In the second half of the eighteenth century, many European cabinets of curiosities collected by traders and travellers were displayed in museums such as the British Museum (1753–1759) and the Louvre (1793) to educate and entertain the public.Footnote 1 By the 1860s museums were centres of scientific culture in major western cities. The concept had also been exported to Asia by European traders and missionaries. This article deals with the first modern museum in China, founded by three East India Company (EIC) supercargoes in Macao, an enclave in the Pearl River Delta where the Portuguese had been allowed to establish a base at around 1557. The Chinese authorities delegated the city's administration to the Portuguese, who were in charge of all matters relating to foreigners.Footnote 2 As we shall see, the EIC established direct trade with China in 1700 and its supercargoes, forbidden to stay in China after their business was finished, resided in Macao during the spring and summer months, between the Canton trading seasons, rather than returning to Europe. As Portuguese, American and British sources show, anglophone traders collected natural specimens in and around Macao and Canton during their leisure time and sent them to western museums and universities,Footnote 3 contributing to the development of natural science.
The first museum founded in China by a Chinese was the Nantong Museum, in Jiangsu, established by philanthropist Zhang Jian in 1905, and one of its main objectives was to teach Chinese visitors the concepts of evolution and historical progress through its displays.Footnote 4 Studies on Chinese museum historyFootnote 5 usually identify the French Jesuit Pierre Marie Heude (1836–1902) as the founder, in 1868, of the first modern museum in China, the Zhendan Museum, a natural history museum originally known as the Zikawei Museum due to its location on the western outskirts of Shanghai's French concession. Before that, the British government of Hong Kong had also set up a small display of “cultural things” around 1855.Footnote 6 In 1872 the North China branch of the Royal Asiatic Society founded a museum in Shanghai, while in 1887 another western missionary, J. S. Whitewright of the British Baptist Mission, founded a museum in Qingzhou.Footnote 7 British efforts were instrumental in the development of modern museums in China, from Shanghai to Macao, but the latter city has been ignored by most, if not all, studies on early Chinese museums.Footnote 8 As we shall see, the Shanghai Museum, founded by Pierre Heude, was not the first museum to open its doors in China, as anglophone sources reveal that in 1829 three EIC supercargoes founded a museum in Macao, which remained open for five years until the end of the Company's monopoly in China in 1834.
Since the middle of the sixteenth century, the cultural and economical life of Sino-Portuguese Macao has been greatly enriched by the presence of a vast array of eastern and western communities – from the lusophone and anglophone to the francophone, Japanese, African, Malay, Parsee, Armenian and other temporary or long-term residents. The English traders arrived in 1700, when the EIC established direct trade with Canton,Footnote 9 and the anglophone presence grew in the city until the founding of Hong Kong and the signing of the Nanking Treaty. For almost 150 years British and American traders, travellers, missionaries and diplomats used Macao as their home and as a “decompression chamber” in China. In 1831 the Canton Miscellany noted some of the British cultural initiatives in the city, namely the EIC's Library (1806–1834),Footnote 10 and the Natural History Museum as an innovative local scientific endeavour:
Macao also owes to the philanthropic feelings of the Members of the Honourable British Company, an Institution, which has and will spread useful knowledge among the inhabitants. We allude to a Library which began in 1806, and contains already at least four thousand volumes in various languages, but principally in the English. . .Another interesting establishment was founded two years ago, by young English Amateurs of Natural History. The Museum which then began is progressing, and posterity will no doubt have to thank it for many rare specimens of Nature's produce and marvels. Were Lectures on: Experimental Philosophy added to the preceding resources of mental improvement, the inquisitive spirit in our days would be, we presume, fully gratified. Cannot the qualification of a Lecturer in that scientific branch, be united with those of a Clergyman who presides over the English Chapel at Macao?Footnote 11
