This book is a delightful undertaking, a well-planned product of Thomas R. Metcalf's rich scholarly career. Following recent works of his such as An Imperial Vision: An Architecture and Britain's Raj (1989), Ideologies of the Raj (1995) and Forging the Raj: Essays on British India in the Heyday of Empire (2005), this new book, Imperial Connections, provides us with a fresh, even broader view of Indian history. Without a doubt the book is a great contribution not only to British imperial history but also modern Asian history.
The first point worthy of note is that the author advances historical research by dealing with the Indian Ocean region as a whole. Throughout the book, the structure and scope are carefully organized, as if to enable the reader to enjoy a smooth and relaxing round trip in the Indian Ocean, from Malaya through Mesopotamia to Africa. In general, recent studies have moved beyond the regular framework of Indian studies toward the development of a transnational historiography of the Indian Ocean as a regional unit. Metcalf is in tune with this research trend. Here he ushers in a new phase of Indian Ocean historiography by executing a detailed examination of its modern history, focusing upon the relatively short period of the turn of the twentieth century, i.e. the Crown period of the British Raj. This focus is well taken, since many previous studies already have taken up the early modern and/or much more broadly defined periods (such as those by Indian history specialists Kirti N. Chaudhuri, Ashin Das Gupta and Michael Pearson). Metcalf inherits the historical and geographical framework established by such early modern specialists: for example, the locations of Surat and Masulipatnam are pointed out in Map I of the Indian Ocean region, c. 1900 (pp. 10–11). These port cities have been chief objects of historical studies of the Indian Ocean concentrating on the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Although in Metcalf's book these old cities do not play prominent roles, such a map does suggest that he shares fundamental interests with early modern specialists.
Second, Metcalf attempts a new and unique holistic means by which to investigate Indian elements of the British Empire around this ocean region. His main purpose is to elucidate the expansion of Indian elements and Indian people beyond the Indian subcontinent, and then to show the distinguishing features of the British Empire during the decades in question. The author explores colonial Indian expansion in several aspects: the Code, institutions, architecture and, more concretely, Indian people as policemen, soldiers and labourers in the Indian Ocean realm of the British Empire. In this sense, Metcalf is making a contribution to British imperial history, but with an unmistakable shift in analytical perspective from Eurocentric to Indocentric. The author demonstrates that India was crucial in giving power to the British Empire in Asia and Africa. Still, labels such as Indocentric and Asian centric notwithstanding, the author in fact is quite even-handed in establishing his framework. He concentrates on the study of British history via an Indocentric perspective, which differentiates his approach from scholars such as Sugata Bose. This style may leave him vulnerable to criticism by more radically Indocentric historians.
The third point to note regards his excellent gathering of sources. Metcalf employs a methodology that attaches great importance to archival works, and less importance to previous secondary studies on individual countries and areas. He has collected a huge amount of colonial records from several archives, including the National Archives of the United Kingdom at Kew, National Archives of India in New Delhi and Kwazulu Natal Archives in Pietermaritzburg. The skilful combination of this huge volume of archival records with field trips around the region has enabled the author to succeed in constructing a new holistic perspective, an innovative format of the historiography of India in the period of the British Raj.
Nonetheless the book also evokes some misgivings, particularly when it is evaluated within the context of Asian history. First of all, although the book is an effort to locate around the Indian Ocean Indian elements and Indian people, the reader receives little information regarding the lives of the Indian people who left the subcontinent. The effect is as if the reader were looking down on Indian people from an airplane window while flying around the Indian Ocean – there seems no chance to meet these people for a face-to-face conversation. Furthermore, Metcalf shows very little of the conflicts and/or reconciliations that occurred between Indian immigrants and the region's other indigenous people; what might have furnished an in-road to a discussion of social development. This kind of analysis of conflicts and responses is a necessity for further holistic studies of the British Empire, as social change within the Empire is unquestionably tied to the British expansion in any given region.
The second misgiving I have relates to the underestimation of economic factors in Metcalf's historiography. As has come to be customary in his works, the author shows little interest in conducting sufficient economic analysis. Aside from a brief description of global economic conditions in the Conclusion, he does not discuss the economic background of several phenomena that he analyses. This tendency of his places him in sharp contrast with other historians working on the Indian Ocean. Metcalf is surely aware of previous studies on the Indian Ocean region during the early modern period, works that take not only economic factors but also cultural ones to be of the utmost importance, and so indeed relationships that link these categories. International trade and traders are often the prominent topic of these works. In Metcalf's historiography, however, political and ideological factors are the main concern.
The third concerns the way he has delineated geographical setting. The author does not take into consideration Indian components and Indian people in play outside of the British Empire. Much of the “informal empire”, as well as countries outside it such as Japan, had an increasing number of Indian residents, who were usually working as traders. To continue the observation I made above, if economic factors had been included in his analysis, an issue such as the significance of Indian people outside of the empire could have been broached naturally. But perhaps the author judiciously decided to forgo such a hugely ambitious exploration. Indeed, if all of these misgivings of mine had been given proper attention, it is unlikely that the book would have concluded at around 280 pages. In any case, his care to delimit the scope of the research, while in one sense a shortcoming, at the same time contributes to the success of a book in compact form.
In conclusion, it is true that the author recognizes some of these historiographical problems from the outset of his work, as demonstrated in his Introduction. So my criticisms may be off-target. Yet this book is sure to spur on counter-research by Asian-centric historians. In that sense, both Metcalf's contribution of an Indocentric view to the historical writing about the British Empire, and the possibility his project raises that Asian specialists will be given inspiration for further research, make strong grounds on which to recommend this book. All things considered, it is no exaggeration to say that the reader will enjoy this book, and no doubt look forward to the author's next.
