Peter Knight's Reading the Market: Genres of Financial Capitalism in Gilded Age America opens with a striking observation. In the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, “a tiny percentage of Americans” were actually invested in financial markets, and the financial sector constituted less than 5 percent of the U.S. economy (3). Yet in these same decades, “Americans began to spend an increasing amount of time thinking and reading about financial markets” (3). Reading the Market aims to explain this conundrum by exploring both “popular understanding of the market, as well as emerging as representational technologies produced by the market” (6). As a professor of American Studies at the University of Manchester, Knight employs theoretically informed close reading of selected case studies drawn from a source base that includes the enormous archive of late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century American print culture: literature, ephemera, and everything in-between.
As the word “genres” in the subtitle suggests, each of the five chapters of Reading the Market presents a genre-based case study. The first chapter examines how “market reports … helped create the very market they supposedly described” (21). This argument—that texts about the market formed the “abstract notion (and linguistic shorthand) of ‘the market’”—recurs throughout the book (11). To arrive at this conclusion in the first chapter, Knight compares market reports in a daily newspaper, a weekly magazine, and a rather nefarious “society magazine” (21). Part advice columns and part gossip columns, these market reports suggested that financial trading followed economic laws, yet price movements were often dependent on insider cliques or a personification of “the market as having moods, whims, and opinions” (56).
In the second chapter, Knight explores the connections between the broad range of how-to manuals designed to instruct and entice investors and the stock ticker's seemingly objective and purportedly democratizing reporting of data. Despite the Gilded Age development of “chartism,” or the practice of predicting future stock prices based on past prices, Knight finds that “reading the market” in this abstract form “continued to employ a rhetoric that presented the technology of the market, and the market itself, as if imbued with a humanlike agency that was decidedly irrational, uncanny, and supernatural” (60). This means that the new “scientific analysis” incorporated much from the preexisting folk elements of financial knowledge (61). Although in the early twentieth century, numbers and symbols transmitted over tape diminished the idea of the insider clique, human agency persisted in the form of a personified and anthropomorphized market.
From data points to drawings, visualization is the subject of third chapter, which finds new forms of both personification and abstraction at work in depicting the market. Knight highlights the cartoons that composed a “Financial Bestiary” complete with bears, bulls, lambs, and cephalopods (107). He explores the view from the visitors' gallery of the New York Stock Exchange, the contrast between images of panicked crowds and lone ticker readers, the choice of neoclassical architecture, and the modeling of price fluctuations through hydraulic contraptions. Ultimately, he argues that images of plotted lines basically replaced insider plots. But the idea of inside information did not vanish. Herman Melville's The Confidence-Man and the works of William Dean Howells and Edith Wharton support the fourth chapter's discussion of the larger meaning of literary plots relating to insider information. These novels, he suggests, underscore the era's moral equivocation and legal murkiness about “crony capitalism” (169).
The last chapter returns Knight to a subject of previous study: conspiracy theory. Reading cartoons, muckraking investigation documents, and Frank Norris's novel The Octopus, Knight demonstrates that, despite the acceptance of the concept of an abstract market, reformers hunted for the conspiracies of powerful individuals. J. P. Morgan and other titans of finance argued that their potentially unethical behavior was cooperation rather than collusion, control rather than conspiracy. Knight argues that historians, especially Richard Hofstadter and Alfred Chandler, have been too quick to dismiss the conspiracy theorists of the turn of the twentieth century as “delusional or misguided” (239). The reformers, he argues, “made the mistake of focusing solely on combatting illegal, formal collusion, when, in fact, it was the informal social ties and shared mores that were more important in oiling the machinery of business during this period” (239). The critics of finance might have been looking for individual human spiders, but according to Knight, they found a more interesting web composed of the class interest of the moneyed elite spun in the absence of regulation.
Knight argues that by studying all of these cultural productions, we can see the creation of “an abstract yet animated image of the market” that allowed for the obfuscation of the market's dependence on social relationships and government intervention (11). Knight's research suggests a fascinating irony: Gilded Age and Progressive Era Americans' acceptance of the concept of the impersonal market depended on its personification.
Reading the Market reflects Knight's extraordinary engagement with literary scholars, historians, philosophers, and cultural critics. In the process of writing this book, he brought many of these writers, myself included, together through the meetings of his Culture of the Market Network and the funding of the United Kingdom's Arts and Humanities Research Council. Jargon like “prosopopoeia,” a rhetorician's term, and “financescape,” an oft-repeated anthropologist's coinage, suggests both Knight's impressive engagement with this large and interdisciplinary scholarly literature, and that the intended audience for Reading the Market is these same scholars (21). As a historian, my methodology for explaining the conundrum at the heart of Reading the Market might be different. I might chart a clearer chronology of change over time or link these cultural changes more precisely to particular events. I might even have chosen a different gerund for the title, as few of the people in Reading the Market are actually reading; they are mostly writing.
Nevertheless, Knight's contribution in Reading the Market to the discussion of America's financial past is powerful and persuasive. His larger work of personalizing its academic genealogy will have a lasting effect on the future scholarly reading of the market's past.