As I said before, the EIC's supercargoes spent half of the year in Macau, and in the late eighteenth century the wives and children of some of the anglophone traders moved to the Luso-Chinese city, changing the way the exclusively male community had lived up to then. The supercargoes were themselves a source of discontent for the Portuguese authorities when EIC and private vessels sailed or anchored along the city's coastline, and traders removed plants and stones from the coast, an activity reported in the British press.Footnote 12 Merchants and chaplains who were also (amateur) naturalists sent specimens of fauna and flora from Macao back to Europe, contributing to the study of Asian botany, geology and zoology. The botanical collecting and natural history endeavour were part of the scientific British enterprise which has recently been associated with the nation's imperial project.Footnote 13 Specimens were also collected around the Canton foreign factories and along the Pearl River Delta, but foreigners enjoyed greater freedom in Macao. One can conclude that the Sino-Portuguese enclave served as a safe port and work platform where specimens could be collected by traders and members of western scientific expeditions.Footnote 14 Rocks, fossils, plants and animals were sent to the West regularly, as well as drawings and descriptions of deformed human beings, like the one in the Catalogue of the Contents of the Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons in London, Parts 5 and 6: The Preparations of Monsters and Malformed Parts, in Spirits, and in a Dried State, published in 1831. Section 323 quotes a description written in 1820 by John Livingstone, surgeon of the EIC, of “A-Ke, a Chinese monster, born in the district of Yunlang-yuen. . .in the year 1804”, of whom a clay model was presented to the Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1822, by L. Thomas:
The male “monster” lived in Macao for a while, in a temporary enclosure near St. Agostinho's churchFootnote 15 . . .A-ke was born sixteen years [ago]. . .with another male child of nearly the same size united to the pit of his stomach by the neck, as if his brother had plunged its head into his breast. The skin of the principal here joins that of the upper part of the neck of the parasite, quite regularly and smoothly. . .The sufferings of the mother were so great that she survived the birth of this monster only two days. Since the time, the parasite has not much increased in size.Footnote 16
Three British amateur naturalists, John Reeves (1774–1856), the Reverend George Vachell (1798–1834) and John Russell Reeves (1804–1877), sent several specimens to London from Macao between the 1820s and the 1840s, and their activities were acknowledged by several scientific publications: “Specimens in good order have been deposited in the British Museum and with the Cambridge Philosophical Society by John Reeves, Esq., and the Rev. George Vachell. . .Macao”, or “A specimen in the British Museum, from John Reeves”.Footnote 17 Other publications, such as An Historical and Descriptive Account of China (1836, Chapter 6 “Botany”), mention the many drawings in possession of the EIC and the collections organised by Mr Reeves in Canton and Macao, as well as his contributions to the collections of the Museum of the Royal College of Physicians.Footnote 18 In the 1820s and 1830s Charles Millett,Footnote 19 superintendent of exports for the EIC who studied Chinese with Dr Robert Morrison (1796–1879)Footnote 20 and after whom the flower Millettia was named,Footnote 21 also gathered plant specimens near Macao that he sent to London.Footnote 22
The intense scientific activity of permanent residents, their travels to other parts of Asia from Macao and the activity of members of scientific expeditionsFootnote 23 led to the accumulation of specimens and other natural curiosities in the enclave, where a “British Museum in China” was founded during a meeting of three EIC supercargoes on 22 February 1829. The permanent exhibition was a smaller version of similar displays in Europe and was advertised as a natural history and science museum in the Canton Register (2 March 1830), a year after it was founded by British Macao-Canton residents who had a lot of free time on their hands. The supercargoes established the museum on a voluntary basis, and the EIC was not officially involved in the process. One of the museum's founders was the previously mentioned John Russell Reeves. His father was the naturalist John Reeves, who had been inspector of teas for the EIC in Canton between 1812 and 1831, collected several fish and plant specimens for the British Museum (London) and who wrote about plants and constellations for Dr Morrison's Chinese Dictionary.Footnote 24 John Russell Reeves arrived in China in 1827 as assistant inspector of teas and succeeded his father