This volume of fourteen essays highlights some of the most recent methods of exploring the fruitful interaction between ‘scholar’ and ‘craftsman’, a process taking place across many fields of knowledge and practice in early modern Europe. In fact the ‘Europe’ portrayed here is distinctly northern in character: about a third of the volume is devoted to the Low Countries (especially Holland), while England, Germany and France are also strongly represented. Within this geographical framework we find close attention to the analysis of ‘local’, indigenous forms of knowledge, an extended exploration of the history of the book, and strong emphasis on material culture as a source of new domains of scientific, medical and philosophical learning.
Editors Pamela H. Smith and Benjamin Schmidt have divided their book into three sections. The first comprises four studies about knowledge-making on the margins of ‘scientific’ endeavour, the second group of five chapters focuses on the practices of reading and writing and their long-term impact on cognitive functioning, and the third section (also five chapters) is devoted to the reformation of knowledge. An important theme running throughout is the impact of confessional divisions on European knowledge production. Essays which explicitly confront this issue include Lori Anne Ferrell's discussion of Timothy Bright's invention of a distinctively Puritan form of shorthand in the 1580s, Carina Johnson's account of the Counter-Reformation's impact on the classification of idolatrous statues in princely collections, and Jonathan Sheehan's study of the emergence of the anthropology of religion in late seventeenth-century England.
Other themes also emerge as significant. The opening chapter usefully introduces gender to the overall mix. Drawing on a wealth of archaeological and written evidence, Chandra Mukerji retells the story of the construction of the Canal du Midi in the Pyrenees during the late seventeenth century. She reveals the collaborative efforts of engineers and mainly female labourers, and in particular focuses on the women whose tacit knowledge of hydrodynamics proved essential to the project's success. Gender (and also race) plays a similarly fundamental role in Londa Schiebinger's essay on the global politics of botanical nomenclature in the eighteenth century. Whilst analysing the imperialistic naming practices most notoriously developed by Linnaeus, Schiebinger at the same time painstakingly assembles the fragmentary evidence for alternative European systems of nomenclature as well as more elusive naming practices in non-Western cultures. Gender also makes an appearance in Arianne Baggerman's survey of readers of J. F. Martinet's Catechism of the Natural World (Katechismus der Natuur, 5th edn, 1782–9). Remarkably, Baggerman has found evidence of children around 1800 who later vividly recalled the impact of this work on their mental life, including one Anna Staring whose own son testified to her passion for nature fostered by reading Martinet's encyclopedic work.
The geographic specificity of knowledge and its highly contingent nature is another important theme. In Part Two, Rudolf Dekker claims it is no coincidence that the symbiotic relationship between new timekeeping practices (the pendulum clock and spring-balance watch) and new forms of autobiographical writing (the diplomatic diary) emerged in one of the most densely urbanized regions of Europe. The inventor of the pendulum clock, Christiaan Huygens, and his journal-keeping brother, the diplomat Constantine, developed their respective methods of analysing time in a thriving commercial environment where effective management of time was at a premium. In the preceding essay Herman Pleij makes a similar connection between the self-conscious development of successful mercantile towns and the acceptance of novelty in their civic festivals as a positive rather than a negative attribute. These new urban values appeared in the late medieval and early modern period among a ‘nouveau riche’ nobility of ambitious merchants. As Claudia Swan shows, this was also a milieu in which the professional collection of naturalia around 1600 flourished on a scale previously unrecognized in accounts of early modern collecting. Moving into the eighteenth century, André Wakefield in the final chapter offers a comparative study of two newly founded universities (Göttingen and Freiburg) whose organization and teaching were determined by the larger fiscal systems of the states they represented.
Alongside essays devoted to larger social networks, this collection also includes case studies of individuals and families. Linda Seidel considers Jan van Eyck's Ghent Altarpiece (1436) as a visual manual of painterly skill and natural knowledge. Her essay is followed by Simon Werrett's account of the expertise of the Ruggieris in the contested field of pyrotechnic production. The Italian family's collaboration with Antoine Lavoisier and other chemists proves to have been an alternative to direct competition with French gunners and savants in the mid-eighteenth century, a strategy which led to a new alliance between pyrotechnics and the science of chemistry in the nineteenth. Other well-known individuals make their appearance: the Huygens family has already been mentioned, but we may also note the chapters on Robert Boyle and the Danish natural philosopher and physician Ole Worm. The first of these, by Scott Black, argues that Boyle's choice of genre for his ‘Proemial Essay’ (1661) was essential to his vision of a reformed methodology for the natural sciences, arguing that the essay required a form of reading that encouraged a habit of reflection indispensable to the new practice of natural philosophy. By way of comparison, Ole Peter Grell's cameo of Worm provides evidence for a long-term process of reflection that finally led to Worm's acceptance of William Harvey's theory of blood circulation. Ironically it took him fifteen years to come to this conclusion precisely because his approach to medicine was hands-on and practical rather than involving, in the way Harvey's discovery was actually made, calculation and inference.
A short review cannot do adequate justice to this kind of collaborative volume. Suffice to say that the contributions here are remarkably even in quality, with each contributor having something original to say about his or her chosen field. As such, this well-edited collection of essays makes a significant contribution to our growing understanding of the relationship between different techniques of acquiring knowledge about – and also asserting control over – the natural world in the early modern period.
