People love conspiracy theories, particularly when it comes to early Christianity, hence the runaway success of works such as Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code. But despite the distortions and exaggerated claims such as Brown and others make, there is still a place for proper, informed, scholarly popularisation. Bart Ehrman is evidently a master of this genre, communicating complex ideas in an accurate, comprehensible and informative way, as the present volume demonstrates. But perhaps inevitably, a trace of the more sensational still clings to his book, and to the title in particular, with its hint of titanic struggles for orthodoxy and the deliberate suppression of opposing views. Perhaps in the end he too is in the grip of an over-romantic view of history and how competing faiths have behaved and still do towards each other.
His aim is clear and commendable: to catalogue the wide diversity of early Christianity and its sacred texts, tracing the emergence of what came to be the orthodox canon of the New Testament, but also considering the texts that did not make it, that in his words ‘came to be rejected, attacked, suppressed and destroyed’ (Preface, p. ix), and how one early Christian group established itself as dominant. In his Introduction he rightly points to the incredible diversity of early Christianity as compared to today, and the loss of that in the emergence of the one form that underlies all our present variety, the form that emerged in the second and third centuries. It was largely the discoveries of ancient texts in the course of the last century that helped to transform our traditional view – texts which, with others long forgotten, he wishes to consider in detail, asking how, when and why the New Testament canon emerged, what the opposing views were, what the strategies involved, and so on. He poses the intriguing question about what if another form of Christianity had prevailed, and speculates on the radical effect it might have had on the course of history since; we might all still have remained pagan polytheists!
His book is in three main parts: first ‘Forgeries and Discoveries’ (chapters 1–4), second ‘Heresies and Orthodoxies’ (chapters 5–7), and finally ‘Winners and Losers’ (chapters 8–12). In Part One he considers Serapion and the Gospel of Peter, the Acts of Paul and Thecla, the Coptic Gospel of New Testament works under the heading of pseudepigrapha, preferring to call all such works forgeries, and noting the ancient distaste for them. But in describing motives for their composition he rather overlooks the most obvious: they were written by Catholics to correct false interpretations. However he gives us a fascinating picture of these ancient forgeries, with illuminating detail, archaeological and other, on figures like Thecla and her long-lasting cult, suitably illustrated, adding such intriguing details as the discovery of a skeleton beside the jar containing the Nag Hammadi Library, and the casual revelation of an Israeli scholar that he had actually seen and handled the book in which Morton Smith found what he claimed was the fragment of a secret Gospel of Mark. Ehrman's own view on, for example, the Gospel of Thomas is that it presupposes a Gnostic perspective, while he rather sits on the fence regarding the genuineness of Morton Smith's secret Gospel.
Part Two deals helpfully with the major heresies up to the fourth century. Thus we have a valuable discussion of Paul and his Judaising opponents and of Ebionites and their polar opposites, the Marcionites, showing awareness of social as well as theological factors and admitting the unlikelihood of, for example, Marcionitism winning out, undermining his opening speculation. On Gnosticism, while well aware of the arguments raging about its definition and character, he is happy to continue to talk of it as a complex phenomenon with numerous manifestations, suggesting its origin in terms of a combination of Jewish and Middle Platonic ideas. Again, intriguingly, while allowing its attraction, he wonders whether it would ever have won out. He traces the history of what he dubs ‘proto-orthodoxy’, again drawing attention to its diversity within certain evolving parameters, from Ignatius (ignoring the recent debate about the genuineness of his correspondence and its dating), 1 Clement, Barnabas and Hermas via Hippolytus (no mention of Brent's major reassessment) to Tertullian and Origen and the beginnings of the doctrine of the Trinity.
Part Three deals in more detail with the strategies evolved by both winners and losers in the struggle for orthodoxy. He traces the classical view of orthodoxy as preceding heresy in writers such as Eusebius of Caesarea, pioneer of church history, and the increasing questioning of that view (Reimarus, Baur, Bauer), generally supporting the Bauer thesis on early Christian diversity, while seeking to answer the question that so perplexed Bauer: why then did one group achieve dominance? He suggests factors such as the appeal to antiquity, rejection of Jewish practices, stress on hierarchy and intercommunication, all involving texts. Hence the battle for supremacy was mainly a literary one. In considering the arsenal of the conflicts he usefully draws attention to polemics against proto-orthodoxy (Pseudo-Clementines, Gnostics) as well as for the heresiologists’ arguments, doubting the claims of Epiphanius about the sexual excesses of his heretical opponents. He then discusses the use of forgeries and falsifications by both sides, here acknowledging forgery for theological, anti-heretical purposes, with a useful section on proto-orthodox falsifications of New Testament texts and passages. His penultimate chapter traces the evolution of the canon of the New Testament through forces within and particularly outside proto-orthodoxy. His final chapter speculates again about what would have happened had proto-orthodoxy not won, acknowledging finally the crucial role played by the state, initiated by Constantine's conversion and the unlikelihood of alternative forms of Christianity being acceptable. He also notes that proto-orthodoxy never entirely won: elements of heresy survived even within an intolerant proto-orthodoxy, which itself became obsolete. Intolerance was crucial for the survival of proto-orthodoxy, but today's changed perspectives can mean pleasure and profit in the rediscovery of lost Christianities.
Ehrman's book is fascinating and illuminating, but suffers from the continuing assertion, for which no concrete evidence is supplied, that the proto-orthodox suppressed or destroyed the writings of their opponents. This weakness is allied to his almost exclusive focus on texts and overlooking of social factors and of the way religious groups actually develop and deal with one another. Proto-orthodoxy did not so much suppress as outgrow its rivals.