in 1831. Another founder of the museum, Henry Mathew Clarke, arrived in Canton in 1825 and was superintendent of exports for the EIC. He learned Chinese but left China in 1839. The third founder, the Reverend George Harvey Vachell, was the eldest son of Vicar John Vachell. He arrived in China on 15 August 1828 to work as chaplain to the EIC, mainly in Macao. George H. Vachell went back home in 1832, married Cecilia Catherine in 1834 and in that same year returned to China as chaplain to the British Commission.Footnote 25 Like Reeves, Vachell started collecting specimens as soon as he arrived, and sent some of them to the Cambridge Philosophical Society Museum at the request of the naturalist Rev. Leonard Jenyns (1800–1893). As I have already said, some scientific British journals acknowledged the research carried out by correspondents such as John Reeves, indicating the importance of their work for the advancement of knowledge. In 1857 The Journal of the Proceedings of the Linnean Society: Zoology published short biographies of some of the Society's members, including John Reeves and his son. Such biographical information on their pioneering research and fieldwork in China, especially in Macao, allows us to understand their contribution to science and European research on Asia, as well as how one of them became involved in the founding of the British Museum in Macao:
In 1812 he [John Reeves, the father] proceeded to China. . .He devoted his leisure to investigating the resources of the country, and to the pursuit of various branches of science, making it his principal object to procure specimens of the natural productions of the country, and especially those which promised to be either useful or ornamental, and to transmit them to England. . .He contributed largely to English horticulture. . .by collecting plants during the spring and summer. . .It was in this way, to instance one case among many, that the Wistaria sinensis first found its way to England. It was in the latter part of his stay in China that he made the fine collection of fishes, which, together with his drawings, furnished the groundwork of Sir John Richardson's valuable Report “On the Ichthyology of the Seas of China and Japan” published in the “Reports of the British Association” for 1845. . . Mr. Reeves became a Fellow of the Linnean Society in 1817, and of the Royal Society in the same year; he was also a Fellow of the Horticultural Society, the Royal Astronomical, the Asiatic, and the Zoological Societies, and of the Society of Arts; and most of these institutions are indebted to him for valuable contributions to their collections.Footnote 26
The same publication goes on to praise the work of John Reeves's son in Macao, especially his research for the British Museum in London:
His son, John Russell Reeves, Esq., (also, let me add, a valuable Fellow of our Society) has likewise presented various fish procured at Macao to the British Museum; among which are several species not figured in his father's drawings. Mr. Reeves's contributions to the British Museum were not limited to the Natural-History departments, but included also the Library and the department of Antiquities, to the latter of which in particular he gave, from his large collection of Chinese coins, all such as were thought desirable for the national cabinet.Footnote 27
In 1829, news of the opening of the British Museum in China and of the work of its founders quickly reached Europe and other parts of Asia, and in September the Asiatic Journal described the structure and aims of the “Macao Museum” in detail, based on an article previously published in the Canton Register:
It appears from the Canton Register, that a society has been formed for the purpose of establishing at Macao a cabinet of natural history and curiosities in art, consisting of beasts, birds, fishes, reptiles, insects, either stuffed or prepared in spirits; paintings of them, and skeletons for the comparative anatomist; anecdotes of the names and habitations of each to be entered by the secretary in a book kept purposely in the museum.Footnote 28
The short description enumerates the contents of the different thematic displays and the founders’ pedagogic efforts to inform visitors: vegetables, stones, Chinese art and ethnographic objects, musical instruments, as well as models of tombs, machines, and the captions explaining each piece's application, so that those ethnographic documents and artefacts were more than just strange and exotic objects on display. Many of the objects had been collected in China and were displayed and explained to the public in Macao by the EIC supercargoes and other traders who lived in the city, the “British community” mentioned in the excerpt below.
