Eugene Park's new work, A Family of No Prominence: The Descendants of Pak Tŏkhwa and the Birth of Modern Korea, is a masterful contribution to the field of Korean studies. It is a work that reflects the digital age in which we live and how the current technology of research can have an impact on historical research and writing. The wide variety of sources pulled together by Park in the book is remarkable. I found myself thinking at several junctures, “how did he find that?”—and indeed, Park's work is innovative in its use of sources. The secret is the amount of material now available because of the digitization of archives in South Korea. Park takes full advantage of materials that would be difficult to research without computer indexing and makes discoveries that were surprising to him and likely will be so to the reader.
Park's voyage of discovery is a highly personal one: he is researching his own family line. And one key discovery—his great-grandfather as a palace guard—unlocks a series of documents that bear the story of not only his own ancestors, but a whole status group of Korean society that become the focus of the book—the overlooked chungin.
Looked down upon by the overlord yangban, the chungin have been largely ignored or misrepresented in histories, but now, thanks to Park's work, we have a fresh and accurate understanding of where the chungin fit into our understanding of Korea in the modernizing era of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Much of the narrative of the chungin, heretofore, has been distorted and inaccurate because of the bias of the histories written from the perspective of the yangban, but Park's work offers a new and much-needed perspective on and from the chungin.
Another valuable and much-needed contribution of this work concerns the value and use of chokpo—the traditional genealogical compilations so widely printed in Korea in the last four or five centuries. In spite of the work of Edward Wagner and Song June-ho in showing the historical value of chokpo, many historians still discount genealogies as reliable resources. Park shows how additions to genealogies, the heart of the problem as far as the critics of chokpo are concerned, can be discovered with the use of other documents, particularly older editions of the lineage genealogy. An additional line, however, in and of itself, is not evidence of purchasing one's way into a chokpo; sometimes remotely located lines of a clan can be excluded from an earlier edition, but added later. Park shows that there are cases of purchasing one's way into a genealogy, yet, through careful use of chokpo with other documents, he demonstrates a masterful way of using chokpo in historical research where chokpo can be used to illustrate a historical point, and can also be verified as to their authenticity or inauthenticity.
Another contribution of the text is the exploration of late modernization and how Korea's attempts at modernization, both before and after the Japanese intervention, had dramatic and diverse impacts on various social entities in Korea. For example, the chungin were both disadvantaged and advantaged by the Japanese government in Korea. It was not a uniform force that affected all of a certain class or category in the same way.
One interesting facet of the book is Park's weaving into the story of the Pak family, the relationship with other families, chungin and yangban. One of the affinal relationships involved the U family, and Park found that one of them was a military commander who was drawn into the plot to murder Queen Min (later Empress Myŏngsŏng), who was later assassinated in Japan, but who became the father of the famous botanist, U Changch'un, the developer of a variety of seedless watermelon. The narrative draws the reader in like a novel one cannot set down; readers will enjoy the many anecdotes and stories in the book.
In Korean studies, this is the second work that uses chokpo as the backbone of a historical narrative, the first being Hildi Kang's Family Lineage Records as a Resource for Korean History: A Case Study of the Thirty-Nine Generations of the Sinch’ŏn Kang Family (720 A.D. - 1955) (Lewiston, N.Y.: Edwin Mellen Press, 2007). Although quite different in scope and approach, both relied on the chokpo as the core resource to write history. Perhaps we are seeing the beginning of a trend that other researchers will join in; these personal histories as illustrations of national histories are valuable and interesting.
Park's work is highly readable and absorbing. It draws you in as he carefully takes you through the story, his own story, and how personalities became history.
