Like the poor, health care rationing it seems is forever with us. Thanks largely to the last Labour government's injection of significant new money into the NHS over several years to tackle lengthy waiting lists and staff shortages, mention of rationing has not been much in evidence in recent years. All that is destined to change as NHS funding goes into sharp decline and the assault on the national deficit gathers pace. This book is therefore timely, although there may be readers who groan at another text on the topic when in fact the literature is already sizeable and rich. The authors anticipate such a reaction claiming that their contribution is different and that they are seeking to offer support to those working in health care with responsibility for priority setting. There is some truth in the claim but it should not be overstated.
Perhaps inevitably much of the book adds little to what is already known. The familiar and well-trodden arguments about rational rationing, and the need for greater explicitness, versus the case for implicit or covert rationing are rehearsed, if rather peremptorily. The book dips somewhat selectively into the literature in support of its thesis that implicit rationing is no longer acceptable and that the direction favoured by everyone engaged in the difficult and messy business of rationing is for greater rationality in decision making. This may be how economists view the world but others, either not mentioned or only in passing, might beg to differ. Even so, the authors acknowledge that since rationing constitutes a complex wicked problem, expecting total rationality to prevail and to trump politics (which, of course, has its own rationality) is being unrealistic. In practice, they concede, the world of health care rationing will continue to be one where a form of ‘muddling through’ persists even if one were to wish it could be otherwise.
The challenge is how far it is possible to improve on muddling through. Here the authors claim to break new ground by reviewing and bringing together in a single text a range of methods and tools devised by health economists to assist with both investment, and more crucially in the current resource climate, disinvestment decisions. These include economic evaluation, multi-criteria decision analysis, accountability for reasonableness and deliberative citizen engagement, and their application to practice is assessed. A second novel feature is to explore notions of leadership and organisational change in complex settings in order to articulate the need for a particular style of leadership if rationing is to be carried out with greater rigour and effectiveness.
Despite a useful chapter on the politics of rationing and the importance of governance in ensuring a fair and just system of surfacing values and allocating resources, the authors do not get beneath the surface of the dilemma about how far it is possible to ration rationally when the issues are so intensely political, often have life and death consequences, and are embedded in organisational contexts and professional cultures and practices. Indeed, there is some confusion as to where precisely the authors themselves stand on the issue. For instance, on page 1 they acknowledge that while making explicit priority setting a core function of health service planning and delivery is long overdue, ‘the solutions to the problems of rationing remain elusive’. A few pages later, they state unequivocally that ‘in this text, we support the claim that explicit priority setting is a valid response to the problems arising from resource scarcity in health care’ (p. 8). By page 12 they seem to have accepted that ‘most health systems are a complex weave of explicit and implicit approaches’ when it comes to managing scarce resources. What their analysis overlooks is the idea that notions such as rationing and resource scarcity are socially constructed realities. They are not givens or immutable in the way economists assume them to be.
Although the book provides a useful exploration and review of some of the issues that remain far from being resolved in respect of rationing heath care, it is no substitute for revisiting the extant literature on the subject, little of which is done justice in this slim volume. In particular, as mentioned, the case for implicit rationing is treated as being ethically dubious and therefore unacceptable. But such hasty dismissal may be presumptuous at a descriptive, if not normative, level. And this is where health economists tend to come unstuck even when seeking to comprehend the complex reality faced by decision makers. There remains a barely concealed frustration, commendably absent from this book, that if only decision makers could see the logic of the situation, they would seize and apply tools like Programme Budgeting and Marginal Analysis (PBMA) with vigour and conviction. But the fact is that, despite being around for many years, PBMA has yet to make a significant impact across the NHS. The authors do not really confront this inconvenient truth, although it is implicit in their discussion of the politics of priority setting.
Similarly, the discussion of leadership styles − while useful in linking the methods and tools available with what needs to happen in terms of ensuring that the organisational context is appropriate for, and receptive to, their application − suffers from being a little too superficial to be wholly convincing. Nevertheless, there is the germ of an important topic and relationship that merits further exploration.
Finally, an important message from the book is the need for more interdisciplinary research. Many of the tricky issues around rationing are to be found at the interfaces between social science disciplines with the consequence that no single discipline has a monopoly of wisdom. There is a need to challenge the dominant economic paradigm which has tended to frame issues in a misleading and overly instrumental way. This book makes a useful contribution to that endeavour by acknowledging the work of writers on leadership and change management. It might have gone further by drawing more deeply on the insights from sociologists and political scientists. At the end of the day, there will always be limits to how far rationing health care can be made explicit since it is governed by politics and power which themselves determine the way resources are allocated. Consequently, while tools and techniques have a place, they do not promise a ‘magic bullet’. It is likely to be the softer features of making decisions and bringing about change that will matter more. Hence the importance of leadership, as the book acknowledges, but also of other factors, too, if leadership is not to fall into the trap of becoming a socially constructed and rhetorical device that conceals more than it reveals. When all is said and done, resolving the rationing dilemma is likely to owe more to the notion of ‘negotiated order’ than to the application of any particular tool or method.
