Based on an international symposium on welfare and colonialism hosted at the London School of Economics in March 2010, this seminar (and its subsequent edited volume) focused upon the dynamics of British imperialism and the impact of social welfare policies created within the diverse global regions shaped by this history of dispossession. While recognizing that imperial priorities lay firmly in the realms of governance, policing, trade and economic exploitation, the symposium nevertheless comparatively explored the uncoordinated and incremental ways that social services became introduced throughout Britain's overseas colonies from the eighteenth through to the twentieth century.
As a published reflection of this workshop, this edited volume ultimately considers how the new systems of hierarchical control established through Britain's imperial project not only impoverished many of these overseas societies (thereby creating increased demand for social services), but also generated new, persistent, and brutally enforced relations of class, racial and gendered inequality. Offering a rich comparative analysis of welfare policies across modern Commonwealth nations, the volume demonstrates how the creation of both processes and subjects of colonial domination historically unfolded as ‘an ugly affair’ (p. 4).
The volume is structurally organized into three sections: an introductory set of overview papers, a set of nine regionally specific chapters and a conclusion. All focus on the concept of ‘welfare’ as the provision of social services and security, rather than colonial health, immigration services or education. When taken together, they can be seen to question the extent to which social policies introduced during the British imperial period influenced the subsequent development of social welfare services within these post-colonial nations. In other words, the volume ultimately encourages the reader to question whether an enduring British imperial legacy can be seen through the policies and practices used to shape social welfare systems in Commonwealth countries today.
The first two chapters provide a summary overview of Britain's imperial history, focusing particularly on how a distinct geography of power enabled a centralization of political, economic and social resources through the spatial and cultural distancing of the colonial periphery. The first offers an insightful analysis of how ‘soft’ power was mobilized through the British liberal political identity to generate concepts of ‘improvement’ and ‘colonial duty’ within the global theatre of social welfare. Authored by one of the volume's editors, the second chapter offers a flavour of this new trans-national comparative approach by considering how the different historical agents (locals, missionaries, charities, colonial administrators and metropolitan officials) generated particular types of early colonial social welfare systems that were ultimately articulated within the broader scope of government provisions over the later twentieth century. The second part of this volume contains a series of powerful regional case studies that highlight the historical roots, growing political evolution and contemporary legacy of public policy and social welfare systems throughout the modern Commonwealth. Exploring issues ranging from the historic forms of racial enslavement that forged the background of social welfare within the Anglophone Caribbean, to the evolution of Australia's social welfare regime from a social right of citizenship to a neoliberal emphasis on voluntary schemes, to the complex tensions amid concepts of ‘caste’, ‘class’ and ‘citizen’ that formed broader social identities within post-independence India, to the influence of British colonialism on the historic organization of racial capitalism, social inequality and identity differentiations within South Africa's social welfare system, this volume is willing to explore and expose the darker aspects of Britain's imperial adventures. Given current and very public demonstrations over the meanings of citizenship and identity within Hong Kong, the chapter on Britain's ‘incremental’ (pp. 104–108) supply of social services within the former colony seemed particularly relevant.
While the volume offers an exceptionally valuable focus on the legal and social policy dimensions of British colonialism, the actual influence of these policies on the places and people of empire remains obscure. The public policies and welfare systems outlined in this volume helped create and sustain the radical transformations of everyday commodities, rural neighbourhoods, urban streetscapes, family relations and social relations that accompanied British imperialism. As this volume observes, ‘the changes that accompanied the colonial stage (though not necessarily imposed by it) brought as much social distress through change and disruption, intervention and non-intervention, as it brought economic improvements’ (p. 32). To understand why and how the hospitals, almshouses, orphanages, schools and housing estates came to adorn the civic landscapes of Commonwealth nations, we must critically unpick (as this volume powerfully does) the evolution of British social policies throughout these former territories. But without acknowledging the material legacies of imperialism – the actual places and objects that sustained such brutally visceral and ideological relations of colonial inequality – we are left to wonder about the lived human experiences of these deeply complex and ambivalent worlds.
