Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 June 2005
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan has a population of more than 145 million people, about 95% of whom are Muslims (approximately 20% Shi'i and the rest Sunni). Although it has a few large cities such as Karachi, almost 65% of the country is still rural, with a per capita income of $408 per year. The overall literacy rate is estimated to be 41.5% but is much lower for women in many of the provinces. Pakistan has a complex culture with many ethnic groups and socioeconomic strata, but overall the society is characterized by hierarchical systems in both private and public domains. The population is religious and family centered with the “family” understood as extending beyond the nuclear; it is not uncommon to have three generations residing under one roof or within close proximity to each other and pooling their resources.
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan has a population of more than 145 million people, about 95% of whom are Muslims (approximately 20% Shi'i and the rest Sunni). Although it has a few large cities such as Karachi, almost 65% of the country is still rural, with a per capita income of $408 per year. The overall literacy rate is estimated to be 41.5% but is much lower for women in many of the provinces.1
United Nations Development Program (UNDP). Human Development Report. 2004.
As is the case in many developing countries, Pakistan is experiencing an increase in high-tech, tertiary-level medicine such as advanced cardiology, state-of-the-art cardiac surgery, major joint replacements, reproductive technology, and organ transplantation. Healthcare is provided free of charge through public (government-run) clinics and hospitals, but these institutions are generally understaffed, overcrowded, and inefficient, and many have a reputation for providing substandard care. In the past decade there has been a proliferation of private healthcare institutions, especially in the larger cities, that utilize a fee-for-service system. However, due to existing poverty and an absence of national health coverage or health insurance schemes, many remain beyond the reach of a majority of the population.
The primary aim of this paper is to give an account of the current status of biomedical ethics in Pakistan. This report, we hope, will address Alastair Campbell's statement that little is found so far about “non-Western world views in the Bioethics literature.”2
Campbell AV. Presidential address: Global bioethics—Dream or nightmare? Bioethics 1999;13:183–90.
In Pakistan it is primarily members of the medical community, many trained in Western institutions, who take the lead in introducing modern biomedical ethics into the country. The first formal move in this direction occurred in 1984 at the Aga Khan University (AKU) in Karachi, the first private university to be established in Pakistan. Biomedical ethics was introduced in the curriculum of medical students at AKU by the Chairman of the Department of Community Health Sciences3
The Chairman at the time was Jack Bryant, an American public health physician with extensive experience in working in developing countries. He is also one of the drafters of the first ethical guidelines for biomedical research issued by the Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences (CIOMS).
Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 5th ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.
At the time, one of the authors (Moazam) was the associate dean of the Aga Khan University postgraduate medical education (residency programs) and instrumental in making bioethics a mandatory part of resident education. For details of the evolution of bioethical activities at AKU, see Jafarey A. The bioethics group of the Aga Khan University, Karachi. Issues in Medical Ethics 2002;X:165–6.
Ethics Review Committees (ERC) are a relatively new phenomenon in Pakistan, although there is a gradual move within a few private healthcare institutions to initiate such committees.6
Besides AKU, which has had a standing committee to review institutional research proposals for a decade, another private university in Karachi, Ziauddin Medical University, has recently set up such a committee and another private sector institution, the Liaquat National Hospital and Postgraduate Institute, has expressed an interest in doing so. The web site of the Office of Human Research Protection (OHRP) of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services currently lists eight Ethics Review Committees in Pakistan that are approved. Of these, three are located in universities and five are names of NGOs. Available from http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/.
For a list of some of the articles related to bioethics from Pakistani authors see Hyder AA, Nadeem S. Health ethics in Pakistan: A literature review of its present state. Journal of Health Population and Nutrition 2001;19:6–11.
Standing Hospital or Clinical Ethics Committees are still a rarity in Pakistan. To date, the AKU Hospital is the only institution with a formal ethics consultation service, which is one of the functions of its Hospital Ethics Committee (HEC), initiated in 2000.8
For an account of how indigenous cultural and religious values inevitably influence ethics consultants, their deliberations, and actions, see Moazam F, Zaman RM. At the interface of cultures. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 2003;14:246–58.
In the late 1990s, a nonindexed journal, the Pakistan Journal of Medical Ethics, began publication with the objective of promoting medical ethics. Unfortunately, due to insufficient financial support and inadequate organizational structure, only half a dozen sporadic issues have been published since then.
In Pakistan a growing interest in biomedical ethics is reflected in the increase over the past few years in the number of workshops and conferences related to bioethics being organized in both the public and private sectors. In Pakistan, as in the rest of the world, there has been a great demand for research-ethics-related programs. This is due to the fact that most international funding agencies and many peer-reviewed scientific journals now require ethical review of research protocols and manuscripts for acceptance. These events provide valuable experience to the researchers, increasing their chances for obtaining funding as well as publication. In addition, with the rapid increase in collaborative research between industrialized nations and developing countries, it is easier to find international funding for activities connected to research ethics and there is a willingness on the part of faculty (especially from established centers in North America) to help run research ethics workshops. This is exemplified by the Global Forum on Bioethics in Research (GFBR), a collaborative effort of several international organizations, which aims at strengthening research ethics in developing countries. The GFBR has selected Karachi, Pakistan, as the venue for their annual meeting scheduled for 2006.
