley's chapter — see below) alongside some more adventurous essays such as Wiseman's conjecture on the lost beginning of Velleius' history, Powell's interpretation of Juvenal's second satire, and Levene's postulation of the lost Pompeius Trogus as a source for Tacitus' perspective on monarchy in Roman history.
Part I, ‘Author and Audience’, opens with Moles's assessment of ‘Narrative and speech problems in Thucydides Book I’, which presents a huge range of interpretative possibilities, concluding that Thucydides is both ‘imperious’ in his endorsement of some aspects of Pericles' pro-war policy and willing to allow the reader to disagree with the text. The conclusion is not particularly surprising, but the article contains a wealth of useful detail and close readings, as do numerous others in this volume. Kraus analyses the structure of De Bello Gallico 7; occasionally the division of the text into sections is rather rigid, but the article productively unpacks the structural significance of topoi in the book's battle scenes. Chaplin raises a point about the morality of Livy's historiography: Scipio's actions in returning a captive to her fiancé are interpreted in terms of political rather than personal moral virtues. Chaplin's argument resonates with other work in the volume: Marincola, analysing Aeneid 12.926–52, writes: ‘Turnus’ putting on the spoils is anything but a “personal” action. For a Roman of the late Republic, schooled in the notion that wealth and empire had ruined the Roman state, the action of Turnus … could not help but call to mind the plundering that the Roman state itself had engaged in' (202). Wiseman's ‘Velleius mythistoricus’ boldly suggests that Velleius' history may have begun with Hercules' battle on the plain of Phlegra, venturing into terra incognita in its conclusion but providing valuable insights into Velleius' use of chronological markers and the overlap between myth and history.
Part II, ‘Quality and Pleasure’, is particularly varied. Chahoud discusses Cicero's conception of wit, usefully comparing De Oratore with the language of comedy and Lucilius' satire. A thorough piece of comparative criticism by Meyer traces the Thucydidean background to Sallust's letter of Pompey to the Senate (Hist. 2.98M). Oakley on the combat of the Horatii and Curiatii in Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus makes a good case for Dionysius being read more frequently as an elegant stylist and important representative of post-classical Greek historiography. Livy's excellence in dramatic narrative is emphasized. He observes the authors' different approaches to portraying the spectacle of combat (theatrical in Dionysius, amphitheatrical in Livy). West's running commentary on Amores 1.1–5 continues the attention to wit. Seager examines Ammianus' account of conflict between Rome and Persia in a.d. 357–9.
The task of elucidating literary texts through attention to their historical context comes to the fore in some of the articles in Part III, ‘Poetry and Politics’. Nelis approaches the difficult question of how to read the didaxis of the Georgics, emphasizing the importance of time and the progress of history in the poem: writing about farming comes to be inseparable from writing about contemporary history. Feeney successfully draws together evidence for traditions of paternal harshness among the Manlii Torquati to elucidate the pathos of Catullus' and Horace's addresses to some of the last generations of that family. A stimulating article by Powell suggests a reading of Juvenal's second satire that departs from recent attention to the sexual and gender-based invective, concentrating instead on legal terminology and suggesting it is an attack on delatores. It is interesting, in the light of Juvenal's determination to attack only the dead, to compare Cynthia Damon's observations (362). She suggests that Tacitus' vehement condemnation of Tiberius' encouragement of delatores may, like Juvenal 1.33–6, have meant flogging a dead horse, given the punishments meted out by Nerva and Trajan. Powell's and Damon's articles, however, invite further discussion of this ‘genus hominum publico exitio repertum et ne poenis quidem umquam satis coercitum’ (Ann. 4.30.3), still a live issue under Nerva, Trajan and Hadrian.
In Part IV, ‘Tacitus Reviewed’, Courtney suggests some textual emendations where he sees not Tacitean compression, but obscurity. Rutherford's treatment of ‘Voices of resistance’ traces the increasing complexity of the oratory encoding different points of view in Tacitus' Agricola and Histories. Ash provides a thorough reading of the bizarre mutiny of the Usipi in Agricola. Keitel draws together the various accounts of disasters in Tacitus' historical works, including fires, floods, earthquakes and the sacking of cities — showing in particular the continuing resonance of the sack of Troy. For Damon's contribution see above; an investigation of metaphors of the historian's presence in the events he describes, Damon's account is most compelling when she observes signs of Tacitus' identification with Tiberius. Pelling presents a nuanced treatment of focalization and points of view at Annals 4.37–8, drawing heavily on Martin's and Woodman's commentary on Annals 4, and referring to Woodman's influential article ‘Amateur dramatics at the court of Nero’. He points out complex layers of authorial comment, and reliable and unreliable statements by historical figures and groups, through which Tacitus denigrates Tiberius' character but also allows us to read some criticism as unjustified. Pelling's view of Tacitus' powerfully suggestive authorial voice combined knowingly with multi-layered historical judgements recalls, in elegant ring composition, Moles's approach to Thucydides in the first article of the collection.
