Comprising twenty-eight essays and including more than sixty photographs, The Routledge Companion to Puppetry and Material Performance aims to satisfy, at least partially, “a hunger for a more comprehensive investigation and articulation of the poetics of the puppet,” and the book's claim to be “the most expansive collection of English-language puppetry scholarship to date” (1) proves well-substantiated. Composed by well-known writers and practitioners in the field, the essays amply grapple with the intertwining of age-old, present-day, and future modes of the puppets’ being, exploring their resonance in our collective subconscious and the universal urge to use puppetry in myriad artistic manifestations, through the animation of figures, objects, and images.
The Companion has three parts. Part II, “New Dialogues with History and Tradition,” edited by Claudia Orenstein, is the most straightforward: descriptions of lively traditional forms of puppetry are paired with analyses of their practitioners’ determination not only to convey the historical value of these forms, but to effect their evolution so as to bring new meaning to the puppet show for a modern public. Tackling a variety of subjects, such as opera dei pupi, the bunraku, the wayang kulit, the tolpavakoothu, the vertep, and the Hyundai Puppet Theatre, most essays are invested in continuity and “reinvigoration” (218) in an age that seems to wish to dilute the religion and ritual from which all these shows sprang. Exceptions are Amber West's engaging account of the eighteenth-century protofeminist Charlotte Charke and Posner's explication of Russia's twentieth-century modernist “[r]edefinitions of the [p]uppet” (130), both revealing important aspects of puppet history in much less familiar contexts.
Part I, edited and introduced by John Bell, consists of theoretical approaches that offer insights of particular value. Stephen Kaplin's “The Eye of Light” is a poetic explication of shadow theatre and humankind's ancient beliefs in its cosmic significance. Essays by Basil Jones on movement as thought and the superfluity of words and by Eric Bass on visual dramaturgy remind us that the book is dealing with an art form for and of the eye, much more than of words. These essays are especially welcome, insofar as if I have a criticism of the book, it is that not enough evidence emerges on the essentials of scenic design and the fine arts in puppetry.
John Bell's “Playing with the Eternal Uncanny” goes to the nub of a perennial problem faced by puppet advocates, analyzing in depth the reason both for people's attraction to and repulsion by puppets. The essay points to modern so-called educated society's (willful?) ignorance of the art form and reluctance to betray what they consider to be uncivilized belief in the life within objects and materials: puppetry is viewed as a residue of primitive societies, presently acceptable only by and for children. The realization brings understanding of what Peter Schumann once called “‘the habitual lament of modern puppeteers about their low and ridiculous status’” (45) in the eyes of a public that deems itself cultured and yet knows little of the artistic brilliance of the said Schumann, of Boerwinkel, Bradshaw, Leith, Taymor, Twist, Kohler and Jones, Soehnle, and scores of others. I also enjoyed Jim Lasko's “The Third Thing” presenting the sociological meaning of public spaces transformed by performative masks, materials, and figures, rather than humans. Margaret Williams, in “The Death of ‘the Puppet’?”, contributes thoughts on the modern concept of “the puppet theatre” (18) separate from the theatre of impersonal objects, both part of a continuum that at some point separates the two but ends, Kleist-like, by coming “full circle to meet each other” (27). Paul Piris offers a profound survey of the puppet's “ontological ambiguity” (30), where he discusses the human actor performing onstage with an animated figure as a “co-presence” (31).
Part III, “Contemporary Investigations and Hybridizations,” opens with an absorbing introduction by Posner, who recalls the eternal magic of the oscillation of vision experienced by any spectator of a puppet show and the new “elasticity of [the puppet's] boundaries” (226), the difficulty of stamping it with any fixed definition. The first essays here are descriptive analyses of productions of the recent past that foregrounded puppets. Mark Sussman's “Notes on New Model Theatres” is an especially entertaining and perceptive essay about the relationship of adults as well as children to the extremes of scale in theatre. He proposes model theatre as “a genre at the intersection of puppetry and cinema, child and adult play, and the miniature and the larger-than-life” (273).
The final four pieces in Part III take the reader to more exotic, futuristic, and controversial realms. Cody Poulton writes on “Technology and the Human in Japanese Theatre,” quoting the roboticist Ishiguro Hiroshi, who claimed in 2010 that “‘androids can express themselves just as well as human actors … [and] that in theatre there is fundamentally no difference between a human and a robot’” (283). Poulton cites Basil Jones, cofounder of Handspring, returning to the contrasting opinion that puppetry “‘ignites a smoldering coal of ancient belief in us that there is life in stones, in rivers, in objects, in wood. I feel … we all left Africa believing in the life of things, as animists” (290). It follows that our ancestors would have believed without hesitation that a robot houses a spirit. Elizabeth Ann Jochum and Todd Murphey examine the new worlds of scientific experiment, including digital animation, robotic engineering, and their relationships to puppetry's more usual manifestations. This is the future, perhaps one that will capture the attention of the young and enterprising while saddening the traditionalists. In the last essay, “Return to the Mound,” Eleanor Margolies concentrates on transformation more than animation; she refers to eco-friendly performances that manipulate natural materials—clay, vegetables, and plants, all reusable or compostable—wherein the performers “[f]ar from aiming to ‘master’ the inanimate … ‘listen’ to their particular materials, sensing their physical properties and potential for movement or metaphorical deployment” (323).
The Companion provides fine nourishment, and whatever your interest in puppetry, it is essential reading.