Similar to the experience of other developing countries, Pakistan has benefited from the international focus on research ethics as a prominent feature of the “globalization” of contemporary bioethics. In the past five years, a handful of Pakistani physicians from a private university in Karachi have taken the opportunity to pursue fellowships and master's degree programs in Australia, Canada, and the United States through funding from the National Institutes of Health and the Fogarty International Center meant particularly for enhancing research ethics capacity in developing world scientists. The Eastern Mediterranean Regional Organization (EMRO) of WHO has also expressed an interest in strengthening research ethics capacity and is funding a situation analysis of research capacity in the countries of the region, including Pakistan. One of the authors (Jafarey) is currently a participant in this project but has extended the survey beyond research to general bioethics capacity in Pakistan.
Also on the rise, and considered as more relevant by a greater number of healthcare professionals in Pakistan, is an interest in what constitutes ethical medical practice in light of the changing face of medicine due to advances in medical science and biotechnology. Sessions in medical conferences organized by medical colleges and universities as well as medical organizations are being frequently devoted to clinical ethical dilemmas and how these are to be addressed against the background of indigenous cultural and religious values and local socioeconomic realities. In the period of 2003–2004 alone, such sessions were arranged by the Dow Medical College, Liaquat National Hospital and Postgraduate Institute, the Aga Khan University, the Pakistan Society of Urological Surgeons, the National Research Institute of Fertility Control, and the National Skin Center. The Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplantation, located in Karachi, has regularly devoted at least one session to ethics in its biennial international conference for more than a decade. The topics chosen for discussion have included ethical and economic factors influencing related kidney donation, treatment of infants with end-stage renal disease, views of Muslim scholars on organ transplantation and brain death, and Islamic perspectives on xenotransplantation
What is striking in the explosive increase in conferences and seminars devoted to clinical ethics is that besides considering the “secular” aspects of bioethics including a language of the four bioethical principles, there is a growing emphasis on exploring traditional Muslim ethical sources and opinions of contemporary Muslim ulema (scholars) and jurists on a wide variety of topics including brain death criteria, issues connected to death and dying, discontinuation of ventilatory support, organ and xenotransplantation, abortions, reproductive technology, and cloning. In the spring of 2004, the Pakistan Islamic Medical Association (a nongovernmental organization) conducted a heavily attended medical symposium that included sessions on Islamic medical ethics and the ethical challenges posed by emerging technologies. The discussants included both physicians and invited Muslim scholars, and they covered issues as diverse as training in medical ethics, ethical issues connected to pharmaceutical marketing, physician–patient relationships, and Islamic views about assisted reproductive technologies.
In October 2004, one of the authors (Moazam) was invited to an international clinical ethics seminar held at the Aga Khan University in which speakers were invited from the United States and the United Kingdom but also included national and regional religious scholars. She herself was requested by the organization committee to address Islamic sources in an understanding of what constitutes ethical conduct for physicians and other healthcare professionals. The response of the audience to her talk entitled “Foundational Concepts of Ethics in Islam” was noteworthy, as it was for other presentations that covered Islamic perspectives on abortions, Muslim juristic rulings on death and dying, and the role of Muslim physicians in the care of terminally ill patients.
The PMDC is the government regulating body that registers all graduates from medical and dental colleges in Pakistan. In 2002, it published a revised and extensive Code of Ethics for all practitioners and included a recommendation that education in bioethics be made part of the curricula. A review of the Code reveals an interesting mix of, and we believe a tension between, philosophically grounded elements of contemporary bioethics and moral values drawn from Islamic teachings. The four principles of contemporary bioethics (autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice) are stated in the Code as being “fundamental elements” of the relationship between the patient and physician. Nevertheless, the point is also made that “if secular Western bioethics can be described as rights-based, with a strong emphasis on individual rights, Islamic bioethics is based on duties and obligations” of the physician. While discussing appropriate care of patients, the Code advises that the practitioner must “adhere to veracity (truth telling) as judged in the patient's interest.” Practitioners are also reminded that “Islamic bioethics is intimately linked to the broad ethical teachings of the Holy Qur'an and the tradition of the Prophet Mohammad,” and that unlike “secular” oaths the “Oath of the Muslim Doctor” invokes “the name of Allah.”9
The Pakistan Medical and Dental Council. Code of Ethics for Medical and Dental Practitioners. 2002;Aug:5–7, 12. The entire code of ethics is available from http://www.pmdc.org.pk/ethics.htm.
