Written for pre-service music educators as well as those already in the field, Navigating Music and Sound Education is grounded in the Australian experience while aiming to embrace broader international perspectives. This volume takes its place alongside issues-oriented introductions to the field such as Colwell and Wing (Reference COLWELL and WING2004) as well as more practice-oriented works such as Campbell et al. (Reference CAMPBELL, DEMOREST and MORRISON2007). However, these texts, as well as ones by Hoffer (Reference HOFFER2009), Erwin et al. (Reference ERWIN, EDWARDS, KERSHNER and KNIGHT2003) and Olson et al. (Reference OLSON, BARRETT, RASMUSSEN, BARRESI and JENSEN2001), are predicated upon music education in the USA as the exemplar. Moving from the realities of classroom and community contexts to issues such as gender and creativity allows for a varied, sometimes kaleidoscopic, glimpse into music and music education.
Navigating Music and Sound Education is an ambitious project which features current research from 20 individuals whose professional identities run the gamut from musician to songwriter to student to educator to music therapist to ethnomusicologist. The book's scope is perhaps the most exciting aspect of Navigating Music and Sound Education. Practitioners will appreciate how contemporary theory and research is so directly and simply explained. Divided into 11 chapters, the book begins and ends with a letter to pre-service teachers. The editors invite students-becoming-teachers to consider themselves as colleagues who will use the text alongside their experiences in the field.
Each chapter focuses upon a discrete body of current, relevant research grounded in the contributors' expertise. The first section (Chapters 1–5) utilises a thematic organisation to address context-based learning (Ch. 1), using a constructivist approach in teaching for musical learning (Ch. 2), integrating music with other subject areas (Ch. 3), creative learning in music (Ch. 4), and gender and music education (Ch. 5). The next section (Chapters 6–9) shifts to a sociological orientation to deal with informal learning in the music classroom (Ch. 6), learning from and within musical communities (Ch. 7), music in indigenous education (Ch. 8) and cultural diversity (Ch. 9). The concluding chapters discuss technological contexts and experiences (Ch. 10) and the changing role of the music educator (Ch. 11). It is the nature of edited volumes that readers will gravitate to the chapters which pique their interest, be it professional or personal. Although a detailed summary of every chapter is beyond the scope of this review, the treatment of certain issues is worth noting.
The editors, Julie Ballantyne and Brydie-Leigh Bartleet, present three case studies of context-based learning in different educational settings: (1) a well-resourced school district suddenly hit with crisis, (2) a culturally dominant music from teacher facing the challenge of working with an indigenous population in a remote area, and (3) a high school population more interested in popular music than the standard repertoire. Although located in Australia, these true-life case studies will resonate with educators anywhere in the world.
Deborah Blair and Jackie Wiggins recommend a constructivist approach to learning music through teacher-designed, exploratory experiences. As they note, ‘At the core of constructivist learning theory (Fosnot, 2005) is the idea that knowledge cannot be ‘given’ or ‘passed on’ to the learner. Rather, learners construct their own understanding by engaging with the world – at home, in the community, and in school.' (p. 21).
Smaragda Chrysostomou and Natassa Economidou Stavrou (who stress that they share first authorship of their chapter) consider integrating music with other subjects. Citing three vignettes of actual classroom situations, they conclude that the teachers in these setting ‘. . . are not afraid to try new things; they feel comfortable in using music in many different ways and, more importantly, they recognize music as an integral part of a bigger and wider picture.’ (p. 47).
Pamela Burnard focuses on creativity in music education as she studies progression in music composition in a study involving British students aged 4 to 15 years, using the five elements of the Conceptual Framework of Creative Learning (developed by the UK Qualifications and Curriculum Authority): asking questions, making connections, imagining what might be, exploring options and reflecting critically.
Approaches to gender, sex and sexuality in music education are explored through the intertwining, and sometimes mythic, disciplines of biology and philosophy in Scott Harrison's provocative chapter. Anja Tait, Edel Musco, Megan Atfield, Leonie Murrungun, Catherine Orton and Tony Gray, all educators in Australia's Northern Territory, compose a beautiful piece on indigenous music and learning. Both the stories and the process by which these authors tell their stories are compelling.
I read the chapters concerning social context with especial enjoyment. Lucy Green discusses the UK-based music education initiative ‘Musical Futures’, in which the informal music-learning practices of musicians creating popular music are adopted in the music classroom. A potent part of this work rests in Green's willingness to reach students through their own music and musicking and to let them describe their own process in their own words. Stephanie Pitts considers music education as a social act; she draws from observations with musical communities in and out of English schools, with adult learners in a summer school, and with a chamber music outreach programme.
Huib Schippers and Melissa Cain examine both the dreams and realities of cultural diversity. Analysing intersections of tradition, authenticity and context, they note:
Understandably, nobody wants to be accused of not having respect for a tradition, of being insensitive to a music's context, or – probably worse – of being inauthentic, by their very nature. Again, there are no easy answers: it depends on whether a tradition is seen as a canon or a basis for continual change with the times; authenticity as ‘doing it in the way it was done in a certain period or place’ or ‘giving the children a meaningful musical experience’ and context as something that needs to be explained or even recreated, or as a constantly changing environment that needs to be acknowledged. (p. 164).
Many readers will appreciate Steve Dillon and Kathy Hirche's description of the future of education in their work with dynamic technological contexts. In the final chapter, Peter De Vries offers a personal and very accessible take, as he emphasises the importance of reflective practice, on the journeys possible for music educators (Schön, Reference SCHÖN1983).
Navigating Music and Sound Education is a wonderful guide and resource for pre-service music teachers, for teachers in the field, and for teacher educators. It offers a range of fresh perspectives on the state of music education as it is and as it might be.