In the second half of the eighteenth century the network of interests around the British opium trade united the supercargoes, the private merchants and the country traders who carried the drug and other goods from India to Southern China.Footnote 29 The EIC's Select Committee was unable to prevent private traders from residing in Macao and Canton given its officials’ personal interests, its dependence on private trade and the strategies of merchants who joined other nations’ diplomatic services before going to Macao, thus evading the Company's legal control.Footnote 30 Independent agents and traders such as Daniel and Thomas Beale, John Henry Cox,Footnote 31 Charles Schneider, David Reid,Footnote 32 William Jardine and James MathesonFootnote 33 arrived in the enclave in the late eighteenth century, using the names of Portuguese residents and the diplomatic posts of other European nations with a view to trading in the city, thus by-passing the law and the EIC's orders of expulsion. The British community was therefore composed of supercargoes, private merchants and their families living in Macao all year long. The private trader Thomas Beale (1775–1841),Footnote 34 who collected fauna and flora from all over the world, was most likely a major donor to the museum. Supercargoes and private traders all contributed financially to the local anglophone “infant institution” which displayed:
Vegetable productions, both dried and in painting. Mineralogical and geological specimens. Specimens of art, especially Chinese, such as costumes, manufactures, models of machinery, buildings, tombs, bridges, boats, arms, fishing tackle, agricultural implements; hydraulics, dyeing materials, with accounts of their application; smelting processes, models of furnaces, &c.; carvings, josses,Footnote 35 ornaments, musical instruments; inscriptions, with translations, coins, books and plates of natural history. Having been submitted in the first instance to the gentlemen of the British factory, and highly approved of by a great majority of their number, a meeting was held on the 22nd of February, when it was resolved to give effect to the undertaking, by establishing a museum at Macao, to be supported by subscriptions of the British community in China, but open to gentlemen of every nation to become honorary and corresponding members by ballot. The editor of the Register observes: “The good-will already manifested towards this infant institution may, we hope, be augured as an earnest of its future success’.Footnote 36
Some American residents immediately donated “objects of curiosity” from all over Asia. Dr Robert Morrison contributed by translating a description of the museum into Chinese to be delivered to the Hong merchantsFootnote 37 and other tea dealers in Canton, in the hope that they would donate Chinese objects. Unlike their Chinese peers, foreigners could not freely enter China and collect material for the institution. The museum was therefore described as a joint effort of British traders and missionaries, as well as American and Chinese merchants – an anglophone philanthropic, scientific and educational initiative in a Chinese territory administrated by the Portuguese:
Several contributions of objects of curiosity have been received, amongst them a very liberal collection from an American gentleman. By the aid of Dr. Morrison, whose talents and co-operation are never wanting in the cause of knowledge, a statement of the objects of the museum has been drawn out in Chinese, and distributed through the Hong merchants, among the tea dealers and numerous merchants from the interior, who annually visit Canton. Experience will not, perhaps, justify our building much on their assistance; yet so much is in their power to effect with but little trouble, that something more may be looked for than the mere isolated efforts of individuals have been able to accomplish, when the desire of gain is brought into action with the more ample means, which an association can command.Footnote 38
Robert Morrison, who also participated in the organisation of the museum as a sinologist and translator, mentioned the founding of the institution and its $30 annual subscription in a letter to George Staunton,Footnote 39 dated 24 February 1829. Naming the permanent collection was difficult, but a decision was reached and the institution officially became the “British Museum in China”:
I am induced to write a few lines to mention the formation of a Museum here. It is to include Natural History and the Productions of Art. It is open to all British subjects by ballot, and not confined to the Factory. Some of the Factory indeed declined being members. For the current year, Mr. Reeves, jun., is secretary, Mr. Clark, treasurer; and the Rev. Mr. Vachell, curator. Our annual subscription is thirty dollars. The name to give it was a difficulty. At last the meeting resolved to call it the British Museum in China.Footnote 40
Dr Morrison's memoirs also described the aims of the museum and his own involvement:
During this summer [1829] an Institution was established in Macao, designated the British Museum in China, for the purpose of collecting native and foreign curiosities, including the productions of art, as well as what pertained to natural history, &c. Dr. Morrison zealously encouraged this attempt to enlarge the sphere of knowledge and science – not only as a liberal subscriber and contributor, but also by circulating among the natives a statement of the objects of the museum.Footnote 41
Several anglophone Macao residents and visitors describe the permanent collection. Harriett Low, an American young lady who resided in Macao between 1829 and 1833, visited the museum with the Rev. Vachell in June 1830.Footnote 42 A year later she mentioned some of the animals on display and Vachell's work setting up the collection: “Dr. Morrison, Pereira and Fox called. After dinner according to agreement we went to Mr. Vachell's rooms to see some birds just sent from Java for the museum – very handsome. Also a flying fox, a wonderful creature, and a large vampire Bat, an immense creature”.Footnote 43 During another visit in 1832 she praised the numerous donations to the museum “where they have a great variety of curiosities. It has been established but a few years ago [1829], but the donations have been very large. Saw a skeleton of a man there. Not a very pleasing reflection that we must all, someday or other, be such a wreck of bones”.Footnote 44 Other visitors, such as Edmund Roberts, list the museum and other British and American institutions (“There are an English ophthalmic hospital,Footnote 45 and a small museum”),Footnote 46 and gradually the museum became part of Macao's collective (anglophone) memory and imaginary, as well as a tourist attraction, like the famous aviary and gardens of Thomas Beale, and the gardens that still surround the Camões Grotto, situated right next to the Casa Garden. This Portuguese villa was rented to the president of the EIC Select Committee and was visited by many British and North American travellers.