Based on a realization of the importance of bioethics, the government of Pakistan approved in January 2004 the constitution of a National Bioethics Committee (NBC) to be chaired by the Director General Health in the Ministry of Health, and with the Pakistan Medical Research Council (PMRC) acting as its secretariat. In the note circulated by the government, the NBC is stated as functioning as “an advisory body dealing with all aspects of bioethics in the health sector in the country.” It is expected to “promote and facilitate ethical health services delivery and health research” and to work through two subcommittees: the Research Ethics Committee and the Medical Ethics Committee. The recommended membership of 20–21 individuals includes 2 each of “Bio Scientists” and “Academics,” and 2 representatives from Universities/Medical Colleges. Also included are 1 each from the categories of General Practitioners, Nurses, Social Scientists, Lawyers, Religious Scholars, Industry, and the Human Rights Commission.10
For details, see the Pakistan government document entitled “The Gazette of Pakistan, Published by Authority,” Part IV, Registered No. M.302, Ministry of Health, Islamabad, 2004 Jan 12; 8–9.
In the past decade, contemporary bioethics and questions about how it should interface with indigenous cultural and religious (Muslim) beliefs, moral values, and socioeconomic realities has evoked a tremendous response within Pakistan. This interest has been largely spearheaded by the efforts of members of the medical community. These efforts, however, had been without tangible institutional support in the form of a dedicated department or center of biomedical ethics within either the public or private sector. In 2004, recognizing the need for an organizational structure dedicated to promoting discussion on these issues and fostering educational and research activities in bioethics, Adibul Hasan Rizvi, the Director and transplant surgeon of the Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplantation (SIUT) in Karachi, took the initiative to establish such a center.11
The plans for the Center of Biomedical Ethics and Culture, its objectives, and its activities were worked out between Dr. Adibul Hasan Rizvi and one of the authors (Moazam) over 2002–2004. She was subsequently offered, and accepted, the position of chairperson for the Center.
The Center of Biomedical Ethics and Culture (CBEC), located on the premises of SIUT, was inaugurated on October 8, 2004, and received wide press coverage. The 300 invitees to the event included representatives from WHO and EMRO and faculty from the Center of Biomedical Ethics at the University of Virginia. Atta-ur-Rahman, Pakistan's Federal Minister, Adviser to the Prime Minister on Science and Technology and Chairman of the country's Higher Education Commission, attended as chief guest. In his speech, Atta-ur-Rahman noted the importance and need for such a Center in Pakistan and promised support for its activities. He also informed the audience of the plans by the Higher Education Commission to establish an International Center of Bioethics in the country that would undertake “research and educational activities on both national and international levels.”12
Biomedical ethics, culture centre at SIUT. Dawn 2004;9:17.
The brochure circulated at the inauguration listed the primary goal of CBEC as being to serve as “an academic and intellectual national resource” and to assist in “capacity building of future faculty and staff in biomedical ethics” for the country. An important function of CBEC was stated to be to explore “the role of cultural, societal and religious norms in shaping indigenous value systems that are seminal components of human moral comprehension.” The audience was also provided information about a seminar and intensive course being planned by CBEC for the spring of 2005 entitled “Foundations of Moral Thought” that would include national and international bioethicists, sociologists, and Muslim scholars as speakers.13
The international speakers who have agreed to participate in the April 2005 Course include Jonathan Moreno, Director of the Center for Biomedical Ethics at the University of Virginia (UVA), Aziz Sachedina, Muslim scholar from the Department of Religious Studies, UVA, and Renee C. Fox, Annenberg Professor Emerita of Social Sciences at the University of Pennsylvania.
In many industrialized countries such as the United States, philosophers and theologians are considered to have played major roles in the birth of contemporary bioethics.14
For a good discussion of the role and interaction of philosophy and religion in the evolution of bioethics in the United States, see Messikomer CM, Fox RC, Swazey JP. The presence and influence of religion in American bioethics. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 2001;44:485–508.
The short history of a still nascent contemporary bioethics in Pakistan reveals the ways in which it is being influenced and molded by local values and existing realities that differ in significant ways from those in countries where modern bioethics was founded. The advent of bioethics as a subject of interest and relevance to healthcare professionals can be traced to the medical college and faculty of a private university in Karachi rather than to philosophical and theological discourse or public and legal pressures. The impetus for the growth in activities related to bioethics in Pakistan is primarily pragmatic and largely coming from members of the healthcare community, especially physicians, some (by no means all) of whom have received part of their medical training in the United States or the United Kingdom. Many of them are involved in tertiary care medical practice.
The soil of Pakistan like many other developing countries has been very receptive to biomedical advances that have brought with them a capacity for tertiary-level interventions extending from reproductive technology to organ transplantations. With this has come a growing realization among healthcare professionals that the biotechnology in Pakistan may be identical to that in the West, but it is being applied in a country with a very different epistemology of what constitutes right and wrong and how this is to be determined. Reason is considered an important human faculty, but many Pakistanis, Muslim physicians and laypersons alike, believe that it is an incomplete guide for chartering realms that extend beyond the purely “scientific.” In this view, when reflecting on morality and ethics, reason must take into account long-standing religious and cultural norms as well as an interpretation of Islamic law.15
For an elaboration of this concept, see Moazam F. Families, patients, and physicians in medical decisionmaking: A Pakistani perspective. Hastings Center Report 2000;30:28–37.