Doostdar's book is an important addition to a growing body of careful scholarship by a younger generation of Iranian anthropologists and other social scientists. Through ethnographies and archival research, this scholarship attempts to come to grips with various transformations and trends in post-revolutionary Iranian society. A common thread is understanding the reflexive turn that emerged after the revolution and that has led to exploration and experimentation in particular among the urban middle classes.
The fieldwork for this book was carried out between 2006 and 2008 with participants in an underground seminar on “Cosmic Mysticism” (erfan-e keyhani). This group was led by a trainee and follower of Mr. Muhammad Taheri, the founder of the Cosmic Mysticism movement who has been in jail in Iran on charges of “insulting Islam” and acting against Iran's national security. Cosmic Mysticism is characterized by the author as a “spiritual-therapeutic movement” that engages in the exorcism of jinns from the bodies of those who are judged to be afflicted—also referred to as “Psymentology.” More broadly, the book addresses phenomena that “exceeded ordinary experience and expectation, and therefore warranted being labeled ‘metaphysical’” (p. 3).
Doostdar argues for understanding the variety of extraordinary experiences by putting them within a broader paradigm of “the uncanny,” “wonder,” “the unseen (ghaib),” visions, dreams, and “unheimlich” (translated as ‘familiar-strangeness’ into Persian). Many intellectuals and politicians characterize such phenomena as “popular nonsense,” irrational and unscientific. The author, however, sees in them an opportunity for opening up lines of inquiry into their supposed opposites—the rational and scientific. A large part of the book is devoted to the many different ways in which Iranian intellectuals and state institutions have attempted to marginalize certain metaphysical ideas and the figures associated with them.
The overarching question that guides this book is “what do we learn if we view the metaphysical in terms hospitable to rational inquiry?” (p. 18). The denial of multiple forms of rationality is a major consequence of the emergence of the modern state, according to Doostdar. He chooses three processes that have been at work since the late 19th century to rationalize the unseen: To rid metaphysical knowledge of superstition; to use scientific approaches so as to enable understanding of metaphysical phenomena; and to discipline individuals and groups to become pious in ways acceptable to the state.
The book, though rather long, is well organized into three parts and each part has short chapters. The first part is about the figure of the rammal (prayer writer). We read about women (and men) who sought out rammals for various problems, often having to do with romance, relationships, and divorces. We meet a rammal in the first part of the book who belongs also to a Sufi order. Nafiseh, a young divorced woman went to this rammal together with a married man who was in love with her. They wanted to know if they suited each other. In the ensuing seances, Nafiseh is transformed and tells the author that she sees the world differently after these sessions. The author asks her to explain and she states: “The world as I see it… is … devoid of time and space, and yet [I see it] as being anything I want it to be, depending on my spiritual power [qodrat-e ruhi]” (p. 37). Doostdar concludes from Nafiseh's spiritual journeys that while she took on some new understandings and left others behind, none of it is permanent: “much of these were provisional judgements, open to reevaluation with the emergence of new encounters or new moods” (p. 37). The description and analysis of people's experiences in ways that acknowledge an almost constant change in how they come to assess them and then leave them behind is a major strength of this book.
While Part 1 is devoted to the rammal, Part 2 is about the scientist. This part begins with an ethnography of a woman in her late forties who lives with her husband and who had been studying Cosmic Mysticism for the past eight months, having taken the seminars of the exorcist the book opens with. Arezu Khanum exemplifies the many individuals and groups in postrevolutionary Iran who engage in spiritual explorations. She reads about Buddhism through the work of the American author Baird Spalding, is familiar with Shamz Tabrizi, Carlos Castaneda, and the American religious movement Eckankar. Following her visions of angels, she realizes that her Cosmic Mysticism teacher is “on a closed path” (p. 111). She articulates and constructs her own knowledge in ways that show how modern science is used to “reconcile… spiritual commitments with the demands of reason” (p. 112). She told the author that because of her experiences and studies, she has been able to understand complex scientific ideas such as quantum theory.
One of the chapters that I found particularly interesting is “Specter of Doubt” (Chapter 16). Doostdar reminds readers of the idea, held by many aarif (mystics), that we may acquire knowledge through revelation. If so, then also scientific knowledge may be obtained in that way. The founder of Cosmic Mysticism has said that he created this doctrine through cosmic “receptions.” He has also tried hard to find a place within the scientific community by making attempts to publish in scientific journals (p. 156). In 2013, he and a coauthor published the article “Definition of Psymentology, an Iranian Complementary and Alternative Medicine” in Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences (Vol 84, 9) offering a scientific definition of Psymentology.
The third and last part of the book is devoted to awliyaʾ allah (Friends of God) and their instrumentalization on the part of the state to offer models of piety. They are clerical figures, Iraq war martyrs, and others who are presented as examples for citizens to follow. Given the state's dismay at the proliferation of “fake” mystic movements, the hope is that such hagiographies help marginalize and dissuade potential followers of these movements.
Doostdar concludes that Shiʿi reason and the reasoning of Shiʿa do not overlap. Metaphysical inquiries have extended, transformed, and at times offered “avant-garde possibilities” to Shiʿi tradition. He sums up his aim as an exploration of the ways in which different kinds of reasoning become simultaneously “available to people.”
I found surprising the author's attribution of the importance of individual experience to the influence of “liberal reformers in Europe and North America” on Iranian religious intellectuals (p. 12). Mystic philosophers, theologians, and poets have written at length about concepts that articulate states and ideals of the relationship of the individual to the divine (Shahab Ahmed, What is Islam: The Importance of Being Islamic, Princeton University Press, 2015; Ata Anzali, “Mysticism” in Iran: The Safavid Roots of a Modern Concept, University of South Carolina Press, 2017). And the concept of experience tajribah has its own entry on the Web site of the Qom Seminary.
Finally, for future research, it would be illuminating to do a comparative analysis of Cosmic Mysticism and the beliefs and rites of Ahl-e Hava (people of the wind) who live on the southern Gulf coast of Iran. They are not mentioned in Doostdar's book but they too believe that some people get afflicted by outside forces, in this case, different kinds of “wind” that enter bodies. And they perform exorcisms to get the winds out. To my knowledge, only one Iranian anthropologist, Kaveh Safa (“Reading Saedi's AHL-E Hava: Pattern and Significance in Spirit Possession Beliefs on the Southern Coasts of Iran,” Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 12 (1988): 85–111), has done an extended analysis of Saʿedi's original monograph Ahl-e Hava (Tehran: Institute of Social Studies and Research,1966). Such comparative work has much to offer, including a widening of the discussion of plural rationalities and the ways in which understandings of Islam may come to be connected to ideas of the uncanny by local communities.
This is an insightful book that will be of interest to social scientists in various disciplines, in particular those concerned with postrevolutionary Iran and with questions of rationality, scientific reasoning, and (Shiʿa) Islam.
