In this highly readable book, Sam Quinones, who has worked both as a freelance journalist and for the Los Angeles Times, provides a series of ‘tales’ that uncover the complexities of national and international migration of Mexicans. Part historian, part ethnographer and part acute analyst of small town politics, Quinones examines both the impact of the migration process on individuals and on the towns they have left, and the roots of this exodus in the profound social inequality that has characterised life in Mexico since the pre-conquest.
Focusing on these people provides Quinones with the opportunity to discuss much more than the policy issues associated with migration. Drawing on his ten years of work in Mexico, the author describes the sea change in Mexican politics brought about by the demise of the PRI and the emergence of a multiparty system. In addition, he examines the dramatic cultural changes that mark even the lives of the poorest rural men and women who move from their villages to Mexico City, in particular the emergence of punk, hiphop and cholo cultures among – of all people – youth recently arrived from impoverished rural zones of Mexico.
Quinones traces the push factors that bring migrants such as 12-year old Delfino Juárez from his village in Xocotla, Veracruz, to construction sites in Mexico City where – together with men from his village – he built structures well familiar to readers of this book: the new Colegio de México campus on the southern edge of the city, the studios of Televisión Azteca, and a Kentucky Fried Chicken outlet. In framing the life story of his central informant in terms of his harrowing experiences on job sites in Mexico City, Quinones goes a long way to answering the question that occurs to even the most detached observer of Mexican workers in the United States: Why would Mexican migrants put up with the harsh conditions, low pay and extreme insecurity that they face as undocumented, or even as documented workers in the USA?
The author's biographies of domestic and transnational migrants include a successful immigrant rancher deeply rooted in California who wins the office of mayor of his hometown in Zacatecas, the pioneer migrants from Atolinga, Zacatecas who introduce taco and burrito restaurants to Chicago, and the Michoacán-born high school guidance teacher who coaches a soccer team comprised of Mexican, Salvadoran and Vietnamese players in Garden City, Kansas, even as he reflects on the self-imposed limitations of second generation immigrant youngsters in US school systems.
With the exception of the three chapters devoted to the story of Delfino Juárez whom Quinones follows from his village to Mexico City and then across the Arizona-Sonora desert to East Los Angeles and back again to Veracruz, each chapter in this book stands on its own and can be read with no reference to any other piece in the book. Alas, although there are interesting comparisons to be drawn among the chapters that deal directly with the migratory experience, readers are left to work these out for themselves as the author makes no attempt to draw any parallels between or among the men he has interviewed. Meanwhile, other very interesting chapters in the book that focus on the creation of a symphony orchestra in Tijuana, the drug-running activities (and the widespread drug dependency) of the traditional German Mennonites in the state of Chihuahua, and the international commercialisation of the gaudy black velvet paintings produced for tourists in Ciudad Juarez and in Tijuana have very little to do with the theme of migration except that these are all border settings and many of the people involved have moved back and forth across that border all their lives.
Still, the alert reader who runs through the book at one go can tease out some very curious and interesting commonalities and contrasts. In Quinones's chapter on South Gate, California, an overwhelmingly white suburb that, with the loss of high-end factory jobs was transformed into a Latino enclave, the gradual seizure of absolute power by a Chicano strongman called forth a civic protest movement that united the community. This development, Quinones insists, sprang from the very fact that Mexican-born residents of South Gate recognised in their mayor all the patterns of repression employed by the old priista caciques in the villages or barrios they left behind. And it is this recognition, Quinones argues, that gives them the strength to resist and to push their oppressor from power. Yet, among the high school students in Garden City, Kansas, Mexican heritage is the explanation offered by the Mexican American soccer coach as the explanation for the submissive and ultimately self defeating behaviour of the bulk of Mexicans who attend the school. This is not an academic study, but it is an engaging book in which biographies of individuals are skilfully assembled to provide a revealing look at political, economic and social change in Mexico and in Mexican communities in the United States.
