Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:58:52.755Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Optimal mixing in three-dimensional plane Poiseuille flow at high Péclet number

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 July 2018

L. Vermach
Affiliation:
Cambridge Centre for Analysis, University of Cambridge, Centre for Mathematical Sciences, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, UKDepartment of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Centre for Mathematical Sciences, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, UK
C. P. Caulfield*
Affiliation:
BP Institute, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0EZ, UKDepartment of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Centre for Mathematical Sciences, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: c.p.caulfield@bpi.cam.ac.uk

Abstract

We consider a passive zero-mean scalar field organised into two layers of different concentrations in a three-dimensional plane channel flow subjected to a constant along-stream pressure gradient. We employ a nonlinear direct-adjoint-looping method to identify the optimal initial perturbation of the velocity field with given initial energy which yields ‘maximal’ mixing by a target time horizon, where maximal mixing is defined here as the minimisation of the spatially integrated variance of the concentration field. We verify in three-dimensional flows the conjecture by Foures et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 748, 2014, pp. 241–277) that the initial perturbation which maximises the time-averaged energy gain of the flow leads to relatively weak mixing, and is qualitatively different from the optimal initial ‘mixing’ perturbation which exploits classical Taylor dispersion. We carry out the analysis for two different Reynolds numbers ($Re=U_{m}h/\unicode[STIX]{x1D708}=500$ and $Re=3000$, where $U_{m}$ is the maximum flow speed of the unperturbed flow, $h$ is the channel half-depth and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D708}$ is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid) demonstrating that this key finding is robust with respect to the transition to turbulence. We also identify the initial perturbations that minimise, at chosen target times, the ‘mix-norm’ of the concentration field, i.e. a Sobolev norm of negative index in the class introduced by Mathew et al. (Physica D, vol. 211, 2005, pp. 23–46). We show that the ‘true’ variance-based mixing strategy can be successfully and practicably approximated by the mix-norm minimisation since we find that the mix-norm-optimal initial perturbations are far less sensitive to changes in the target time horizon than their optimal variance-minimising counterparts.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2018 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic representation of the initial distribution and boundary conditions imposed on the scalar concentration field shown in (a) side view on the midplane $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ and (b) top view on the midplane $y=0$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Schematic of the (nonlinear) DAL method for solving the constrained optimisation problem (2.26). At each iteration, the ‘direct’ system (2.17)–(2.19) is integrated forwards in time to the time horizon $T$, where the adjoint variables are initialised and the adjoint system (2.32)–(2.34) is then integrated backwards in time to $t=0$ in order to obtain $\unicode[STIX]{x1D735}_{\boldsymbol{u}_{0}}{\mathcal{L}}$. The initial condition is then updated via the conjugate-gradient method combined with a projection step ensuring (2.23) (as described in Foures, Caulfield & Schmid (2013)) until convergence.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Optimal initial conditions for maximising the time average of energy growth for a flow with $Re=500$ over time horizons (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$. Isosurfaces of 40 % of the maximum (yellow) and minimum (blue) of the streamwise velocity component $u$ are shown.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Spatial distribution of the scalar concentration field at the terminal time horizon for a flow initialised by perturbations which maximise the time-average of energy growth for (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$ on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Time evolution of the three studied measures for the three optimisation problems contained in (2.26) at $Re=500$. For each of the initial perturbations, the rows show: (a,d,g) the time-averaged energy growth $G(t)$; (b,e,h) the mix-norm $M(t)$; and (c,f,i) the variance $V(t)$ of the concentration field. The perturbations associated with the different optimisation problems are shown in the columns: (a–c) maximisation of the time-averaged energy growth; (d–f) minimisation of the mix-norm; and (g–i) variance. The quantities $G(t)$, $M(t)$ and $V(t)$ are defined in (3.5), (3.1) and (3.2), respectively. Thus, the time evolution of the optimal perturbations which actually optimise the specific quantities are shown in the panels located on the diagonal. Each panel contains five plots corresponding to the five chosen time horizons, $T=2,5,10,20,30$. The associated time horizon for each plot is indicated by a dot. The optimal envelopes $G_{opt}^{L}(T)$, $M_{opt}^{L}(T)$ and $V_{opt}^{L}(T)$ (plotted with dashed lines) are obtained via cubic interpolation of the optimal values at the time horizons, and the envelopes are plotted in all the panels of each row to allow better comparison between the various optimisation problems. In (a) to (c) the dot-dashed lines represent the optimal envelopes $G_{opt}^{2D}(T)$, $M_{opt}^{2D}(T)$ and $V_{opt}^{2D}(T)$ obtained by Foures et al. (2014) from flows restricted to evolve in two dimensions. The squares in (c) indicate the values of the scaled variance produced by energy-growth-maximising perturbations in two dimensions at the specific target times as reported by Foures et al. (2014). The black dot-dashed line in (c) corresponds to the cubic interpolation of these data points.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Optimal initial conditions for minimising the variance for a flow with $Re=500$ over time horizons: (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$. Isosurfaces of 40 % of the maximum (yellow) and minimum (blue) of the streamwise velocity component $u$ are shown.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Spatial distribution of the scalar concentration field at the terminal time horizon for a flow initialised by perturbations which minimise the variance for (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$ on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 7

