Deborah Tor's book presents a fascinating study of the phenomenon of ‘ayyari in the eastern Islamic world in the ninth to eleventh centuries. ‘Ayyari is a term that has generally been understood as having negative connotations, and has traditionally been associated with brigandage. Tor's book overturns our understanding of the term, and shows how the ‘ayyars were originally associated with religious warfare. The bulk of Violent Order analyses ‘ayyari with a particular emphasis on the first Saffarid dynasty that ruled Khurasan and Sistan in the ninth and early tenth centuries, before losing most of their territories to the Samanid rulers of Transoxiana. The Saffarids were the first and only ‘ayyar state of the Islamic world and at least two thirds of the book is devoted to them, making this a study of prime importance for our understanding of this little known state, which to date has been the subject of only one monograph in a western language, by C. E. Bosworth.
The first chapter of Violent Order is devoted to analysing the history of the term ‘ayyar, and Tor ably demonstrates that at least until the late tenth century it did not have any negative connotations, and gained chivalric connotations in the eleventh century with the involvement of ‘ayyars in the sectarian politics of Baghdad. Chapter Two discusses the origins of the ‘ayyars, and links the development of the ‘ayyar phenomenon to the proto-Sunni mutatawwi'a, an ascetic group devoted to pursuing jihad on the frontiers of the Islamic world against the unbelievers beyond. During the eighth and ninth centuries these mutatawwi'a, who were closely linked to the ‘Traditionists’, carried out warfare, especially against Byzantium and the Turks east of Transoxiana, as a group entirely separate from the ‘Abbasid government, whom they regarded with some suspicion. As well as fighting the infidel, the mutatawwi'a fought Muslim heretics, and especially the Kharijites, who had gained considerable strength in the east, especially Sistan. It seems, as far as one can make out on the basis of the rather sketchy sources, that ‘ayyar was the name given to members of what were effectively mutatawwi'a bands who undertook jihad against the Kharijites of Sistan.
It was in this milieu that the Saffarid dynasty emerged, the subject of Chapters Three, Four, Five and Six of Violent Order. That the Saffarids originated as anti-Kharijite militia has long been known, but Tor demonstrates that the association of the dynasty with brigandage is the product of later historiography. Rather, she paints an entirely new picture for us of the founder of the Saffarid dynasty, Ya'qub b. al-Layth, as neither a brigand nor a Persian nationalist (as some scholars have assumed on rather slight evidence), but rather as an ascetic and devout figure motivated above all by the desire to promote Islam, both during his early career and later when he had developed a sizeable empire. Tor shows how the Saffarid dynasty was strongly supported by the Sunni ‘Traditionist’ scholars, and how Ya'qub drew widespread support, even from former Tahirid supporters, for his occupation of the Tahirid lands of Khurasan owing to that dynasty's failure to adequately combat religious dissent (from a Sunni Traditionist point of view). Especially valuable is Chapter Five, dealing with the relationship between the Caliphate and the Saffarids, which casts new light on the caliphs' attempts to use the emergent dynasties of the eastern Islamic world to shore up their own position, and set them at odds with each other to weaken them to the caliphs' advantage.
Chapters Seven and Eight focus largely on ‘ayyars in the post-Saffarid period. Chaper Seven deals with the connection between ‘ayyars, futuwwa (very roughly: chivalry) and Sufism, and Tor argues that by the tenth century, futuwwa and ‘ayyari were starting to be linked, although the only references to support this are a brief reference in Tabari and one in Bal'ami – and it should be noted that the text of the latter's work is too problematic to allow us to attribute this phrase to the tenth century with certainty. The evidence from the eleventh century is much more convincing, with an unambiguous passage in the Qabusnama showing the existence, at least for some circles, of a clear connection between ‘ayyari and chivalrous behaviour. The final chapter of the book draws interesting comparisons between the ‘ayyars and the knights of mediaeval Europe. Tor argues that violence was as much of a part of the ‘ayyar ethos as it was for the western knight, and that the ‘ayyars use of force was often linked to power struggles in the elite or to disputes between the Sunnis and Shi'ites of Baghdad. Indeed, she ably demonstrates that the ‘ayyars often formed part of the elite themselves.
Tor's book is well researched and thoughtful, as well as being a pleasure to read. Her basic argument is convincing, but there are a few areas where this reviewer feels that she overstates her case. In particular, she argues that the negative image of the Saffarids is due to a deliberate programme in Samanid historiography to blacken their reputation which has then fed into later works, such as Ibn Khallikan's influential passage on the dynasty, which relied on a lost Samanid work by al-Sulami. However, very little Samanid historiography survives, and thus much of this argument is based on what she presumes Samanid historical works said, rather than what we know they did. Her argument is even less convincing when the work is extant. For example, she suggests that Bal'ami's tenth-century Persian history is silent on them because the author “had nothing bad to say about the Saffarids, and therefore refrained from saying anything about them at all in order not to displease his Samanid master” (p. 91). Yet Bal'ami has nothing to say about the Samanids either, not for any superficial political reason, but because writing contemporary or near-contemporary history was not his purpose. Equally, al-Maqdisi's history, the Kitab al-Bad' wa-'l-Ta'rikh, which was probably composed for a SaffaridFootnote 1(and is not mentioned by Tor), has nothing of interest to say about either the Samanids or the Saffarids, because it did not fit in with the author's historiographical project. This theory of a successful Samanid campaign to blacken the Saffarids leads the author into some further errors. For instance, Hamzah al-Isfahani's Ta'rikh Sini Muluk al-Ard is described as a “Samanid source” (p. 209, n. 157), whereas as far as we know Isfahani wrote for the Buyids and on the few occasions he left his native town, it was to visit Baghdad. A Samanid connection is completely lacking. Tor's argument is based partly on the fact that she believes the Samanids were competing with the Saffarids for legitimacy as ghazi leaders. Doubtless the Samanids did wish to act as ghazi leaders on occasion (although jihad in tenth-century Tranoxiana evidently remained to a fair extent in private hands). However, she places far too much weight on single phrase in Hamdullah Mustawfi Qazvini's Tarikh-i Guzida (oddly described by Tor as a post-Mongol source whereas in fact it dates to the reign of the Ilkhan Abu Sa'id) that describes the ancestor of the Samanids as an ‘ayyar. This leads Tor to state “[the Samanids'] biographies proudly proclaim that the dynasty's eponymous founder was an ‘ayyar” (p. 253, see also pp. 260–261). Qazvini is writing too late to be given much credence unless a stronger argument for this conjecture is made and no contemporary or near-contemporary, source, mention it. Indeed, Tor herself has very ably pointed out how the term ‘ayyar changes in meaning over time, so it is not even clear that what Qazvini means by this phrase is what she wants it to mean.
A few minor technical flaws should be noted in an otherwise well-written and well produced book. The Arabic term al-hall wa-'l-'aqd is rather oddly translated as “all loosing and tying [i.e. the bannum]” (p. 224) rather than simply, and more comprehensibly, as “power”. At least in this reviewer's copy, p. 158 is missing, meaning that Chapter Four grinds to a halt in mid-sentence. Finally, it is a great pity that the publishers chose not to provide an index, making easy reference to the rich material Tor has gathered much harder than is desirable.
However, these criticisms apart, Tor's book is a significant contribution to our understanding of the mediaeval Islamic east, and will be required reading for anyone researching the Saffarids, Samanids or the dissolution of the Caliphate. It gives a new context to our understanding of the so-called ‘Persian Renaissance’, and is in sum an impressive work of scholarship.
