When one takes up this book, it is almost impossible to reach quickly for the last pages and wonder if there is that much to say about physical barriers, particularly walls, to fill 350 or so pages. But upon returning to the beginning, the reader is immediately grabbed by the author's uncanny ability to place what is a historical examination of physical barriers squarely in current political debates, both empirical and theoretical. And then, as the reading progresses, one realizes that there is even more to say about physical barriers than the author did. In fact, this reader cannot avoid thinking, for example, that there is a wall under construction between the United States and Mexico, a stone's throw from my own home where I sit reading the book, and very little was said about that particular physical barrier. But the contribution of this book to an understanding of what is happening in my own backyard is vast.
At the empirical level, Brent L. Sterling makes it clear that there are important reasons to study the external and domestic effects of physical barriers as a security strategy, not only because some countries are building walls and fences today (the U.S. walling and fencing of the border with Mexico being the most vivid example) but also because other countries are contemplating doing the same (including Afghanistan, Botswana, India, Saudi Arabia, and Thailand). Chapter after chapter, one is transported through fascinating details, from strategic threats (real or imagined) to the leaders' perceptions and motivations (from the simplest to the most complex) to the decision-making processes (bureaucratic, military, and financial) behind the construction of physical barriers. Chapters 2 through 7 are full of numbers, dates, historical facts, data, and bits of information all thoughtfully strung and arranged to make just that argument and intuitively lead the reader back to a more philosophical appreciation of Robert Frost's poem “Mending Wall.” In the end, little doubt remains that human beings have, for thousands of years and in many diverse places, put their faith in physical barriers as strategic instruments for achieving defensive goals. It also becomes clear that technology and modern weapons do not seem to have deterred this unending faith in physical barriers. The merits of the book are increased by the author's ability to present us with a disciplined narrative, even though many pieces of the puzzle are missing, telling us that he has visited those places to understand better the conditions under which the physical barriers may have been built.
At the theoretical level, Sterling brings important conceptual frameworks—such as offense/defense theory; deterrence theory; accommodation theory; power projection theory; decision-making theory; and signaling, strategic culture, and bureaucratic politics theories—to bear on his analysis. This shows not only his vast theoretical knowledge but also his ability to combine that knowledge with solid empirical research to give us an in-depth analysis of something as controversial as the building of physical barriers between peoples and nation-states. He skillfully demonstrates that all of these theories have something to add to the explanation of the use and abuse of physical barriers as a strategic instrument throughout the ages and into our days. Out of his detailed reflections, the author draws clear theoretical conclusions about strategic physical barriers. And not all of them are encouraging.
These structures, the author argues, generate intense concerns for their targets. This often leads to their destruction because the target population sets out on a quest to defeat the purposes of the barriers. In other words, the physical barrier increases the adversary's motivation to go around it. Worse, if the barrier is built before an adversarial relationship is formed, it will tend to create one and make the security environment even more difficult for the builder. And if the barrier is built after an adversarial relationship already exists, it will increase the determination of the adversary to defeat the purpose of it, adding to an already tense situation. (The walls of Athens and Chinaare two clear examples.) To make matters worse, the deterrence intentions of the physical barrier do not hold. Sooner or later they are defeated and eventually abandoned by the builder, partly because they help focus the adversary on the wall itself and how to destroy its purpose. Thus, the barrier will not remain for long. No barrier ever has. Eventually they all come down, but not before they have given the enemy added focus and discipline in an uncertain security environment.
Another important conclusion has to do with the effects of the barrier on the builder itself. Although a physical barrier may buy time for the builder, on the downside it may actually be a symbol of the builder's feelings of vulnerability and its own failure to deal with the causes that necessitated the wall in the first place. Thus, a physical barrier may be directed not only at the adversary but at the builder's own inability to deal with a problem domestically, due to political or policy reasons. As a consequence, it is possible to argue that a physical barrier may say more about the builder's domestic political environment than about external security conditions. In the end, though, physical barriers make the building power a status quo power, unwilling to change and adapt, and the “buying of time” may actually postpone the difficult steps that need to be taken domestically to adapt to a new geopolitical environment. The “sense of being safe” that a wall provides may then morph into a “muddling through” solution that entails not only the builder's inability to deal with the root causes of the problem but also an increase in its paranoia and its fear of the future. For example, the wall may create domestic cleavages about the nature of society itself.
Methodologically, the book is quite solid. Sterling goes well beyond a complex historical narrative and the necessary theoretical task of extracting the lessons from each case. He sets out on a course of disciplined comparative work through a particularly sharp instrument known as “structured-focused comparison”: Each physical barrier—the circumstances, motivations, and actors surrounding the decision to build it and then to abandon it, as well as the repercussions both external and domestic—is carefully examined in order to understand what the six cases reveal about the utility or futility of physical barriers as a strategic security measure. The author acknowledges that it is not easy to compare circumstances and actors as disparate as the ancient Athenians and Chinese and the Israelis of today. Yet his thoughtful analysis of the six chosen cases pays off rather well. We have a book that is coherent and consistent and has much to teach us about physical barriers and the way humans have always seen them, in the face of, and in spite of, technological advances.
The value of the book lies not only in its contributions as an empirical and theoretical study of physical barriers over time but also in what it has to say about our own wall-building efforts in the southwest United States. Do Fences Make Good Neighbors? is an excellent springboard for looking at what the wall is intending to do, what it is doing, and what it may do to us. And even if the author states that he is not attempting to articulate a formal “theory of walls” (p. 11), the book goes a long way to give us one: a common thread for understanding why physical barriers are built, their effectiveness and consequences over time, and, even better, what their effects are on our security environment, on our presumed adversary, and on ourselves. This turns out to be a wise promise, as the cases do yield disparate results, but the author undersells his own findings. His conclusions on what the wall may signal to others about us and about what wall building may itself do to us is, in and of itself, a powerful result to which we should turn as we proceed with our 1,000-mile physical barrier between the United States and Latin America.
