I Neglected harmonisation of consumer services
Whilst the European legislators have extensively regulated the sale of consumer goods, they have somewhat neglected the harmonisation of rules governing contracts for the provision of services to consumers. The meaningful exception is the adoption of the Package Travel Directive 90/314/EEC to regulate the provision of package travel services in the tourism sector. However, even this service-oriented European consumer legislative act had a minimum harmonisation character. Whether the adoption of the new Package Travel Directive 2015/2302, with its maximum harmonisation character, will start a new European legislative trend in the consumer services area remains to be seen.
Considering the lack of legislative priorities to harmonise the provision of services to consumers, it should not surprise that the academic scholarship also devotes less attention to this idea. The book of Barend van Leeuwen is a highly welcomed addition to this field. The author’s main research objective is to examine the impact of European standardisation of services on private law, the presumption being that the adoption and application of European standards in the area of consumer services should lead to the convergence of national private laws. If this presumption holds true, this should encourage the European legislators to facilitate adoption of European standards.
In order to test this hypothesis, the author examines two areas of consumer services, in the healthcare and in the tourism sector. These sectors have been selected as there have been some attempts made at standardisation in them through the Comité Europeén de Normalisation (CEN). Whilst the tourism sector is often characterised by cross-border provision of services, the healthcare sector has only more recently evolved to facilitate cross-border movement of patients. Moreover, the tourism sector was traditionally regulated by private law, whilst the healthcare provision of services fell within the scope of regulation of public law. There are also significant differences in the European legislators’ competences in regulating the provision of services in these two sectors. The choice for comparison of these two varied sectors is, therefore, justified and provides for interesting case studies throughout the book, eg on PIP breast implants or tourist guides’ training.
II New approach for services?
The first difficulty that the author acknowledged and tackled was the lack of harmonised European standards in the area of consumer services. The announcement of the New Approach to consumer products confirmed the EU legislators’ competences to adopt European standards for consumer goods. The objective behind this announcement was to prevent the formation of national barriers to the free movement of goods. Despite the freedom of provision of services being one of the fundamental freedoms in EU law, the adoption of national requirements for the provision of services is still perceived as less susceptible to impede the well-functioning of the internal market. One of the reasons for this thinking is that many services are still unlikely to be provided cross-border. The author’s choice of consumer services sectors neutralises this justification for not adopting further harmonisation measures therein. Even if healthcare services were traditionally provided locally, in recent years healthcare tourism grew as patients started showing more initiative in seeking better and/ or cheaper healthcare abroad. Tourism services traditionally are associated with cross-border provision of services, and, therefore, the European legislator has attempted to harmonise this area. Still, there are merely a few European standards adopted in these two sectors, with their adoption remaining controversial and application wanting. Van Leeuwen points out that in these two different services’ areas, the lack of adoption of European standards is often the result of the missing consensus as to the benchmarks for their quality and safety.
III Quality versus safety
The author conducted a detailed and comprehensive analysis of the healthcare and tourism sectors, which included interviews with stakeholders. This allowed Van Leeuwen to share with the readers the stakeholders’ concerns as to the impact that the adoption of the European standards could have on the quality of the provided services. In the healthcare sector, analysed in Chapter 4, the fear is that the standards would be adopted by organisations that are not fully representative of the medical profession, which could endanger the quality of the healthcare services provided on the basis of such standards. In the tourism sector, discussed in Chapter 5, the same concern as to the impact of the European standardisation on quality has been displayed, but it was rather motivated by the competitive nature of tourism service providers. The difference in applied quality benchmarks allows tourism service providers to distinguish themselves from competitors. They express fears, therefore, that they would lose this advantage as a result of the European standardisation. The author suggests, following on the stakeholders’ views, that the solution to this concern would be for the European standards to focus on providing safety rather than quality benchmarks. Perhaps such an approach would allow the European legislators to get involved, as it could overcome the reluctance of the stakeholders to the adoption of the European standards.
IV Convergence of private law?
The involvement of the European legislators seems necessary if European standards are to be used to further harmonise the provision of services to consumers among the Member States. Van Leeuwen calls it one of the paradoxes of the convergence that whilst standardisation could be used to further strengthen the internal market, the European institutions are not taking control thereof. Unfortunately, only with the adoption of more European standards in the area of consumer services, could we empirically examine their impact on the convergence of national private laws. The author proposes two ways through which European standardisation of services could have an impact on national private laws, namely, through contract law and tort law (Chapter 6), as well as free movement law and competition law (Chapter 7).
Even if more European standards will be adopted, it is still necessary that national courts and stakeholders apply them in private law. This could be done either by directly incorporating European standards in services contracts or by using them to determine the standard of proof in liability cases. In either case, the European standards would influence national private laws and, most likely, gradually contribute to further convergence thereof.
V Model PhD book
Clearly, whilst writing his PhD book Van Leeuwen encountered many obstacles to test his hypothesis that further European standardisation could positively impact convergence of national private laws. There are few case studies that he could examine, and they do not fully explore the potential of European standardisation, due to the reluctant application of the European standards by national stakeholders and courts. It seems, therefore, that the author had to compromise his claims and, for example, look beyond the direct effect of application of European standards in private law to their evidentiary role; beyond a possibility to use standards for determining services’ quality to only looking at their safety benchmarks. Whilst we may start reading this book hoping that it might provide sufficient incentive to the European legislators to take further steps in the regulation of the provision of services to consumers, the final claims made in it are not ground-breaking. It is, rather, a solid study of the status quo, indicating all its drawbacks, but not making bold claims as to the way forward.
That being said, Van Leeuwen’s book could definitely be recommended to PhD students and their supervisors as a reference source. It has a very logical structure, with the author’s methodology and research objectives clearly outlined from the first pages. All the methodological choices, such as the choice to discuss the two chosen services sectors and not to conduct a comprehensive comparative law analysis, have been convincingly justified. Each chapter has its own introduction and provisional conclusions, with the consistent cross-referencing between chapters not letting the reader lose track of the author’s thoughts and intentions. Despite the many different areas of private law discussed, their presentation is coherent and the chosen case studies enticing. Here is to hoping that this book inspires all current and future PhD students in the area of private law (and beyond it) to write as lucidly, and to convey their research results in such an appealing fashion.