Other temporary visitors were guided through the museum, as Charles Samuel Stewart's 1830 travel narrative reveals when it enumerates places of interest in Macao: “The library and museum of the East India Company, an aviary of splendid birds belonging to Mr. Beale, an English resident, and a small Chinese temple, were also visited by us with much gratification”.Footnote 47 In 1834, English-born Australian physician and naturalist George Bennett (1804–1893) visited the enclave on his way to Australia and described the museum just before it was closed down. He listed some of the objects brought from all over the world to be displayed in the institution's several rooms, where a guide informed visitors and guarded the collections.
A museum has been established at Macao, by the English residents, and even now contains an extensive and excellent collection of birds, beasts, weapons, fossils, &c. from all parts of the world. Several rooms are appropriated solely for this collection, having a person to take charge of them, and attend upon visitors. So little encouragement, however, is given to natural science, and the European merchants are so much absorbed in mercantile affairs, that, on the dissolution of the establishment of the Honourable East India Company, this excellent nucleus for an extensive, valuable, and, (with scientific arrangement,) useful collection, will no doubt be broken up and dispersed.Footnote 48
According to the naturalist, the independent traders were only interested in business, so he foresaw the destruction of the museum after the EIC left China. The museum was in fact closed down, but his characterisation of the traders was not entirely accurate. On 19 October 1835, several western merchants, including the already mentioned William Jardine, met in Canton to established the China branch of the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge to show that “foreigners who come to this country have other objects in view than mere selfish gains”,Footnote 49 as if to contradict Bennett's point of view, which was common at the time.
Both the academic and general British press described the museum as a British contribution for the advancement of learning in Asia and in the West. It was also an effective way to improve the EIC's social image, a strategy which would have pleased the Company's directors in London, because of the strong demand in Britain for the end of the institution's monopoly in China, especially towards the end of the eighteenth century.Footnote 50 British traders and manufacturers began to demand that the government allow direct access to trade in China in vessels other than those of the EIC, so that they could thus offer more competitive prices than the Company's. The minister Sir Henry Dundas (1742–1811) affirmed that the EIC's China trade was in a precarious and fragile state but that the presence of new, independent traders might upset the situation by giving rise to cultural and economic conflicts; the Company's monopoly should therefore be upheld until such time as new privileges could be obtained from the emperor.Footnote 51 Following the 1833 act to regulate trade with China and India, the EIC's monopoly in China came to an end, and with it the “British Museum” in Macao. In that same year, the British Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge published the following description in its Quarterly Journal of Education that echoed the already quoted description published in Morrison's memoirs:
British Museum: This institution was established at Macao, in conformity with a resolution passed by members of the British factory on the 21st February, 1829. The object of the museum is the collection of specimens of natural history and of the productions of art. It is supported by annual subscriptions of thirty dollars each, the subscribing members being British subjects alone. Natives of other countries are eligible as honorary or corresponding members. The committee of management is composed of a treasurer, a curator, and a secretary.Footnote 52
