Contemporary debates over the moral justification for reparations center on the damage done by slavery to the social, psychological, and economic fabric of modern nations. Advocates frequently refer to the essential wrong found in the way legislated abolition was sometimes accompanied by compensation to slave-owners, but never to the enslaved. Certainly enslaved people who rebelled against the system fought to possess the land as well as their freedom, and even where abolition was legislated the idea sometimes persisted that at some future date the land was to become the property of the children of the enslaved. The free people who debated slavery and legislated its abolition rarely considered the compensation of the enslaved an imperative worthy of extended discussion. On the other hand, they did devote a great deal of energy to debating the possibility of compensation to slave-owners—for the loss of their property in human life—and considered in detail the variety of forms by which such compensation might be delivered. Rather than “compensation for slavery” the objective was to compensate for losses resulting from the abolition of the system. It is these debates which form the foundation of Frédérique Beauvois’s novel approach to the question.
Beauvois surveys the history of compensation debates across the Americas and also in the European metropolitan centers where imperial decisions were made. The most easily quantified and best known form of compensation was paid in money. British slave-owners topped the list with £20 million, followed by the French, whereas those owning people in other regions of the Americas received relatively little and often nothing. In some cases, slave-owners received compensation in the form of labor, where freed slaves were forced to work without pay for their former masters for a term of years, or emancipation was gradual. Doing so shifted the cost of compensation to the backs of the enslaved, an easy solution for metropolitan governments and taxpayers, something Robert Fogel and Stanley Engerman called “philanthropy at bargain prices.” Occasionally slave-owners were given land in addition. Those in Puerto Rico received all three types of compensation—money, labor, and land—whereas slave-owners in the U.S. South, where by far the largest enslaved population was found, received nothing. The British got labor as well as money, the French only money. Elsewhere the pattern varied from nation to nation. Beauvois sets out these patterns clearly.
The primary basis of Beauvois’s study is the content of debates over compensation that found their way into the written record, notably the transcripts of speeches delivered in the British and French parliaments. Her focus is firmly on these two nations, because their colonies held the largest ratios of enslaved people and because the scale of the payments made to slave-owners was particularly large. Outside the Americas, as Beauvois recognizes, the process of abolition was quite different and compensation most often not a question for debate.
Both pro- and anti-slavery advocates typically regarded compensation as a justifiable entitlement and a necessary lever in the negotiation of freedom. In the British House of Commons and the French Chamber of Deputies abolitionists were confronted by individual representatives and lobby groups with direct interests in slavery and the slave trade—notably metropolitan merchants and absentee planters—determined to protect their investments. Although it is sometimes difficult to decide where to locate particular individuals, the advantage for Beauvois is that arguments advanced by parliamentary speakers can be systematically studied in relation to the interest groups with which they were associated. Much of the analysis advanced by Beauvois is founded in her statistical study of these patterns.
The most persistent arguments in favour of compensation were founded in a legalistic notion of expropriation or compulsory purchase—the loss to the slave-owner from the abolition of rights to treat enslaved people as property to be sold, rights to property in children of enslaved women, and to extract labor. It was broadly agreed that expropriation as a social and economic instrument was affected only in exceptional cases, as in the nationalization of church property in the early stages of the French Revolution or the public acquisition of land for railroads. It was something to be feared by the capitalist community, and a powerful argument in favour of compensation as a precedent. There was also a long-standing argument that the existence of slavery was a shared social responsibility, not simply a crime committed by the slave-owner.
As the debates proceeded a fresh strand emerged stressing the need to provide compensation in order to secure the cooperation of the slave-owning classes. Only near the very end of the debates was it argued that compensation was essential to enabling planters to pay wages and retain labor. These were arguments advanced by speakers on both sides of the question, in complex combinations and associated with different opinions on the speed of abolition. For example, planters whose plantations had become unprofitable sometimes spoke in favour of immediate abolition hoping to benefit by the compensation needed to encourage the cooperation of those invested in colonies where strong profits were still being made. Similarly, whereas some abolitionists distinguished between property in things—chattels—and human beings, others argued for gradual abolition, seeing property as a sacred trust.
Beauvois follows these twists and turns in fine detail with regard to the British and French examples, making a substantial contribution to the historiography. She also opens up a broader discussion directed at explaining why compensation was paid in some cases but not all, and why the forms of compensation varied from place to place. Here Beauvois relies on existing published research for comparative analysis. Debate seems likely to develop on the basis of her stimulating contribution, with regard both to the reasons for these contrasting patterns and the question whether, however morally misplaced, compensation of slave-owners was essential to the achievement of legislated abolition where it occurred comparatively early.
