Over half of the English migrants to the New World in the seventeenth century were indentured servants. These migrants entered alienable multi-year labor agreements preembarkation that would be executed on arrival in America. John Wareing focuses on the geographic and social origins of these migrants and on how the recruitment process in London worked during the late seventeenth century. Quantitative data are taken from the registration of indentured servants—3,543 that have survived for the years 1654–1660 in Bristol and 2,107 that have survived for the years 1683–1686 in London. The London data receive the most attention. Unquantified information is taken from London court cases on recruitment irregularities and from the political records on the oversight and control of the servant trade.
The quantitative data are presented in cross-tabulations. The London data sorted by recruiter and by recruiter’s occupation and social status are new additions to the literature. Other cross-tabulations, done anew here by the author, have been published previously by other scholars. The author also assesses the printed contract forms and legal requirements that affected the different contracts used in the London data that in turn affected the nature and amount of information recorded. While excellently done, some of these assessments have been previously published by other scholars. The presentation of the geographic origins and American destinations of the servants in the London data via maps overlaid with tiny pie charts is not easy to decipher.
The narrative presentation of the unquantified data from court cases and political debates dealing with the transatlantic servant trade is turgid, tedious, rambling, and repetitive. The author appears to tell the reader every court case, every newspaper story, every fictional account, and every political debate he encountered. That said, certain parts are informative and interesting, such as discussions of the servant recruiting ground in London known as the Tower Hamlets and the biography-like recounting of the activities of William Haveland—a major servant procurement agent. The author’s discussion of the evolution in the political oversight of the servant trade, namely the conflict between Crown patents and Parliamentary acts, and between relying on prosecution in court versus contract registration to deal with recruitment irregularities, is informative and a nice addition to the literature.
Economists will be disappointed in the author’s analysis of how the trade worked. Terms such as supply, demand, and profit are used in a casual and clueless manner. The nuances of contract structure and how that structure influenced contract breech are not addressed, nor are information and transaction costs adequately considered. For example, the author seems to assume that only criminals with premediated pretense of being servants would breech servant contracts. The author’s analytical framework is neo-Marxian categorization and opinion. The concepts of exploitation, greed, deception, force, and the commodification of labor are tossed around a lot. While the author frequently equivocates, he paints a dominant picture of servant recruiters and shippers being immoral, greedy, profit-driven, deceiving exploiters; and servants being mindless, duped, desperate sheep. The author sees most servants as exercising no choice over their American destinations and having no ability to negotiate terms in their contracts. Testable implications of this view are largely left unarticulated and unexplored. The author does note that most adult contracts were similar in length, which he interprets as proof that servants had no negotiating power. The author’s conclusion, however, implicitly assumes that information and transaction costs were zero which, of course, they were not.
Among the numerous stories the author recounts of forced recruitment, only one mentions servants being physically restrained pre-voyage. Among the numerous stories the author recounts of deceptive recruiting, only two indicate what the actual deceptions were—one being a would-be servant was promised some cakes if he went with the recruiter and the other being a would-be servant was supposedly told he would get an estate in America if he agreed to go as a servant. From the court cases of irregular recruitment, it is difficult to tell if the charges of kidnapping and deceptive recruiting are about that per se or about the would-be servant breeching a prior agreement with parents or employers. Uncertainty over who was legally liable when a would-be servant breeched a prior labor arrangement may have been at the heart of servant registration reforms—something the author does not adequately consider.
The author presents a new, four-category taxonomy of indentured servants based on how they were recruited and on the author’s opinion of the exploitation involved. From the least to the most exploited, they are consigned, redemptioner, exchange, and customary servants. Consigned servants negotiated directly with their colonial employers who were visiting England or with the employers’ agents in England. Their existence is more hypothesized than clearly identifiable in the London registration records. Redemptioner servants incurred debts for migration and sold themselves upon landing in America to repay those debts. Little information is provided on this category. Exchange servants received standard contracts and comprised most of the servants registered in the London records. Customary servants migrated with verbal agreements and were assigned standard contracts upon arrival by courts in America based on their adjudged age. They do not show up in the London servant registration records. This taxonomy is used throughout the book. The author, however, does not adequately consider the colonial laws regarding servant resale, the recruitment and marketing costs for consigned servants, and how life-cycle servitude in husbandry in England compared with customary indentured servant agreements. The relevance of the author’s taxonomy becomes less clear once these considerations are taken into account. The author provides new and interesting information on the recruitment of overseas servants in late seventeenth-century London. Understanding how that market worked, however, requires further study.