Figure 8.Optimal initial conditions for minimising the variance for a flow with $Re=500$ over time horizons (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$. Isosurfaces of 40 % of the maximum (yellow) and minimum (blue) of the streamwise velocity component $u$ are shown.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Spatial distribution of the scalar concentration field at the terminal time horizon for a flow initialised by perturbations which minimise the mix-norm for (a) $T=2$, (b) $T=5$, (c) $T=10$ and (d) $T=20$ on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 9

Figure 10.Time evolution of the scalar field distribution produced by the energy-growth optimal perturbation (with time horizon $T=5$) at (a) $t=2$, (b) $t=7$, (c) $t=12$, (d) $t=18$ and (e) $t=30$, on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Time and wall-normal variation of the various production terms (as defined in (3.6)–(3.9)) for the optimal flow for energy growth over a time horizon of $T=5$: (a) the base flow term $P_{\bar{u}}$; (b) the (total) perturbation term $P_{u}$; (c) the perturbation term in the $x$–$y$ plane $P_{2D}$; and (d) the three-dimensional deviation term $P_{3D}$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Time evolution of the scalar field distribution produced by the variance-optimal perturbation (with time horizon $T=30$) at (a) $t=2$, (b) $t=6$, (c) $t=10$, (d) $t=15$ and (e) $t=30$, on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 12

Figure 13.Time and wall-normal variation of the various production terms (as defined in (3.6)–(3.9)) for the variance-optimal flow over a time horizon of $T=30$ for a flow with $Re=500$: (a) the base flow term $P_{\bar{u}}$; (b) the (total) perturbation term $P_{u}$; (c) the perturbation term in the $x{-}y$ plane $P_{2D}$; and (d) the three-dimensional deviation term $P_{3D}$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.(a–c) Variation with $y$ and $t$ of mean profiles $\langle \boldsymbol{U}\rangle _{xz}$ as defined in (3.10) for the transitional flows at $Re=3000$ (solid lines) and the parabolic base flow $\bar{\boldsymbol{u}}$ (dashed lines). (d–f) Flow rate $Q(t)$ as defined in (3.11) for flows with $Re=500$ (dashed lines) and $Re=3000$ (solid lines) for time horizon $T=5$ with optimal initial perturbation, for (d) time-integrated energy growth, (e) mix-norm minimisation and (f) variance minimisation for $T=5$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Time evolution of the three studied measures for the three optimisation problems contained in (2.26) at $Re=3000$. For each of the initial perturbations, the rows show: (a,d,g) the time-integrated energy growth $G(t)$; (b,e,h) the mix-norm $M(t)$; and (c,f,i) the variance $V(t)$ of the concentration field. The perturbations associated with the different optimisation problems are shown in the columns: (a–c) maximisation of the time-integrated energy growth; (d–f) minimisation of the mix-norm; and (g–i) variance. The quantities $G(t)$, $M(t)$ and $V(t)$ are defined in (3.5), (3.1) and (3.2), respectively. Thus, the time evolution of the optimal perturbations which actually optimise the specific quantities are shown in the panels located on the diagonal. Each panel contains three plots corresponding to the three chosen time horizons $T=2,5,10$. The associated time horizon for each plot is indicated by a dot. The optimal envelopes $G_{opt}^{T}(T)$, $M_{opt}^{T}(T)$ and $V_{opt}^{T}(T)$ (plotted with dashed lines) are obtained via cubic interpolation of the optimal values at the time horizons, and the values computed at $t=30$ using time horizon $T=10$. The envelopes are plotted in all the panels of each row to allow better comparison between the various optimisation problems. For comparison, the optimal envelopes $G_{opt}^{L}(T)$, $M_{opt}^{L}(T)$ and $V_{opt}^{L}(T)$ for flows with $Re=500$ are plotted with dot-dashed lines.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Optimal initial conditions for (a) maximising the time-integrated energy growth, (b) minimising the concentration variance and (c) mix-norm for a flow with $Re=3000$ over a time horizon $T=5$ represented via isosurfaces of 40 % of the maximum (yellow) and minimum (blue) of the streamwise velocity component $u$.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Time evolution of the scalar field distribution produced by the energy-growth optimal perturbation (for a flow with $Re=3000$ with time horizon $T=5$) plotted in figure 16(a) at (a) $t=5$, (b) $t=10$ and (c) $t=30$, on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 17

