To put it into perspective, the principal of secularism in France must be positioned at the intersection of three cardinal pillars: freedom, citizenship and what has founded them historically and what embodies them: the Republic. These three closely intertwined pillars where each supports the other, allows individuals and the national community to flourish, move forward, build, and develop. If one of them breaks down, the whole edifice is destabilized and with it freedoms, including the freedom of worship.
This is why the principle of secularism is inherent in France's constitutional identity, and it is also the reason why secularism cannot be given a qualifying definition or description: calm, absolutist,Footnote 2 positive, negative, open, closed, inclusive, exclusive, accommodating, or “Gallicanism.” It also cannot be raised to the level of a ‘religion’ or an ‘ideal to be achieved’,Footnote 3 because it is neither spiritual in nature nor is it a virtue towards which a person might strive simply because secularism is a principle a principle of the organization of the State and more specifically a legal instrument to guarantee and protect freedoms, all freedoms ‘even religious freedoms’.Footnote 4
This is why the law of 9 December 1905 lays down the principle of secularism (without calling it as such)Footnote 5 as a fundamental condition for the freedom of conscienceFootnote 6 which is an absolute freedom which means that every member of society has the freedom to believe or not believe, to have or to refuse to have a religion (cultural, philosophic, ideological or political) to be skeptical with respect to religion, to be an atheist, indifferent or agnostic.Footnote 7
However, the reason why the principle of secularism is the subject of so many polemics, conceptions, interpretations, controversies and even confrontations is due to the critical scrutiny which it attracts (deliberate, self-serving or through ignorance). Everyone depending on his or her conception of freedom, political views, or ideological position for or against a particular cultural or political opinion, adjectivizes it to glorify it, or to accuse it of the most incongruous evils.Footnote 8
The purpose of this lecture is to demonstrate the simplicity and clarity of the principle of secularism in the light of France's painful journey towards a universalist conception of human rights,Footnote 9 as the only way to protect each and every one from community and/or social identity- based withdrawal, radical religious entryism, the overpowering influence of religion on thought and behavior, racial hatred and feeding all kinds of racialFootnote 10 and essentialist ideologies.Footnote 11
I. A French History Marked by Painful Struggles Towards a Universalist Law of Human Rights
The origin of innumerable debates around the principle of secularism and the Republic of France's attachment to the universality of human rights, lies in France's combat against a monarchy which exhorted the divine right of kings combining God in the person of the king, the State, and the law.
In this old world, there was no place for the independence of the individual or the State against religion. Religion, glorifying the omnipotence of the irrational and combining the sacred with the profane, imposed, by the nature of things, its own dogmas, its own morals, and its orders ! It was against this old world, where an individual could at best be favored or disadvantage by his or her membership or non-membership of a religionFootnote 12 that France succeeded in rationalizing power and the law. This was done firstly by the Revolution of 1789 and the constitutionalist period versus the fundamental laws of the kingdom,Footnote 13 and secondly by the law of 9 December 1905, which laid down the principle of the separation of church and state (article 2 of the law of 1905) whilst guaranteeing the freedom to worship ‘subject only to the restrictions enacted in the interests of public order’ (article 1 of the law of 1905).
However, this realization of the legal construction of a rational and universalist democracy was interlaced with tensions and religious wars. Therefore, to only take one of the most striking periods (which is directly connected with the fundamental place which secularism holds in French law): the 40 years of religious wars between Calvinists and CatholicsFootnote 14 which wreaked havoc in France, and which only ceased when Henry IV impose the Edict of Nantes in 1598.
The more virulent the ravages of irrationality (the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre of August 1572), the more urgent was the need to rationalize power and universalize the law.
Indeed, the repeal of the Edict of Nantes in 1685 by Louis XIV and the proclamation of Catholicism as the state religion with the re-sacralization of power,Footnote 15 only acted to revive an almost irreversible instinct of distrust of religions with their lot of dogmas and transcendent Truths notably when they combine with (or are part of a process of penetration into) the public sphere.
Secondly, World War Two, National Socialism, and the Vichy regime with their raft of oppressive laws and the destruction of human dignity in the name of predetermined criteria (of a racial or religious origin) completed the ‘French people's’ enlightenment to the essential nature of the universality of the rights of man and citizen. Therefore, to finally break with regimes that ‘have tried to enslave and degrade humanity’ that in 1946, the French people again proclaimed that ‘all human beings possess inalienable and sacred rights, irrespective of race, religion or belief.’Footnote 16 The Vichy regime (1940-1944) which was dissolved in on 19 August 1944 was therefore classified as a sad ‘constitutional hiatus’, rightly so because the Republic of France is now permanently indifferent to individual allegiances and convictions and now wishes to protect individuals equally before the law with equal dignity.
It is therefore in this context of a traumatic history of wars of all kinds Footnote 17 that French society is today observing, experiencing, conjecturing and confronting a violent ideologic-religious entryism, a communitarianism retrenchment as well as a new separatist and very active militantism based on ethnic originsFootnote 18 derived from an Anglo-American concept of multiculturalism and a ‘woke’,Footnote 19 cancel culture, racial, tribalist cultureFootnote 20 so foreign to the universalist culture of the rights of man and so harmful for the Republic of citizens.Footnote 21
Therefore, the only legal instrument which can confront what may be the harbinger of new dark hours of history is the principle of secularism. This is the only legal instrument which is capable of permitting individuals to emancipate themselves and the only one which is capable of enveloping citizens and protecting them in their rights … beyond and without regard to what they “are” (by birth, by choice, or by inclination).
