In February 2006 Claire Bishop published her influential essay “The Social Turn: Collaboration and Its Discontents” in Artforum; in this essay, she identifies a “social turn” in contemporary art practice, and claims it evidences a “recent surge of artistic interest in collectivity, collaboration, and direct engagement with specific social constituencies” (178). In her latest publication, Artificial Hells, Bishop suggests that “this development should be positioned more accurately as a return to the social, part of an ongoing history of attempts to rethink art collectively” (3). She responds to it in her book by charting a (primarily European) twentieth-century history of “participatory art” practice, attending particularly to its evolving politics.
Artificial Hells is split into nine chapters. The first provides a theoretical framework for the book as a whole. This chapter is an updated version of her Artforum article in which she advocates two primary critical positions: first, she argues against a treatment of aesthetics as being “synonymous with the market and conservative cultural hierarchy,” favoring instead a rehabilitation of aesthetics as “an autonomous regime of experience that is not reducible to logic, reason or morality” (18); second, she is highly skeptical toward the “social task” of participatory projects as an implicitly important gesture of resistance, preferring instead a critical evaluation of participatory art “as art” (13; her emphasis). This latter rehearses an opposition to the likes of Nicolas Bourriaud that will be familiar to readers of Bishop's other publications. But where the first chapter gains renewed interest in relation to its Artforum predecessor is through a more detailed discussion of Jacques Rancière's work as a means of theorizing participatory art. Bishop redoubles Rancière's claims that “good art,” firstly, “must negotiate the tension” between integrating life and art and “separat[ing] aesthetic sensoriality from other forms of sensible experience” (29–30); in adopting “Rancière's idea of art as an autonomous realm of experience,” Bishop provides space to historicize participation “as a constantly moving target” (30).
The chapters that follow build on this theoretical framework, each responding to a particular period and place framed as being noteworthy for the metamorphosing face of participatory art throughout the twentieth century. These chapters engage with some familiar points of reference, framed as a “counter-history” to “North American critics writing on North American art” (5): Italian futurism, Paris dada, the Situationist International (SI), Augusto Boal's work in Brazil (part of a rare venture away from Eurocentrism), the Artist Placement Group, Joseph Beuys, and—favorites of Bishop—Thomas Hirschhorn and Christoph Schlingensief. But Bishop also engages with less familiar territory: Prolekult theatre in the wake of the 1917 Russian Revolution; artists and movements contemporaneous with, but independent from, the SI (such as Groupe Recherche d'Art Visuel [GRAV] and Jean-Jacques Lebel); and Czechoslovakian artists promoting participatory art under state socialism in the 1960s and 1970s (which refreshingly highlights occasions where individual over collective freedoms are apt to be supported). This list is, of course, selective, but it indicates the breadth of research demonstrated by Bishop, rendering this book as much a useful archival resource as a means of illustrating a New Historicist account of participation in artistic practice over the past century.
Balanced against the strength of historicizing participation in this way, however, is the paradoxical drawback of rendering a participatory history as seemingly causative. Bishop orders her case studies chronologically, and occasionally claims that fairly isolated events, such as exhibitions by Kasper König and Jan Hoet, “paved the way” for particular shifts in the development of participatory art (195)—as if a multifarious set of contributions were not profoundly influential. There is also Bishop's observation that “the audience” evolved through three stages in the twentieth century, from demanding a role in the early avant-gardes, to “enjoy[ing] its subordination to strange experiences devised for them by an artist, to an audience that is encouraged to be a co-producer of the work” (277). However, it seems to me that while attempts to render audiences as coproducers might have become more pronounced (an observation rightly critiqued by Bishop), the rise of audiences, particularly theatre audiences, that seem to hanker after “subordination to strange experiences” has also been on the rise; the increasing popularity of immersive and one-on-one theatre, not to mention installation art, is illustrative.
However, both criticisms should be set against numerous attempts elsewhere in the book to account for more dispersed sociopolitical pressures affecting participatory art practice. Bishop's interrogation of U.K. politics in the New Labour years, as exerting influence over participatory ideology in the arts, is one such example. Accountability and inclusion became buzzwords that, Bishop suggests, bled into the logic of participation championed through New Labourite rhetoric (13–14). She also proposes that this has accelerated under David Cameron's “Big Society” vision of volunteerism (14). Additionally, although participatory art might be seen to stand against neoliberal agendas in opposing individualism and the fetishized commodity, she writes, there exists a failure to recognize “that so many other aspects of this art practice dovetail even more perfectly with neoliberalism's recent forms” (277). This observation is valuable not only for its insightfulness, but also for its sobering urgency.
Bishop is fairly insistent on pushing theatre as the “lens” through which her history of participatory art might be read (3); what is surprising, then, is the scarcity of “lenses” drawn from theatre and performance studies that might have nuanced her otherwise praiseworthy points about spectatorship and participation. Other than passing references to Peggy Phelan (37) and Richard Schechner (89), both the art and theatre practices on which she draws remain the concern of an art historian. This is acceptable, even expected, particularly given that this is a book on “participatory art” and not “participatory theatre”; but given her recognition that the theatre, like other modes of performance, has “long-established codes for experiencing a performer's relationship to labour” (232), it seems surprising that the wealth of material unpacking such codes in theatre and performance discourse is largely avoided. This, however, is not to devalue this book as a rich repository for theatre and performance researchers interested in the study of audience participation. Artificial Hells is refreshingly skeptical, well researched, and admirably theorized.
