The earliest Moroccan novels depict intellectuals and activists in the independence movement navigating their place in the cultural and physical spaces of modern, European-built areas and traditional, enclosed medinas. Many of these works even parallel the labyrinth of the medina in their nonlinear narrative structure. The tensions between colonizing, intellectual, and working-class identities, and between spaces designed to maximize the reach of the authoritative gaze and those created to block external eyes, are what Ian Campbell studies in Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution: The Arabic-Language Moroccan Novel, 1957–72. Given that Morocco's independence was recognized by the French and Spanish governments in 1956, and that after 1972 Morocco at once became more engaged with international relations across North Africa and the Middle East and began to produce a growing number of novels exhibiting a variety of themes and styles, the sixteen-year period that this book covers is the foundational period of Moroccan nation-building. The novels published during these years are important for understanding the dynamics that emerge in later Moroccan novels and that are the substrate of Moroccan culture in general.
Campbell's study is organized into an introduction, eight chapters in which the primary texts are grouped thematically, and a conclusion. The first of the eight chapters is a useful and well-constructed overview of the historical and cultural contexts in which these novels were written and that they depict. In it, Campbell concisely covers the cultural and political history of the colonial period, the resistance movement, the revolution, and the decade and a half that followed. This framing enables Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution to be both a literary history of the earliest Arabic-language novels of Morocco and an analysis of spatiality and spatial practices in the works. Campbell argues that through the contrast between colonial power's “abstract mapping gaze” and the resistance to it of labyrinthine, yet patriarchal, Moroccan spaces, as well as through the sanctuary offered by spaces that allow for equality of power and gaze, the texts of the period negotiate the traumas and shifts of the anticolonial revolution and what lies beyond it.
Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution offers detailed, solid, and often innovative readings of all the texts it studies, from Abdelmajid Ben Jalloun's 1957 Fi al-Tufula (In [My] Childhood), to three novels by Abdelkarim Ghallab published in the 1960s and early 1970s, to Muhammad al-Zafzaf's 1972 al-Marʾa wa-l-Warda (The Woman and the Rose). Campbell's study covers some twelve novels, offering convincing interpretations of their spatial dynamics and relationships to the nationalist movement. In particular, I found the analysis of Khinnatha Binuna's al-Nar wa-l-Ikhtiyar (Fire and Choice) to be the most compelling. The study pinpoints the significance of the protagonist Layla's walks through the old and new sectors of Rabat: her wanderings through the city streets disrupt other events in the novel, but serve to construct her subjectivity. Ultimately, Layla not only imposes the mode of interacting with space typical of the winding medina upon the modern areas of the city, but she uses the freedom offered by that nonlinear movement to arrive at the decision to choose activism over marriage. These wanderings, which also occur in the novel's overall narrative structure, create an implicit critique of reductive, linear biographies and national histories.
Another particularly noteworthy section of this study is Chapter 6, in which Campbell uses trauma theory to present an illuminating interpretation of Abdallah Laroui's 1971 novel al-Ghurba (Exile). In a number of the texts, Campbell traces the difficulties that the Moroccan intellectual has in inserting him/herself in the revolution and in the project of improving what the postcolonial state offers Moroccans. Campbell describes this disjuncture as a missed encounter. In Chapter 6, through the analysis of Laroui's al-Ghurba, he identifies these difficulties and the resulting missed encounter as a traumatic experience. Drawing from Cathy Caruth's work on historical trauma and in dialogue with other critical accounts of al-Ghurba, Campbell demonstrates how Laroui's novel reframes Moroccan independence as, rather than a triumphant culmination, a traumatic event with negative consequences. Furthermore, Campbell convincingly argues that the novel's nonlinear structure functions to bewilder state censors and to conceal the novel's message: that Moroccan intellectuals must reconcile the violent process of the revolution with the fact that the new power structure (the postcolonial state) is not significantly different from the old one (the colonial protectorate).
Throughout the study, Campbell engages effectively with previous scholarship on Moroccan narrative as well as with the work of Henri Lefebvre on social space. However, it would have been fruitful to dialogue with other critics, such as Bertrand Westphal and Robert Tally in the emerging field of geocriticism, Farid Zahi (al-ʿAyn wa-l-Mira: al-Sura wa-l-Hadatha al-Basariyya [The Eye and the Mirror: The Image and Visual Modernity] [Rabat, Morocco: Manshurat Wizarat al-Thaqafa, 2005]), and Sara Upstone (Spatial Politics in the Postcolonial Novel [Burlington, Vt.: Ashgate, 2009]), all of whose work is extremely relevant to the topic and theoretical approach of Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution.
The book's footnotes are clear and effective and its bibliographic material is helpful, although one of the novels is left out of the otherwise useful list of “Books Examined in This Study.” With the exception of the introduction, where there are some opaque passages, the writing style of Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution is quite lucid. Nonetheless, the study's theoretical framework remains unclear.
Some of Campbell's terminology clouds his analytical aims and, moreover, a crucial term—sacred interior space—is never defined. In Campbell's discussion of spatiality, and specifically of an abstract, mapping gaze, he equates “Western” and “abstract.” He is careful to qualify the binary opposition that this can create, between an abstract, rational (monolithic) “West” and a concrete, irrational (equally monolithic) Morocco. Similarly, he explains that the term labyrinthine is not meant to evoke exotic images of the East. However, the repeated use of the term labyrinthine, instead of referring to enclosed, nonlinear, medina patterns, seems to foreground the exotic and uphold an opposition between the abstract and the irrational. Similarly, the conceptualization of colonizer and colonized found in the study does not attend to the nuances of overlap between these categories. For instance, the study does not address the ways in which Arab culture and the Arabic language are also colonial forces with regard to the autochthonous Amazigh (or Berber) population, nor the ways in which the Jewish Moroccan community had an in-between status during the colonial period. More importantly, although the study makes repeated use of the term “sacred interior space” to refer to physical and figurative spaces in which equal gazes are established, there is no explanation of the sacredness of these spaces. Rather, the question “Why ‘sacred’?” remains. Unfortunately, these lapses weaken the persuasiveness of Campbell's argument that the period's novels process the traumas and shifts of the Moroccan transition to independence through the encounter between the abstract, mapping gaze of colonial discourse, the resistance of labyrinthine Moroccan spaces, and the sanctuary of sacred interior spaces.
In spite of these limitations, Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution is an original contribution to the field of Moroccan literary studies. It is particularly useful for students and scholars of modern Arabic literature, postcolonial literature, and specifically Moroccan history and literature. I recommend the book to these audiences as it will provide a window into the core tensions of postcolonial Morocco that persist to this day, understood through the lens of space. Given the relative paucity of scholarship focused on the Arabic-language Moroccan novel, Labyrinths, Intellectuals and the Revolution offers a highly original and elucidating approach to a set of often-neglected texts.