Figure 18.Time evolution of the scalar field distribution produced by the variance-minimising optimal perturbation (for a flow with $Re=3000$ with time horizon $T=5$) plotted in figure 16(b) at (a) $t=5$, (b) $t=10$ and (c) $t=30$, on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 18

Figure 19.Time and wall-normal variation of the various production terms (as defined in (3.6)–(3.9)) for the variance-optimal flow over a time horizon of $T=10$ for a flow with $Re=3000$: (a) the base flow term $P_{\bar{u}}$; (b) the (total) perturbation term $P_{u}$; (c) the perturbation term in the $x{-}y$ plane $P_{2D}$; and (d) the three-dimensional deviation term $P_{3D}$.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Time evolution of the scalar field distribution produced by the mix-norm-optimal perturbation (for a flow with $Re=3000$ with time horizon $T=5$) plotted in figure 16(a) at (a) $t=5$, (b) $t=10$ and (c) $t=30$, on the vertical midplane at $z=\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}/2$ (left column) and the horizontal midplane $y=0$ (right column).

Figure 20

Figure 21.Time evolution of the mixing performance ${\mathcal{P}}_{Re}^{T}$ as defined in (3.17) for flows with (a) $Re=500$ and (b) $Re=3000$ and which maximise integrated energy growth (thin black dotted lines), minimise mix-norm (blue dashed lines) and minimise variance (red full lines). Flows associated with different target times are distinguished by different markers.

Figure 21

Figure 22.Time evolution of scaled mixing performances (a) ${\mathcal{E}}_{500}$ and (b) ${\mathcal{E}}_{3000}$ as defined in (3.24) and (3.25) for flows which maximise integrated energy growth (thin black dotted lines), minimise mix-norm (blue dashed lines) and minimise variance (red lines). Flows associated with different target times are distinguished by different markers.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Time evolution of the energy dissipation rate $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}(t)$ for the optimal flow fields for optimisation time horizon $T=5$, i.e. for the flow fields visualised in figures 17, 18 and 20.

Figure 23

Figure 24.Mix-norm minimisation problem (2.26) with $T=2$ and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}=1$, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}=1$. (a) The value of the scaled mix-norm $M(T)$ at the target time $T=2$, i.e. the optimised quantity defined in (B 4), as a function of the number of iterations. (b) The relative change of the optimised quantity $\unicode[STIX]{x0394}M(T)$, as defined in (B 5), as a function of the number of iterations at the target time $T=2$. (c) The scaled residual $r$ at the target time $T=2$, as defined in (B 6), as a function of the number of iterations. (d) The time evolution of the scaled mix-norm $M(t)$ for the solution after 150 iterations. Different line types denote the results from the five different resolutions as listed in table 1.

Figure 24

Table 1.Five resolutions used to test the DAL method. The resolution labelled ‘STD’ is the one used throughout the main body of the paper.