If, like me, you have trouble with sentences (written with no intended irony) such as ‘Ergo: in the beginning there was the abyss’ (p. 1) or ‘the void both invites and eludes the gaze of those who name and create’ (pp. 5–6), this book may not be for you. However, though written ‘en dificil’, Mark Thurner's History's Peru does reward its readers with valuable insights into the writing of Peruvian history. But this is not a reader-friendly book. It lacks a conventional introduction, and the reader has to await the epilogue, or some 250 pages, for a clear(-ish) statement of the book's objectives. Most of the chapters of this book have appeared in print before, so an introductory chapter explaining, at the very least, how the chapters fit together and the book's main overarching argument would have been helpful (the short preface does not really do the trick).
Despite its subtitle, History's Peru is not a conventional study of Peruvian historiography. Thurner's book establishes no dialogue with – in fact, almost entirely ignores – other studies of Peruvian historiography. Readers unfamiliar with the field could be forgiven for concluding that this is the first study ever written on the topic, since with the exception of an endnote that references studies of Jorge Basadre's oeuvre (on p. 287), there is hardly any mention of other historiographical studies, including, for example, Joseph Dager's book on the nineteenth-century historiography that Thurner discusses extensively. Instead, Thurner's intended interlocutors are authors such as, on the one hand, Edmundo O'Gorman, Elías Palti and Dipesh Chakrabarty, and, on the other, Jacques Rancière, Hayden White and Reinhart Kosselleck.
The book is therefore conceived as an intellectual history of Peruvian history in dialogue with certain approaches to the philosophy of history. It is based, according to Thurner, ‘on a pointed reading of the most influential writings of Peru's most significant historians’ (p. xiv). Thurner's anointed historians (or ‘philosophical historicists’, p. 247) are Inca Garcilaso de la Vega, Pedro de Peralta Banuevo, José Hipólito Unanue, Sebastián Lorente and Jorge Basadre. Whether Garcilaso is a ‘historian’ is perhaps a question not worth dwelling on for too long here. Given Thurner's approach it would make little sense to expect a rigorous social science-type justification for his case study selection. That said, it was not always clear to me why these and not other ‘historians’ were chosen as objects of study. Other equally significant historians that could have received attention include, for the twentieth century alone, Maria Rostworowski, Pablo Macera and Alberto Flores Galindo.
The underlying argument in the book is relatively straightforward. Thurner contends that the historical writings of authors as different as Garcilaso, Unanue, Lorente and Basadre provide commensurate critiques of the Spanish and, later, European historiographical narratives that marginalised Peru by consigning it, in Thurner's terms, to the ‘antechamber of modernity’ (p. 247 and passim). In other words, taking a cue from Chakrabarty's Provincializing Europe (Princeton University Press, 2000), Thurner suggests that these authors constructed narratives of Peru's history that at once deprovincialised Peru and in turn provincialised Spain/Europe. These historical narratives, Thurner adds, are not only Peruvian histories of Peru, they are ‘always already a “Peruvian history for Peru”, that is a history that is generative of a Peruvian future’ (p. 249).
To be sure, these narratives were produced in different ways – indeed, in ways expressive of, but also critical of, the dominant intellectual paradigms and geopolitical contexts in which they were inscribed. But, in Thurner's reading, they represented analogous instantiations of a common decolonial critique, a form of history-making alternative to, even undermining of, European historical thought. So, for example, Thurner's discussion of Garcilaso points to the ways in which Los comentarios reales not only founded Peru by reconstructing the history of its naming, but also produced for Peru a glorious past, by projecting the history of the newly founded Peru back to the Inca empire, and a glorious future, by transferring ‘sovereignty from the Incas to Charles V’ (p. 10) and therefore raising Peru to the level of a global empire.
Similarly, Unanue's historical writings, Thurner suggests, ‘became sites of critique from which to provincialize the pompous historical claims of the newly ascendant northwestern corner of the continent that now claimed to speak for Europe’ (p. 100). In the case of Lorente, who Thurner argues has been wrongly overlooked by historians of Peru as the key pivotal figure in Peruvian historiography – indeed, ‘the founder of contemporary historical studies in republican Peru’ (p. 197) – the historian's work was a direct challenge to European historical narratives about the rest of the world: ‘Lorente's narrative suggests that … historicist concepts such as “soul” and even “progress” could underwrite a discourse that ran contemporaneous and parallel rather than behind and subordinate to “Europe”’ (p. 142). Basadre's writings, too, ‘propel Peru toward a future whose “historical reason” must be distinct from that of modern Europe’ (p. 235).
Thurner suggests that ‘if world history is something more than a European invention, then Peru is a good place to look for that “something more”’ (p. xiii). But arguably the point is that Peru is as good a place as any other place, and therefore no better than any other place, to look for that something more. All ‘national’ histories exhibit the same rhetorical manoeuvrings that Thurner finds in the work of Garcilaso and in Basadre: they all, to a greater or lesser extent, reposition national history in ways that challenge its supposed marginality to ‘universal’ history. In that sense, history's Peru is also history's Australia and history's Mauritania. Thurner says as much in his baroque style: ‘any “past” exists for the world of names of history only to the extent that its future or “posterity” has become a present in which its trace may be apprehended and written’ (p. 257).
So Peru in this book plays the role of a testing ground for, or place of enunciation of, the idea that histories other than European universalising history not only exist, but exist to challenge that universalising history. It is, then, less a book about Peru's history than one about history's Peru. But, in fact, Thurner has many interesting things to say about the writing of history in Peru; that is to say, about Peru's history. His close readings of the historians he studies, particularly Lorente and Basadre, and the broader intellectual milieux in which they operated and which their work both reacted to and reflected, represent important contributions to the study of Peruvian historiography. They help trace, among other things, the genealogy of key leitmotifs in Peruvian historical writing and historical consciousness. Although unconventional, and certainly not an easy read, History's Peru may nevertheless be read profitably by Peru's historians and history's Peruvians.
Note: The previous two reviews were commissioned from Paulo Drinot before he became an editor of the JLAS.