To sum up the Republic, ‘indivisible secular, democratic and social’ (article 1-C), guarantees the prevalence of the general interest and public reason (legal)Footnote 22 over all kinds of individual interests or exaltation of ideologies, dogmas, or beliefs, especially religious. However they are in turn all protected (by the Republic), providing their practice does not interfere with public order is established by law.
I. The Principle of Secularism that Guarantees and Protects General Citizenship
Although citizenship is, in the words of the Conseil d'Etat, ‘the cement of Republican society and the point where the three principles of freedom, equality and fraternity converge’,Footnote 23 the principle of secularism is the guarantor of this, in that it is based, through its substance and purpose, on the prevalence of the general interest, reason and the law over individualism, personal convictions and other markedly entryist and therefore separatist identities.
In this respect, the principle of secularism, enshrined in Article 1 of the Constitution of 4 October 1958,Footnote 24 is binding on the State, which is therefore duty-bound to guarantee the Republican principles of freedom (including freedom of worship), equality and fraternity by promoting and protecting them. The corollary of this duty can only be the choice (alongside the neutrality of public services) of a universalist conception of human and citizens' rights, combating obscurantism and promoting the free will and autonomy of the individual in full possession of his or her life choices and own destiny as a human being and in compliance with the laws of the Republic.
France's choice of this model of society based on universalism is therefore a bulwark against communitarianism, the submission of citizens to laws other than those of the Republic and against discrimination (negative or positive) based on religious, ethnic, or ideological affiliation (or lack thereof).
The purpose or effect of France's choice of the principal of secularism must not be to compel the State to exercise an ‘active neutrality’, Footnote 25 that is, to engage in a posture of promoting the unfettered practice of religion. This display of active neutrality would be devastating for ‘living together’ and for the unity of the people. One only has to look at Lebanon to be convinced of this where the State is constitutionally bound to pay ‘homage to the Most High’,Footnote 26 to respect all religions and confessions and to guarantee and protect their unrestricted exercise. This posture which is engraved in the Lebanese constitutional marble has enabled religious groups to take control of State power and the civil status of citizens, who are legally, socially, and politically assigned to a given religion.
The same causes have the same effects and this posture of ‘active neutrality’ would only result in a retreat by the French Republic favoring, by accentuating, the entryism of fundamentalist and communitarianism ideologies and thereby destroying the unity of the Republic and the rights and freedoms of individuals. Furthermore, this entryism has been at work in French society since the 1980s.Footnote 27 This fact was related by the rector of the Grand Mosque of Paris, Chems-Eddine HAFI, when he highlighted ‘the ravages of radicalisation instrumentalization’ of the Muslim religion, and when he asserted that ‘the Islamist hatred is also targeted at Muslims […] who reject the deviation of the Islamic message’ and seek ‘the resources needed to block the route to what is […] harmful to their religion’.Footnote 28
This is why, under the principal of secularism, the state has a duty to intervene to ensure that the social contract stays on course.Footnote 29 Whilst preserving the active nature of its political independence in relation to religions, it is up to the legislator to fix the limits which have to be respected when exercising rights and freedomsFootnote 30 and for underlining the principle of the equality of all before the law, ‘when either protecting or punishing’.Footnote 31
Therefore, when confronted with individual (and individualistic) aspirations irrespective of their legitimacy and the legitimacy of their protection, the State must affirm that they, (the aspirations) cannot be intended to interfere with the principles of the social contract. Consequently, the protection of citizenship is not a choice but a duty of the State because this protection is a condition for freedoms, because it is a bulwark against any interference with the freedom of thought, opinion and expression and a condition for releasing individuals from the dogmas and all sorts of communitarianism and/or identity-related pressures which may pit them against one another.
Because when the citizen is considered to belong (or not to belong) to a religion, an ideology, or an ethnic group, he or she is inevitably ‘reduced’ to this membership, setting him or her apart and isolating him or her from his or her fellow human beings and erecting ideological walls between people by disregarding that which unites everyone: their universality.
The aggrandizement of highly individual (intuitu personae) identities also encourages conflict and can lead to the destruction of public power in favor of multiple powers and in the end to only one, the power which has succeeded in dominating consciences and imposing its dogmas … with or without resistance,Footnote 32 that is, getting up one morning and realizing that the other person is black, yellow, white, Catholic, Jewish, Muslim, or Buddhist and no longer my fellow human being in humanity and dignity!
The principal of the secularism of the State and its corollary, the neutrality of public services is therefore a formidable legal tool for protecting ‘man and the citizen’. It is the principle of secularism which protects the unity of the French people, and which positions the citizen as an individual before the law, ‘a subject and player in an institutional system’,Footnote 33 without the legal recognition of his or her differences. It is in this sense that article 1 of the Constitution of 1958 stipulates that the Republic «guarantees the equality of all citizens before the law without distinction of origin, race or religion»; and it is in this sense that the Republic ‘indivisible, secular, democratic and social’, respecting ‘all the beliefs’ (same article 1-C), is the guarantor of the freedoms which protect the metaphysical convictions of everyone and their unfettered practice without however raising them to the levels of the laws of the Republic and without permitting them to affect the public order established by the law. Therefore, the Constitutional Council (in its decision 2004-505 DC) reiterated that ‘no one can invoke his or her religious beliefs as a pretext for disregarding the common rules which govern the relationships between public bodies and private individuals’.
Secularism, a precious asset of the Republic is above all the foundation for citizenship, the dignity of the person and a condition for freedoms in that it prevents Caesar from believing that he is GodFootnote 34 and vice versa.
