Shakespeare wrote Julius Caesar as he was concluding a series of four plays about English history, from Richard II to Henry V. Julius Caesar thus benefited not only from Shakespeare's close reading of Plutarch's Greek and Roman Lives but also from immersion in Holinshed's account of fratricidal struggles to acquire and maintain political power in England. Jan Blits emphasizes Shakespeare's interest in the Roman Republic (ix), but Shakespeare also wrote an early tragedy about the Roman Empire (Titus Andronicus), and among the four plays and one narrative poem he wrote about Rome, only Julius Caesar focuses on political power as distinctively as the English history plays do. Moreover, no Shakespearean tragedy so slights its title character: Caesar appears in the entirety of just one scene (2.2); he appears briefly in only two others (1.2 and 3.1); and he is killed early—in the eighth of the play's eighteen scenes. The ensuing struggle for power pits Caesar's assassins against Antony and Octavius, who are victorious in the end, though they share the play's concluding speech, anticipating the future deadly rivalry between them as well. These features of Julius Caesar have more in common with Shakespeare's history plays than with his tragedies.
As an accomplished classicist, as well as a Shakespearean, Blits has written extensively about all of Shakespeare's Roman works except Titus Andronicus, including two books on Julius Caesar. His notes refer to a wide range of classical authorities, and his book is a mine of information about ancient Rome. He observes, for example, that in Coriolanus Shakespeare acknowledges universal military obligation in the early republic by using the speech heading “Citizen,” whereas he identifies commoners with the names of particular trades in Julius Caesar, which is set during the late republic, when soldiering had become a distinct profession (2). Similarly, Blits observes that the word “city” appears frequently in Coriolanus but not once in Julius Caesar (35n29). Following the lead of Wolfgang Müller and John Velz, Blits details how longer speeches are organized according to the divisions of an oration as specified by Quintilian and others. He is very attentive to detail, observing, for example, that Caesar uses the word “friends” only once—and then in a highly ambiguous line (74n79).
Along with these very real strengths, Rome and the Spirit of Caesar has some eccentric features that limit its value and usefulness. First among them is Blits's decision to organize the book by focusing a chapter apiece on each of the play's five acts and by dividing each chapter into a scene-by-scene analysis that often proceeds line by line—a feature of his book on Coriolanus as well. This way of presenting material serves well the purpose of copious commentary, but it is a strategy that reduces argumentative focus and the book's overall coherence. Plot summary is virtually unavoidable with such a strategy, and Blits frequently succumbs to it, though plot summary in itself adds nothing to interpretation or analysis. Moreover, summary encourages redundant paraphrasing of quotations that need no addition to make them clear: “Antony tells the people to acquiesce in its happening with Caesar: ‘So let it be with Caesar’” (95).
Blits is not the first commentator on Julius Caesar, of course, and no writer works in isolation, so it is surprising how little others are acknowledged in Rome and the Spirit of Caesar. Even if the author depended largely on his own assiduous labor and impressive erudition, he joined a select community of scholars in publishing this book, and they deserve to be recognized. Blits acknowledges T. S. Dorsch's second Arden edition of Julius Caesar (1955), but he seems not to know John Dover Wilson's Cambridge edition (1949), A. R. Humphreys' Oxford edition (1994), or David Daniell's third Arden edition (1998). Blits faults M. W. MacCallum for insufficient knowledge of Roman history (xi–xii), but Blits's interest in “the spirit of Caesar” (a phrase from the play that Blits uses in his title) is anticipated by MacCallum's political focus on Caesar as “the spirit of Empire” and on Brutus as “the spirit of loyalty to duty” that embodies republican virtue. To be sure, MacCallum, writing in 1910, was critically superseded by the mid-twentieth century, as J. C. Maxwell pointed out in 1957, but historically MacCallum is the play's second serious critic after Samuel Johnson, and much subsequent criticism looks back to MacCallum, including Blits's. Among recent critics of the play, Paul Cantor and Geoffrey Miles have made many of the points that appear in Blits's book, though neither critic is acknowledged in it.
In short, this is a valuable but flawed contribution to the critical history of Julius Caesar. Its value lies principally in copious references to classical sources, which will prove to be useful to future editors of the play. Often, however, the sources display the author's erudition rather than Shakespeare's. Writing for a living as a shareholder in a busy acting company, Shakespeare quickly absorbed what he read, turning it into compelling characters and memorable verse. But he was not a scholar; he did not read widely on a given topic; he preferred a narrow range of sources and seldom compared them, because he didn't have to. His self-taught, learned contemporary Ben Jonson complained about Shakespeare's lack of reading in the classics (he had “small Latin and less Greek”) and mocked Shakespeare's occasional lapses. Jonson set the tone for neoclassical critics of Shakespeare, who faulted him on narrow grounds until Romantic criticism rediscovered his merits in the late eighteenth century. Blits also measures Shakespeare by classical standards, but accepting his reputation as a towering genius, Blits tends to attribute more erudition to a sixteenth-century playwright than history or the facts warrant.
