Echoing the famous opening line in John Womack's classic Zapata and the Mexican Revolution, ‘This is a book about country people who did not want to move and therefore got into a revolution’, the author opens this book with: ‘This is a story of village tyrants come to grief; of men and women whose carefully defended world of racial privilege, political power, and landed monopoly has come unglued’ (p. 3). What unfolds is a fascinating ethnography and cultural history of the landed elites of Chilón in the northern zone of Mexico's southernmost state of Chiapas. The puzzle Bobrow-Strain sets out to explain is why these cattle ranchers and coffee growers, poised at the waning end of an era with their lifestyle on the brink of disappearing, largely acquiesced to the land invasions triggered by the 1994 Zapatista rebellion rather than resorting to their traditional means of violent repression. For a full understanding of agrarian social relations in Chiapas, this work focusing on the landowning class is a vital complement to the more plentiful studies of the causes of the uprising and its impact on indigenous and campesino populations.
Bobrow-Strain brings to this study a meticulous mining of state and private archives, as well as extensive interviews and observation of the landowning class. A keen observer of social dynamics, the author not only analyses the power relations embedded, for example, in the company store/debt/liquor system, or the shifting role of the state as mediator of landowner/peasant conflict; he pulls the reader into the scene through vivid vignettes that he has observed or recorded. The human drama of the shifting historical balance of fortunes portrayed here is reminiscent of Gone With the Wind, or Giuseppe di Lampedusa's The Leopard, or on a smaller screen the rural Chiapas novels of Rosario Castellanos.
Dissecting local history, the author traces the origins of ladino estate agriculture in north-central Chiapas to merchants and politicians from the highland town of San Cristóbal, who seized indigenous communal land or purchased it from speculators to invest in coffee and sugarcane (and cane liquor) in the late nineteenth century. Thus was born what in the Nicaraguan context was called a burguesía chapiolla, a homespun local elite, descendants of merchants and bootleggers. Bobrow-Strain sets aside the common myth that the Mexican Revolution never came to Chiapas, showing that in fact the reforms of the Cárdenas era set into motion a complex renegotiation of power between landed elites, the state (in the person of federal teachers and agrarian officials) and indigenous peasants. The landed elites of Chilón adapted to the policies and discourse of the late-arriving revolution by manipulating the changing instruments of rural power. They reinvented themselves as rugged cattle ranchers on the agrarian frontier, projecting a gendered masculinist self-image as forward-looking producers for the nation. Yet this post-war modernisation into the cattle business brought a shift from earlier patterns of close labour control, while extensive cattle ranching exacerbated agrarian conflict by further displacing subsistence agriculture.
One of the key findings of this study is that by the 1990s the young generation of landed elites was already abandoning this life for urban and professional alternatives, unwilling to continue struggling amidst growing agrarian conflict and the stagnating future prospects of a rentier class. In the wave of land invasions unleashed by the Zapatista uprising of 1994, the shocked ranchers' demands for the state to restore ‘order’ found little echo. In one telling scene, a landowner rushes to the agrarian prosecutor's office in the state capital of Tuxtla Gutiérrez to find the land invaders already there, the leader with his feet propped comfortably on the desk. Sensing power tipping toward the indigenous groups, many landowners took the government's compensation payments and cashed out rather than fighting.
While neoliberal economic restructuring by the 1990s did not bode well for the coffee and cattle producers of Chiapas, this study is much more nuanced than a simple economistic analysis. The author is at pains to point out that land values and expectations of profitability are inextricably linked to the ladino landowners' self-image and what he calls ‘geographies of fear’, shaped by racial constructions of the indigenous ‘other’. Constructions of collective memory figure prominently in this study, from the landowners' retelling of colonial accounts of the 1712 Tzeltal massacre of ladinos in Chilón to the watershed 1980 massacre of peasants by landowners and government forces at Golonchán (rendered as Wolonchán in some accounts).
Fifteen years after the Zapatista uprising, the son of Governor Juan Sabines, who presided at the time of the Golonchán massacre, is the governor of the day, having switched his party flag of convenience from the long-reigning PRI to the ‘opposition’ PRD. Paramilitaries still menace and a few landowners still fulminate or wax nostalgic, but most have reaccommodated themselves to commerce or politics, and indigenous peasants no longer shuffle before them with downcast eyes and hat in hand. Since Mexico's neoliberal agrarian counter-reform of 1992, the de facto local agrarian reform launched by indigenous struggles in Chiapas began an open-ended process of reconfiguring rural space. The lesson of Bobrow-Strain's excellent book is that not only peasants but also landowners respond to shifting circumstances in ways not predetermined by a generic class label. The devil is in the details of land tenure and spatial arrangements, state structures and policies, and complex interactions of culture and social power.
