In The Science of Culture and the Phenomenology of Styles, Renato Barilli provides an innovative and insightful account of art history, one which is sure to provide readers with a new perspective on aesthetic development. Barilli’s project is to identify and examine “homologies”—a term which gestures towards equivalence rather than mere resemblance or mimesis—between developments in the realm of fine arts and contemporaneous technological advances. The task of rewriting (or, at least, reconceptualizing) the trajectory of Western art over the last five and a half centuries is a Herculean task, one which Barilli executes masterfully, without compromising readability for theoretical complexity.
The book’s project is outlined in the introduction, and several theorists who have informed Barilli’s work are discussed. Chief among these are Lucien Goldmann, Heinrich Wölfflin and Marshall McLuhan, whose book, The Gutenberg Galaxy, is frequently referenced. The introduction closes with a brief mention of the historical periods that Barilli focuses on: modern and contemporary.
The first three chapters of the book introduce Barilli’s ideas, gradually narrowing the scope of discussion so as to provide an overview on the concepts with which he works and the connections between them. The second half of the book applies these theoretical tools to the analysis of the development of Western art from 1450 to the present. This method of organization increases the approachability of the subjects broached in The Science of Culture and the Phenomenology of Styles, ensuring that a firm theoretical foundation is built before substantive analysis and discussion take place.
The first chapter is primarily focused on delivering etymologies and robust definitions of the terms “style”, “phenomenology” and “culture”. Here, the author differentiates between the material or low stratum, and the ideal or high stratum, of culture. The former pertains to technical practices, while the latter refers to conceptual developments that underpin all kinds of activities, including but not limited to, artistic creation. Though distinct, the two strata are subsumed under the umbrella of culture, and Barilli illustrates how they interact with each other.
This leads to discussion of the different kinds of relationships that can obtain between the two strata. Of particular interest are vertical relationships, wherein the notion of a homology is introduced: a description of the connection between the two different strata, with specific focus on how the art of a given historical period can be understood to connect with contemporaneous technological advances. Barilli is careful to note that this does not suggest a literal representation of technology via art, but rather, that art is rendered in the visual language and logic of dominant technologies. This process is assigned the term “technomorphism”. The second chapter looks more closely at the high stratum, as the origins and development of the term “fine arts” are discussed. The balance or interplay of the two strata is also examined. The third chapter narrows the scope of analysis, coming to focus on a specific portion of the ideal stratum: the visual arts. Variations can be found within a single realm of the high or low stratum, which is referred to as an internal relationship. Thus, the central focus of the book is set upon, namely, the examination of internal relationships of artistic movements within the high stratum in order to determine how these relate to developments in the material stratum.
The modern period—which, for Barilli, begins in 1450 with the invention of the printing press—is the focus of the fourth chapter. It is noted that Johannes Gutenberg’s accomplishments are nearly simultaneous with the publication of Leon Battista Alberti’s revolutionary On Painting, which utilizes optics and mathematics to impose an imaginary grid over the picture plane, thereby establishing foundational aesthetic concepts such as perspective and vanishing points. The remainder of the fourth chapter is dedicated to tracing the modern period with the aim of determining how to understand the internal developments within the artistic sphere. Giorgio Vasari’s classification of Renaissance artists is examined, and in one of the most enlightening passages of the book, Barilli likens the status of Leonardo da Vinci to that of Paul Cezanne—both artists, he argues, were transitional figures whose work was, at the time, only partially accepted.
The penultimate chapter begins with discussion of when, chronologically, to locate the birth of the contemporary age. Barilli concludes that the frequently cited year of 1789 fails to conform with the homological analysis he is conducting, and determines that 1860 is a more appropriate date. The years between these dates are transitionary, and the work of significant artists within this period is considered. Around the middle of the nineteenth century, Barilli finds technology and culture finally aligning with each other. The development of electromagnetism coincides with the work of post-Impressionist artists such as Cezanne and Paul Gauguin, who reject the dominance of Alberti’s perspectival science. The historical avant-gardes, as well as the art of the latter half of the twentieth century, is discussed. The closing chapter offers a closer look at Wölfflin’s theories. After an exposition of his ideas, Barilli notes that Woolflin’s analysis may not address all facets of the complicated internal relationships to be found within the art of an epoch, but concludes that his ideas provide the foundation for others—presumably Barilli himself—to do so.
The current English translation of The Science of Culture and the Phenomenology of Styles arrives nearly thirty years after the original Italian publication. In view of demonstrating how the ideas of the book figure currently, a brief postscript examines their application to artistic developments that have occurred since the original publication. Barilli discusses how McLuhan’s notion of the global village is more relevant than ever, noting that it has opened Western artistic practice to new traditions and tendencies.
Barilli’s work offers a thought-provoking and dynamic approach to the study of art history, and encourages readers to reconsider some long-held assumptions about the way in which artistic production develops over time. The Science of Culture and Phenomenology of Styles is a supremely enjoyable book, sure to please leisure readers as well as provide a valuable resource for those who are conducting research.
