There is faith in the international community that placing human rights at the centre of the global democracy and development agenda is vital. This has been the mantra of governments, international organizations, and activists committed to building a world in which state power is constrained and the rights of citizens are paramount. To attain this goal requires a strong democratic framework of governance. A democratic framework for governance, rooted in the rule of law and strong institutions, makes for the ideal setting in which poorer countries in particular can develop and meet the needs of their people.
The 1980s saw a number of African authoritarian regimes come under pressure to restructure their political systems and so open up space for human rights, especially the civil and political rights sacrificed after decolonization on the altar of nation-building. Using a number of countries as his case studies, E. Ike Udogu describes the movement from dictatorship to democracy. At the core of his argument is the African encounter with European rule. State formation, the tensions between ethnic groups compressed into a single political space, and rapacious elites seem to him to account for why the postcolonial state deliberately disregarded civil and political rights in particular.
With his focus on history, Udogu seems to suggest human rights abuses in Africa are path dependent. European rule was at best benevolent despotism; ripping apart precolonial African constitutional orders, this despotism was carried into the independent state as the new elite ensured that the laws European powers had used to rule would persist in different forms. Udogu misses the opportunity to expound on the importance of path dependence as an explanation for the persistence of undemocratic forms of governance in Africa. Understanding how societies are trapped in a web of bad laws is important in demonstrating why such laws are difficult to uproot and replace with laws that respect and promote human rights and democracy. Udogo's listing of clauses from a variety of constitutions could have been sacrificed in favour of greater analytical rigour.
The role of human rights bodies to help translate rights into reality is another issue of import in Africa. For democracy to survive requires strong human rights bodies and Udogo's work acknowledges this by elaborating on the roles these organizations play. From the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission and its work with regard to prisoner's and women's rights to the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights with its interpretation of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights, Udogu does well here, laying out in detail the role of such bodies and how they have sought to expand the meaning of rights.
The quality of human rights laws embedded in democratic frameworks is regularly assumed to explain the advancement and prosperity of the world's liberal democracies. The high growth rates, high incomes, and political tolerance found mainly in Europe and North America are said to be a consequence of their institutional development: their formal and informal constraints on ruling classes in these countries, developed and honed over time, purportedly explain their stability and prosperity. The panacea prescribed for Africa tends to be an emulation of these countries. Udogu's work makes a contribution to understanding the historical development of human rights and democracy in Africa and why there is the need to continue to strengthen these two concepts.
