Beyond Imported Magic is a compilation of papers seeking to give individuals, institutions and Latin American nations a voice in the building of their scientific history. It also highlights the importance of understanding the local and national contexts in the production processes of scientific and technological knowledge along with the development of international networks. Without discounting the obvious interrelations with developed countries, the book highlights the role of actors usually less visible in the construction process of intellectual and scientific production in Latin America.
The book avoids the typical Eurocentric approach dominant in Science and Technology Studies (STS), rescuing a regional identity, often ignored or neglected. It can be considered a product of a process that began three decades ago when historians, anthropologists and sociologists of Latin America began to address local factors, trying to understand the local complexities and richness of the field. This process resulted in the creation of study groups and institutions in STS in the region.
The contributions to this compilation are varied. This is one of the strengths of the book, which covers a wide range of subjects, topics, historical contexts. It is divided into three parts, which together manage to delve into the complex regional scientific scene. The first part considers the Latin American perspectives in studies of science and technology through chapters that focus on specific cases of the development and scientific practice. For example, Cukierman explores the Manguinhos Institute's expeditions in Brazil in the early twentieth century that helped build the idea of a Brazilian identity as one nation, as well as the idea of a double colonisation (scientific and physical). Pérez Bustos, Olarte and Díaz del Castillo delve into the issue of gender and how certain scientific practices such as forensic genetics in Colombia became invisible or non-scientific. These are all consistent chapters that provide new ways of understanding the limitations and contributions of local scientific efforts.
The second part of the book focuses on how scientific knowledge travels and spreads between communities and nations and how the formation of scientific networks affects the production of scientific and technological knowledge. Rodríguez analyses the use of fingerprints in detective work in Argentina as a pioneering effort since they were used much later in Europe. Palmarola explores the confluence of science, technology and ideology in the use of concrete panels for housing in Cuba. In doing so, he argues that the process of adaptation of Soviet technology can be understood as a local appropriation of what initially was a foreign technology. Cox Hall talks about the first picture of Machu Picchu and how the camera was used as a negotiated practice (‘charismatic device’). Although Europe is very much present, the focus is on the local appropriations and developments.
The third part of the book focuses on local and global networks related to innovation and the relationship between science, technology and politics in Latin America. Technology and politics determine bureaucratic decisions affecting how science and technology are produced and used in order to achieve political goals. This third part includes Hageod and Mateos and Díaz Suarez's chapter on nuclear energy and the Cold War, Tironi and Barandiaran's chapter on Chilean energy policy and Delgado and Rodríguez Giralt's discussion of the struggle of Brazilian peasants to include native seeds (Creole seeds) in the national insurance system and Biehl's analysis of the right to health in Brazil.
The book can be praised for many reasons. First, it includes a diversity of topics, many of them original and previously unexplored (e.g. the pioneering analysis of fingerprints in Argentina, the One Laptop per Child programme in Puno, Peru, and Colombian geneticists working in contexts of political and domestic violence). Second, the variety of the primary sources used presents the state's official view of science and technology and public perception of science and technology. In addition to government plans and newspaper sources, the book uses interviews, magazine covers, and literature and official documents of the police department. The authors have thus shown creativity not only on the topics selected but also on the type of sources used to support their research.
The various studies focus primarily on countries such as Argentina, Brazil, Cuba, Mexico, but also cover more ‘peripheral’ countries such as Paraguay. It encourages us to rethink issues and approaches to the history of science and medicine. Beyond Imported Magic will be a reference for all of those involved and interested in the processes of obtaining, constructing and disseminating scientific knowledge in Latin America and serve as a guide for future research. The book also moves away from the issues repeatedly worked in the history of science providing fresh perspectives and topics. It is thus a book that must be considered for any researcher that studies the history of science in the region.
