Maureen Flanagan, the inaugural editor of The Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, has, with this book, continued to pioneer in the field. Indeed, Flanagan's America Reformed has, in the five years since its publication, become the standard textbook for the period. Unlike most textbooks, which tend toward the bland and banal, America Reformed serves as an excellent intellectual reflection of the field; it will also surely continue to serve as an important shaper of future scholarly discourse.
The subtitle reveals one of Flanagan's most important arguments. Flanagan's progressives come in all flavors and varieties, and progressivisms were determinedly plural. Without a lot of fuss and bother, Flanagan clears away a decades-old problem, as scholars believed that they had to either offer a distinctive unified portrait of “the” progressives or else pronounce them non-existent. Instead, Flanagan lets a thousand (well, at least a dozen) progressives and progressivisms bloom—a commonsense intellectual move that should forever change the way historians discuss the early twentieth century.
That said, Flanagan concentrates on progressives who focused on social justice, politics, economics, and foreign policy. These reformers moved in and out of coalitions with each other, but their distinctive concerns and methods mean that in Flanagan's hands they ultimately became different types of activists. “Economic progressives”—whose primary national policy goal at one point was, for example, the Federal Trade Commission—hoped, most of all, to stabilize and regulate a liberal capitalist economy. “Social justice progressives”—whose primary policy goals were measures such as mother's pensions—in contrast, sought not only to provide aid and dignity for the downtrodden but even beyond that, to deepen human connections that had grown increasingly tenuous. All of these progressivisms led to greater civic engagement, and a deeper democracy, at the same time that they “challenge[d] one another as much as they challenged the existing institutions” (28).
Women were at the core of social justice progressivism, and they are at the heart of the stories that Flanagan tells. Flanagan does not neglect the largely men's realms of the FTC, or the Federal Reserve, or antitrust. Still, she often begin chapters with female reformers, and national “mainstream” politics is required to fit itself into the activism of women, rather than the other way around—whether on matters of public health, suffrage, or labor relations.
In her most daring interpretation, Flanagan makes it clear that women were as deeply political as men and that previous scholars' attempts to turn female reformers' motivations into a maternalist “wanting to ‘help’” (88) is essentialist and therefore wrong. Flanagan herself seeks to advance a contrasting subversively “unsafe” (88) gendered argument based on “experience” rather than essence: men based their politics on the hierarchical corporation; women on the familial home.
Readers will have to determine for themselves how much this analysis truly escapes essentialism. After admitting that “there were men who agreed with women and vice versa on issues of political progressivism,” Flanagan more boldly declares that “the preponderance of evidence shows female and male reformers assessing the problem from a different perspective and arriving at different conclusions about causes and solutions. Women almost always spoke about the social responsibility of all citizens and the municipal government to do something about housing immediately. . . . Men continued to focus on mechanisms and instruments, and always on private enterprise” (83). Still, Flanagan's ideas (which she lays out in more detail in her monograph, Seeing With Their Hearts: Chicago Women and the Vision of the Good City, 1871–1933) are challenging, requiring engagement from feminist and non-feminist scholars alike.Footnote 1
Throughout all of Flanagan's explorations, there is a refreshing respect for, and in fact even a general judgment in favor of, her protagonists. Unlike previous generations of scholars (especially Hofstadter-influenced consensusites and New Left-inspired radicals), Flanagan sees no need to condemn first and ask questions later. Rather, and without excusing their mistakes on issues such as racial equality, she engages all the progressives as well-intentioned, thoughtful, and genuinely democratic citizens.
At times, Flanagan's judgments can come, unexpectedly, in the midst of a normal scholarly discussion of an issue such as immigration. As she rightly notes, “Compassion and extending a ‘helping hand’ to others—even if at times these seemed condescending attitudes—exposed a faith in a common humanity and the innate decency of people that challenged the exclusionists and overt racists. This idea also was a product of the Progressive Era” (112). At other moments, she offers complex and fair-minded formal conclusions, as with the book's final sentence: “Despite its shortcomings, progressivism made the United States by the mid-1920s a far more orderly, well-regulated, and fairer society than it had been in the 1890s” (286).
America Reformed is not without its shortcomings. Despite its intellectual innovations, in most places the prose suffers from traditional textbook sluggishness. Despite the introduction of many new characters and perspectives into the stories of progressivisms, Flanagan frequently plays it safe in terms of her relatively standard treatment of more mainstream characters, such as Upton Sinclair and Theodore Roosevelt. Despite her careful attempts to make sure not to essentialize her categories of progressives, Flanagan does tend to create stark divisions between different types of political actors that deeper research and reflection is unlikely to fully sustain.
In all, however, America Reformed is very good news for those of us in the Gilded Age/Progressive Era business. Along with Rebecca Edwards's New Spirits, Oxford's delightfully eclectic companion text on the Gilded Age, Maureen Flanagan's book will be invigorating courses at both the undergraduate and graduate level for years to come.
