India's turn to neoliberalism has arguably resulted in an epochal shift. According to policy makers, media, and the corporate sector, formal adoption of neoliberal principles in 1991 has produced a new, “global” generation in India. The ambitions, desires, and aggressive energy of this new generation are supposedly transforming India into an economic power to reckon with. Jyotsna Kapur's new book, The Politics of Time and Youth in Brand India, focuses on a “heightened preoccupation” with youth, novelty, and the “speeding up of time” across a range of discourses in present-day India, including Bollywood cinema, popular television serials, and consumer culture. A professor in the Department of Cinema and Photography at Southern Illinois University, Kapur has widely published in the field of capitalist and neoliberal political economy, everyday life, and popular culture. Drawing on her knowledge of cinema studies, feminist frameworks, critical theory, and Marxist concepts, the author unveils the multiple contradictions of neoliberalism in India.
Kapur argues that though the dominant rhetoric represents neoliberalism as an all-encompassing, novel, liberating moment, this freedom is largely exercised within enclosed residential enclaves or air-conditioned malls. Outside these privileged spaces, sexual violence, kidnapping, and honor killings are frequently used tactics to perpetuate the hierarchies of caste, gender, and class. She suggests that the projected freedom of India's new generation is mostly a marketing gimmick, a strategy of neoliberal capital to attract laborers and consumers. The advertising and culture industry continuously goads young people to “break free” from a stifling past and seize their own destiny. However, the uncertainties of employment in neoliberal capitalism undercut individual agency and force young people to submit to disciplinary routines that promise success in a globalized labor market.
The book starts out with a brief analysis of relevant theoretical frameworks and the political economy of neoliberalism and its “global generation” (chapters 1 and parts of chapter 2). Kapur points out that the shift to neoliberalism marks a break from a “sense of collective responsibility” (p. 50) that characterized postcolonial state and society in India. Although largely rhetorical, the Nehruvian goals of securing social and economic equity restricted the corporate takeover of resources. The memories of India's anti-imperialist struggles significantly shaped such visions of the nation. In neoliberalism, the emphasis on a market ethic and profits tends to erase that memory and makes the state complicit in the process of “accumulation by dispossession.” Thus, a bourgeois self-maximization, and not social goals, is the priority of neoliberal subjects. In this discourse, time loses any connotation to history and appears merely as an instrument for maximizing labor and generating surplus. The dissociation of individual imperatives from the “social” and “historical” arguably marks the distinctiveness of neoliberal society and its enterprising members. The later chapters examine these purported claims of the newness of India's “first” global citizens and their uninhibited freedom to act in a marketized world. Simultaneously, the book explores the cultural and political implications of the “radicalized speed up and fragmentation of time in neoliberalism” (p. 18).
Kapur argues that the emphasis on individual actions devoid of any attachment to the past or detachment from outcomes has reinforced an upper-caste Hindu ethic of karma. Management gurus and self-help manuals routinely evoke the Hindu epic the Mahabharata to instill the spirit of competition and immediate self-advancement in young aspirants. Citing examples from the epic, they stress the urgency to act while underplaying the issues of morality and righteousness. The mantra of emotional detachment and guilt-free accumulation produces unrelenting, risk-neutral actors, unfazed by the ups and downs of free-market capitalism.
Kapur reiterates how the diminishing welfare role of the neoliberal state has accelerated the commodification of social goods. Increasing dispossession and economic uncertainties have intensified confusion, chaos, and conflicts. In an engaging analysis of Bollywood cinema and television serials, Kapur illustrates how the Hindu tradition has been reified as a model of conflict resolution in contemporary India (chapters 2 and 3). Cinematic narratives frequently evoke Hindu mythical figures to valorize a morally ambiguous vigilante culture where a proactive individual assumes the responsibility of restoring order. But the portrayal of cyclical, changing yet unchanging, time in cinema and television serials renders individual actions insignificant. This dichotomy is reflective of the contradictory demands of neoliberal capitalism. Its smooth functioning requires hopeful, risk-loving bourgeois actors who must have an unwavering faith in the rapid profit-generating capacity of neoliberal ventures. These same individuals must also accept that fluctuations in the pace of the economy are inevitable. In this context, visual depiction of a cyclical time that is beyond individual agency becomes a coping mechanism. It helps neoliberal entrepreneurs accept the uncontrollable nature of capitalism. Moreover, portrayal of unchanging gender dynamics in the televised domestic sphere produces a sense of stability in a rapidly changing consumer culture.
In chapter 4 (a previously published essay), Kapur further illustrates how middle-class responses to a fast-paced, individual-centric neoliberal capitalism have renewed a deeply gendered and hierarchical Hindu tradition. Drawing on the Bollywood culture industry, she reveals how the projected hybrid weddings have become occasions to celebrate a “superior” Hindu tradition and its pure and docile female subjects. These lavish, family-centered affairs define the individual's freedom in terms of purchasing power and consumption while they glorify submission to a patriarchal tradition. Like the wedding-themed films, Bollywood thrillers offer insights into the anxieties engendered by neoliberalism. In the backdrop of chaotic urban spaces, swift actions and preemptive reasoning emerge as the individual's techniques to preserve his or her class privileges. While they valorize a culture of speed, Bollywood thrillers also depict how a radicalized capitalism has intensified inequalities, distrust, conflicts, and insecurities.
Although The Politics of Time and Youth in Brand India sometimes reads like a collection of rather disjointed chapters, it is a welcome addition to the growing corpus of studies that examine neoliberal subjectivities.
