This book is essentially a collection of texts about gambling in Singapore and in Las Vegas. The texts are presented as being unified mainly by the theme of the architectural and spatial dimensions of gambling, as well as by the notion of the ‘taming of vice’. Other overarching concepts are ‘moral laundering’ and, in regard to Singapore, ‘progress without crisis’ and ‘nationalist modernity’.
The first chapter is about the definition of illegal gambling in colonial Singapore, which focuses on the premises of gambling (the ‘Common gambling house’) rather than the activity itself. We learn how this definition came about, how law enforcement used it, and how organisers of illegal gambling responded. The second and third chapters of the book investigate how this definition of gambling stood up to the alternate iterations of gambling in Singapore and the shifting views on gambling, brought about by modernisation and nation-building. For example, various forms of lotteries are described, such as those targeting children and housewives. There is a very interesting account and analysis of the role of small-scale gambling in the street economy, which is ethnographic in nature and to a large extent based on oral history. We gain an understanding of some of the factors and contexts that made gambling so prevalent among the Chinese in Singapore. The fourth chapter follows this development in a later phase, when a national lottery was established and Singapore began to consider building, at a central location, a huge integrated resort with a casino.
Chapters 5 and 6 are mainly about slot machines and casino architecture in Las Vegas. Much of this is already well known and has been analysed in similar ways. However, as the author points out, the specific profession of casino designer/architect has not received focused attention in the academic literature. Unfortunately, several of the floor plans of Las Vegas casinos reproduced in the book are of poor image quality and so reduced in size that only broad outlines can be discerned. The two chapters on Las Vegas, in particular the sections on slot machines, have only a tenuous relation to the Singapore parts of the book. Clearly, the Marina Bay Sands resort and casino, which was built by an American casino company, had to depart from its preference for a flashy and spectacular exterior and instead follow the requirements of Singaporean politicians that the casino should be inconspicuous. But that could have been covered in two pages rather than two chapters.
In the final empirical chapter, the author returns to Singapore, discussing and analysing in detail the process that led up to the decision, in 2006, to build the Marina Bay Sands integrated resort with its casino.
Although the author repeatedly stresses that this is not a historical study, the texts on Singapore range from colonial to post-colonial times, and in the final chapter to the plan for Marina Bay Sands. Part of this resort is pictured on the front cover: the iconic cantilevered platform of the ‘Sky Park’ spanning the three towers of the complex. It is an anti-climax for the reader that the book does not say much in particular about the architecture of Marina Bay Sands and what kinds of people, and in what numbers, have been coming to the casino to gamble since it opened for the public in April 2010.
The style of writing spans from meticulous renderings of detail, which are valuable for those interested in the topics covered, to advanced theoretical discussions and interpretations in a post-modern style, with little in between. The analytical approach is interpretative, influenced by post-modern icons, such as Baudrillard, Deleuze and Foucault, as well as more generally by the works of qualitative social scientists and historians. The author is well-versed in this literature, as well as in literature relating to nation-building and socio-cultural perspectives on gambling. However, the analysis and argumentation could have been more focused and effective, given text that is too often weighed down by verbiage and repetition.
To conclude, this study of gambling in colonial and post-colonial Singapore is a valuable contribution to gambling studies and Southeast Asian studies. The author refers to similar gambling scenes in other Southeast Asian settings, which make these parts of the book essential reading for scholars of this topic. Despite its quirks and shortcomings, the book is a welcome addition to the rather few texts — compared with all that has been written on the psychology of excessive gambling — that explore how gambling is embedded in historical, ideological and economic contexts.