In 1835, after the museum's closure, the London Quarterly Review mentioned the “public museum of rare animals, fossils, weapons, &c. &c., collected at the expense of the English residents”,Footnote 53 while Anders Ljungstedt's (1759–1835) famous Historical Sketch of the Portuguese Settlements in China, Macao's first history written in English, refers both to the EIC's library's 4,000 volumes and to the museum: “another interesting foundation was laid in 1829, by young English amateurs of natural history. The Museum was progressing, and posterity would no doubt have been indebted to it for many rare specimens of nature's produce and marvels, had not the founders of it been obliged, by the dissolution of the British factory at Canton, to separate”.Footnote 54 The 1833 Act to Regulate Trade with China and India officially ended the monopoly of the Company in the Pearl River Delta on 22 April 1834, and, as a result, both its library and museum were closed down and part of the collection left Macao. The April 1836 issue of the Journal of the Asiatic Society lists the specimens from the former Macao museum that the British trader in Canton Robert Inglis offered to the Museum of the Calcutta Asiatic Society, Footnote 55 which had been set up in 1814:
A collection of 148 mounted birds, six birds’ nests with eggs, six mammalia, one reptile, and the head and legs of various birds, were presented by R. [Robert] Inglis [of Canton], Esq. These formed part of the Macao museum lately abandoned. It had been proposed to transfer the whole collection to Calcutta [Museum of the Asiatic Society], and as far as concentration is beneficial, it is to be regretted that this magnificent intention had been abandoned.Footnote 56
The number of stuffed animals sent to Calcutta reveals both the value and the diversity of the Macao museum's collection, which was gradually dispersed after 1834. Robert Inglis’ philanthropic gesture was also acknowledged in the Catalogue of the Birds in the Museum Asiatic Society (1849), in which the origin of several items is listed: “from the former Macao museum: presented by R. Inglis, Esq. (1834)”, or “specimen from the dispersed Macao Museum”.Footnote 57 Unfortunately the general Catalogue of Curiosities in the Museum of the Asiatic Society (Calcutta, 1849), organised by the institution's librarian, does not mention the “Macao objects”.
Museums and private collections in Great Britain and other western countriesFootnote 58 were therefore enriched with specimens collected in Macao since the eighteenth century, and, in the case of the Calcutta museum, by the specimens taken from the “dispersed Macao Museum”, the first museum in China. We tend to think of the EIC and the American firms only as commercial institutions in China, but their presence was highly relevant in cultural and social terms, as supercargoes and traders greatly enriched the everyday life of the enclave and contributed to the advancement of scientific knowledge both in Asia and in the West. Their presence in China, and especially in Macao, was therefore not only economic but also cultural; it was vital for the dissemination of scientific knowledge and, as we have seen, for the training of the first British and American sinologists. Since the EIC's cultural and scientific role was not satisfactorily replaced by any other organisation or group of people after 1834, the museum and the library's closure impoverished Macao and the Pearl River Delta in cultural terms. The museum, like the library of the EIC, the English Tavern/Hotel on the Praia Grande,Footnote 59 the schools and hospitals founded by Protestant missionaries, Footnote 60 the English-language newspapers printed in Macao and Canton,Footnote 61 the theatre and opera performances, the several photographers who did business in the enclave from the 1840s onwards,Footnote 62 the EIC Press (1815–1834), the Luso-British Theatre (a temporary wooden building, 1839–c.1843) and the Protestant old cemetery and chapel – which can still be visited in Macao – reveal the greatness of the impact that the anglophone community had on the city's everyday cultural life and history. The British Museum in Macao symbolises the British supercargoes’ interest and field work in Macao and Canton and their contribution to the advancement of knowledge locally and in Europe. The temporary institution was a manifestation of expanding scientific knowledge, of more amateur cultures of scientific appreciation and of European (British) posturing in Asia. It was also a vehicle for some of its founders to establish scientific credentials while asserting that Macao, Canton and China in general were centres of knowledge. As I have shown, it was the three above mentioned EIC supercargoes, and not the French Jesuit Pierre Marie Heude, as previously thought, who founded the first (western-styled) museum in China, the British Museum of Macao, which opened its doors 39 years before the Zhendan Museum in Shanghai.
