No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 September 2005
Raymond William Baker introduces us to a coterie of Egyptian Islamist intellectuals he labels “the New Islamist Trend” (elsewhere he calls them “moderate” or “centrist” Islamists, and a few times they are given the lofty title “the Islamic Awakening”). These thinkers, who include religious scholars such as the late Muhammad al-Ghazzaly, journalists such as Fahmy Huwaidy, and lawyers such as Kamal Abul Magd, emerge out of a wasaṭiyya (middle) tradition that eschews the violence and intolerance of the most radical Islamists, while rejecting what Baker calls “secular extremism” that seeks to banish religion from the public sphere entirely. Baker's aim is twofold: he wants to give a flavor of the New Islamists' thinking and, just as important, to ease the suspicion that Westerners might harbor toward those who label themselves “Islamic” or “Islamist.” These are laudable goals, and this is the work of a mature scholar who knows his subject well—so well, in fact, that he often recedes from view and allows the New Islamists to speak to us directly.
They have a lot to say. Baker dutifully reports New Islamist wisdom on everything from the state of the Egyptian educational system to the status of women, freedom of thought, the welfare state, and scores of issues in between. If there is anything in the New Islamist program that Baker finds wanting, he does not let us know. At first this strikes the reader as an admirable bit of restraint on the author's part—indicative of a desire to remain in the background and let the subjects do the talking—but soon it becomes clear that Baker comes not to judge the New Islamists but to praise them. Indeed, in almost three hundred pages, the New Islamists seem incapable of saying anything that is not “enlightened,” “pragmatic,” “tolerant,” “impressive,” or “seasoned.” This would be fine if the New Islamists were in fact all of these things. But as in any group of thinkers, some of what they say is worthy, and some is not so worthy.
Consider their stance on freedom of expression. We might expect that those whose words and thoughts are routinely suppressed by an authoritarian regime would be among the most ardent champions of free speech. But the New Islamists, who have had to contend with all sorts of government harassment and censorship, are not above using the levers of government to harass and censor others. For example, Baker tells us of a New Islamist professor of literature who sued the Egyptian TV monopoly for broadcasting “un-Islamic programming”—in this case, a popular song-and-dance extravaganza aired during Ramadan. Baker applauds the plaintiff for using the courts to mount his attack and for refraining from questioning the programmers' “personal status as believers”—as though this were not the least that decency required. He paints as eminently reasonable the New Islamists' demand that artistic expression be consistent with “Islamic values,” but he never considers whether it is legitimate for any group to set itself up as the arbiter of what is or is not Islamic.
In at least one case—the 1994 attempt by Islamist militants to kill Naguib Mahfouz—this New Islamist pretension has had disastrous consequences. Baker tells us that al-Ghazzaly, who emerges as something of a hero in this book, condemned the attack and rushed to Mahfouz's bedside. But al-Ghazzaly was not innocent. He had been a member of the al-Azhar committee that banned Mahfouz's 1959 novel Children of Gebelaawi, fixing it in the Egyptian imagination as blasphemous. Baker argues that there is a “difference between criticism and violence” and that al-Ghazzaly's critique of Mahfouz's writings was worlds away from the attempt to take the author's life, but it is hard to justify the distinction. Censorship may not involve bodily harm, but it is violence nonetheless. And it cannot help but pave the way for real brutality.
Baker makes much of the fact that the New Islamists routinely denounce the intolerance of their more radical counterparts, but he fails to ask whether they live up to their own rhetoric. He opens the book with an account of a famous 1992 debate between al-Ghazzaly and Egypt's foremost secularist, Farag Foda. The audience apparently included several young Islamist hecklers, and Baker gives al-Ghazzaly great credit for silencing them. The episode is presented as evidence of the New Islamists' temperance, moderation, and civility. But careful readers will recall that, shortly after this event, Foda was gunned down by Islamist radicals. At the assassins' trial, according to press reports, al-Ghazzaly testified that Foda was an apostate and that his murderers had simply carried out a responsibility shirked by the state. Baker tries to rescue al-Ghazzaly by telling us that his testimony has been “distorted in tendentious ways as a justification of the assassins” but he never clues us in to exactly how. In the end, he suggests that al-Ghazzaly did not really endorse the killing and that he should have made himself clearer. But al-Ghazzaly made his living interpreting the word of God, so it seems odd to argue that he did not know the meanings his own words would convey. In any case, Baker gives us no evidence to support his assertion.
This is not to say that the New Islamists are all of a piece or that they are wholly intolerant or illiberal. Although Baker seems to think of them as a bloc (the book is littered with formulations like “according to the New Islamists,” or “the New Islamists made it clear,” or “the New Islamists insisted”), he does reveal some tensions among them. For example, we read that Kamal Abul Magd's response to the Mahfouz assault was not only to condemn it but to criticize al-Ghazzaly's earlier efforts to silence the writer. Elsewhere, we see instances of real tolerance, such as Fahmy Huwaidy's spirited rejection of the traditional Islamist suspicion of Coptic Christians. And when we read of the New Islamists' attempt to convince the Taliban not to demolish the ancient Bamiyan Buddhas, it strikes us as something akin to an act of heroism.
But the overwhelming feeling one has on reading this book is that Baker is too quick to accept what the New Islamists have to say. For example, he writes that the New Islamists believe that “secularists have a place in the Islamic community…provided they do not call into question or actively undermine its foundations, thereby endangering the community and depriving it of its Islamic identity.” But isn't that just a sanitized way of saying that secularists may think what they like as long as they keep quiet? And when he assures us that “many secularists in fact do accept the principle of applying sharia,” we are forced to conclude that either he does not take secularism (or the shari

a) seriously or he is operating with novel definitions of both. If “moderate secularists” are those who accept the shari

a, then it is no wonder that they “pose no problem for inclusion in an Islamic community.” But it should bring us no comfort.
Still, none of this is to deny the importance of the New Islamists' work or the service Baker does in presenting them to us. We constantly hear that Islam is in need of “reform.” One of the virtues of this book is that it gives us a close look at the kind of painstaking intellectual labor such reform involves. Whatever their faults, the New Islamists represent the most liberal elements of the religious movement, and they spend much of their time trying valiantly to stretch, bend, and redefine Islamic concepts to render them more capacious and forgiving. And so we see them pay lip service to the Islamic injunction against ribā (usury) but go on to declare that the interest charged by banks is ḥalāl. We see them affirm their support for the shari

a while arguing that modern, democratic government is largely consistent with it. And on and on. We might wonder whether such contortions are likely to pay off in the long run: history shows that real reformations involve not so much reshaping the faith as learning when to ignore it. But as long as the people of the Muslim world are caught between the dual yearnings for more Islam and more freedom, Baker's New Islamists may offer the best hope of achieving both.