Reading this volume does not lead to the conclusion that the history of Ottoman Bosnia is in peril, as the book's title avers. Rather, the assembled eighteen contributions attest to lively, innovative scholarship in several languages, by specialists from many countries. The essays originated as papers at a conference held in June 2001 in Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina (called here “Bosnia”), organized by Noel Malcolm and Quintin Hoare on behalf of the Bosnian Institute of London. Although the essays share no common theme, each contributor builds on historical understanding by creatively exploiting some of the rich, highly diverse sources available to study the Ottoman era in Bosnia, which lasted from the 1450s to 1878. Interspersed among the essays are excerpts from conference discussions, in which participants comment upon one another's presentations, raise questions, and relate findings to other scholarship.
The conference was convened to highlight the state of research on Ottoman Bosnia in the aftermath of Serb nationalists' horrific destruction through bombardment of Sarajevo's Oriental Institute and its document collection in May 1992. The first several essays are suitably devoted to the institute's devastation and the valiant effort, led by Harvard University's Andràs Riedlmayer, to replicate some of the lost manuscripts by gathering microfilms and photocopies from researchers who had earlier consulted the institute's collections. Behija Zlatar, the highly respected director of the Oriental Institute for the past decade and an able scholar of early Ottoman Bosnia, writes of the institute's postwar recovery to become again a premier research institute concerned with Bosnia's Ottoman heritage. Under her leadership, associates of the institute have made repeated trips to Istanbul and other archival centers to gather copies of documents relevant to Bosnia. Despite the loss of unique original documents to shelling in 1992, institute associates have systematically reestablished a first-rate archive to support further research and writing on Ottoman Bosnia. Several contributors describe the rich holdings of other institutions in Sarajevo, particularly the Gazi Husrevbeg Library and the Bosniac Institute. One senses in these essays a new postwar urgency, particularly on the part of Bosnian scholars, to identify, gather, and preserve documents for the study of Ottoman Bosnia.
Several contributors demonstrate the value of census documents in tracking migration and population fluctuations during the four centuries of Ottoman rule in Bosnia. Drawing on population data for selected communities in Bulgaria and Greece, Machiel Kiel sheds light on the complex process of Islamization and the resulting fluctuations in Muslim and Christian populations. Kemal Karpat uses a wide variety of sources to show that fewer Muslims emigrated from Bosnia during Austro-Hungarian rule than previously believed. In an admirably creative application of routine court records to social history, Michael Hickok disputes the widespread view that the 18th century in Bosnia and Herzegovina was a time of anarchy and lawlessness, arguing instead from records of homicide investigations that the Ottoman authorities remained in charge and deeply concerned with security for both domestic and foreign merchants traveling in the empire.
Marcus Koller's introduction is an informative, richly documented summary of major disputes in historical interpretation of the period. Although failing in his stated intent to bring thematic unity to the volume, Koller offers a valuable overview of the major scholarship conducted by Bosnian scholars and foreign specialists since the Oriental Institute was established in 1950. His introduction helps make the volume lively and recommended reading for anyone interested in documentary sources and the state of historical research on Ottoman Bosnia.
Several contributors reinforce the impression that scholars are only beginning to transcend the language barriers to more comprehensive research on Ottoman Bosnia. Many Bosnian scholars now know Ottoman Turkish, but they often lack access to important comparative and theoretical studies in Western languages. Many Ottoman scholars in the West and Turkey, on the other hand, do not know a southern Slavic language and therefore lack access to the largest body of superior scholarship on Ottoman Bosnia.
Unfortunately, the volume contains an assessment of neither the documents lost in 1991 nor what Riedlmayer and his colleagues have hunted down and restored in copy. Perhaps it is just as well. In coming to symbolize the vulnerability of unique historical sources, the bombardment that burned those documents has ironically spurred further study of Ottoman Bosnia. The rejuvenation has produced benefits no less valuable than information contained in the lost documents. The contributors to this volume have produced a fitting retort to the nationalists who sordidly destroyed the Oriental Institute and its holdings in 1992.
