The past two decades have witnessed the flourishing of empirical and theoretical studies on the political teachings of Confucius and his disciples. Most of these studies have compared or contrasted the system of government early Confucians advocated with that of liberal democracy as practiced in the West. Theoretical works have, for example, sought to determine whether the fundamental principles of Confucian politics are compatible or convergent with those of Western liberal democracy. Empirical works, on the other hand, have sought to determine whether the cultural legacies of Confucianism discourage ordinary people from embracing democracy as the most favored system of government in East Asia. As a result, relatively little effort has been made to “reinterpret” the vision of classical Confucian politics and “reconstruct” it as a viable system of government.
Loubna El Amine's Classical Confucian Political Thought represents a systematic effort to reinterpret the gist of classical political Confucianism from the perspective of nonethical and nonideal theoretical perspectives. It also represents an original endeavor to differentiate Confucian politics from Confucian ethics by identifying political order as the ultimate end of Confucian government and respecifying its relationships with governmental and nongovernmental institutions. Through such efforts of conceptual reinterpretations and theoretical reconstructions, El Amine has attempted to fill lacunae in the literature on classical Confucian political thought.
What system of government did early Confucians advocate? What did they consider its ultimate end? What did they prescribe as an effective means to achieve that end? What specific roles did they recommend for the common people and their political leaders to play in the political process? And why? These are the central questions that El Amine explores with a comparative explication of three classical Confucian texts known as the Analects, Mencius, and the Xunzi. In addressing these questions, she employs a number of tools—conceptual, methodological, and theoretical—that contemporary political scientists have developed.
As contemporary political and social psychologists study human values, for example, El Amine conceptualizes Confucian values as two-dimensional phenomena—one dimension dealing with their preferences and the other with their priorities. Weighing the priorities early Confucians assigned to ethical and nonethical values, she identifies political order as the foundational concept of classical Confucian political thought. Accordingly, she proposes a nonethical notion of government, which aims to construct a well-ordered and well-supplied society known as datong shehui, not to build a nation of virtuous citizens.
Further, El Amine conceptualizes political order as a multilevel, developmental phenomenon evolving slowly from a basic level of minimizing conflicts between rulers and the ruled to a high or “exalted” level of maximizing cooperation and coordination between them (27). At the basic level, political order refers merely to maintaining peace and security. At the high level, it involves creating datong shehui, a fiduciary community of great harmony or unity in which people live in peace and happiness. El Amine's book treats each level in separation from the other. As a result, it offers little about the dynamics and sources of the transition from one level of political order to another.
What constitutes a basic level of political order? According to El Amine, early Confucians equated it merely with the absence of conflicts between rulers and the ruled. This is a thin conception of political order because it fails to take into account the conflicts that often take place among different groups of the ruled. More notably, it does not accord with a thick conception of order, which involves close cooperation among those groups. For such a thick conception, Confucians decreed the Golden Rule to promote harmonious interpersonal relations among the common people: “Do not do to others what you would not like them to do to you” (Analects 12:2; 15:24); “Try your best to treat others as you would wish to be treated yourself” (Mencius 7a:4).
What measures did early Confucians prescribe as an effective means of building a well-ordered and well-supplied society? El Amine contends that they did not endorse the inculcation of the common people in ren and other virtues. Instead, they recommended the institutional practices of rituals and filiality. Contrary to such an overly simplistic interpretation, Confucians did advocate use of those practices in the belief that they would serve as a necessary means of inculcating virtues, such as yi. This was also the reason why they emphasized the need for educating the masses as soon as their basic needs are met (Analects 13:9).
Theoretically, El Amine misspecifies the relationships among the three key variables of Confucian political order, including rituals, moral education, and political order. Contrary to her interpretation that Confucian rituals contribute directly to political order, those rituals should be viewed as having little direct impact on it because moral education intervenes between those two variables. Independently of those rituals, moreover, moral education shapes the behavior of the common people powerfully.
El Amine also offers incoherent accounts of Confucian political order. In discussing the relationship between rulers and the ruled, for example, she treats the “complementarity” or “fittingness” of their interests as a contributing factor for political order (43). At the same time, she describes the ruled as a mass with no distinct interests (44). Likewise, she points out that the ruled become orderly when the government provides for their welfare (51). Yet she holds that “the ruler derives his authority from establishing political order and not from fulfilling the needs or aspirations of the common people per se” (44).
Finally, it should be noted that in reconstructing classical Confucian political thought, El Amine often engages in selective observations and overgeneralizations, which are logically flawed. She makes little effort to highlight that early Confucians put forward a number of important concepts and theories widely practiced in contemporary political science. These include the notions of human nature, needs hierarchy, and political legitimacy and theories of congruence, institutional development, neomodernization, and socialization.
