In the study of late antique housing, small finds have received less attention than the architectural and ornamental features of houses. Moreover, how these objects were perceived sentimentally by their users has thus far been an overlooked aspect, to which Jo Stoner's monograph, based on her doctoral thesis (University of Kent, 2015), is a welcome contribution.
After a preface (IX), list of figures (X–XI) and abbreviations (XII), the introduction (1–8) indicates that the volume centres on late antique material culture, from a ‘perspective on the lives of artefacts … focusing upon cultural meanings and personal or sentimental values’ (1), by combining archaeological, textual and iconographical sources. Moreover, it considers material culture as ‘representative of a broader section of society, rather than just the elites or middling classes that often form the focus of studies on Late Antiquity’ (1). By unravelling interlinked meanings connected with personal objects, S. aims at understanding owners of different socio-economic statuses, as well as the multiple lives of objects, their real and sentimental values, and related cultural ideas. To achieve this purpose, she mainly relies on the theories of object biography, memory studies and agency, which are, however, not profoundly developed. In the same line, since most of the late antique objects studied ‘were originally domestic in nature, and were used, displayed, or stored within the home’ (4), a definition of the late antique house would have been useful: throughout the book an extensive range of ‘homes’ occurs, ranging from the elite residence to the monastic cell. The author opts for a broad geographical perspective, integrating objects from different regions of the Empire in her study, which gives the book at some places a rather mixed character. From a chronological point of view, most objects under study belong to the third to fifth centuries a.d., but they are supported with evidence from earlier or later periods.
The main chapters focus on three categories of domestic objects, each discussed by means of selected examples, some of which are accompanied by colour or black-and-white illustrations. Apart from heirlooms, inherited from one generation to another within a family (9–26), S. discusses gifts, which were typically transferred through social exchanges between individuals, as a separate category (27–45). The third chapter (46–73) analyses both non-religious and Christian souvenirs, which got their meaning from their connection with a particular location, travel or event. However, as S. also indicates herself on several occasions, this categorisation feels somewhat artificial, since several objects could change roles during their lifespan and, consequently, reappear as examples in the three chapters.
Each of the three sections starts with a definition of the specific object category. As in the introduction, here too some more references to the scholarly literature and theoretical framework could have been provided. The core part of each chapter consists of the discussion of selected domestic objects, after which the main ideas are summarised in a conclusion, which is oddly lacking in the third chapter on souvenirs. Due to the nature of the evidence, most of the discussed examples are elite objects, including several highlights from museums, which are placed in the broader framework of late antique society through the use of textual evidence (e.g. the use of silver tableware in dining contexts; the role of jewellery in marriage practices). By integrating documentary papyri, which frequently inform us about people from all walks of life in Egypt, S. also tries to shed light on the meanings of less often preserved, ‘ordinary’ objects. However, the roles of these ‘domestic objects’ within the physical house are not always clear. This issue could have been compensated by referring to more domestic objects from investigated houses, such as House D at Kom el-Dikka (67), which is a rare example of an excavation context mentioned in the book.
Through the case study of basketry, the fourth chapter (73–91) exemplifies how one object category could unite different layers of (contemporaneous or subsequent) meanings during its lifespan. In contrast to most examples discussed thus far, basketry represents a ‘cheap’ object category. Despite the meaningful roles of domestic baskets, this last section includes repetition and does not feel like an integrated part of the book. Besides, the monastic context, which receives much attention, could have been better embedded in the broader context of late antique housing.
Finally, the volume ends with a general conclusion, summarising the most significant ideas in each chapter (92–106), followed by a bibliography (107–16) and a useful index (117–20). Although S. succeeds in bringing to life the personal and sentimental relations between people and objects, this is not entirely the case with the connection between objects and their domestic context, an issue of which the author herself is aware. At the very end of the book, she attempts to fill this gap through the imaginative reconstruction of a lower- to middling-class house in Egypt with its associated material culture and sentimental meanings. In this way, she offers a final counterpart to the elite material culture that predominates in her study, in order to prove that sentimental values linked with objects transcended status and socio-economic borders. Bringing together people of different backgrounds in her object-based approach to the late antique world, the author thus shows again the close bond between persons and objects, which connects the reader of this book in a recognisable way with the people of the past.
