We live in an age in which equality – levelling up (or down) to a norm of the middle-class, white, heterosexual man or, these days, couple – is seen as the primary goal of hitherto disadvantaged groups. The transformative agendas of the civil rights and gay and women's liberation movements of the second half of the twentieth century have been replaced by campaigns for inclusion, some of them surprisingly successful. As its title indicates, After Legal Equality surveys the social and legal landscape now that formal equality has largely been achieved in many Western jurisdictions, and discovers – no surprise to most of the authors here who, as Claire Young points out in her chapter, have been predicting it for years – that equality brings with it a new set of challenges.
The editor's opening statement sets the scene:
‘Groups seeking equality sometimes take a legal victory as the end of the line. Once judgment is granted, or a law is passed, coalitions disband, and life goes on in a new state of equality. For their part, policymakers may assume that a troublesome file is now closed.’ (p. 1)
In fact, as Robert Leckey goes on to explain, once some rights have been achieved, others may be dismantled (the UK's welfare state is an obvious example) and the private sphere expanded by the inclusion of, for instance, same-sex couples in marriage and parenting roles, thus taking over caring responsibilities from the state. Or gains may trigger a backlash, with reactionary forces appropriating progressive arguments, as fathers' rights movements have done. Equality may work better for some members of the qualifying group than others, and some people, including those who never actually sought the right, may actually be worse off, such as same-sex couples on benefits who live together in the UK. Finally, the rights awarded to selected individuals may exacerbate the disadvantage suffered by those who are left out.
It is fascinating to see the effect that legal reform has had, not only on the way in which future goals are identified and pursued, but also on the way that past campaigns are interpreted. In this book, Roderick A. Ferguson describes how the current worldview has led to liberationist histories being recast as narratives of campaigning for (state-granted) rights when, in fact, these movements were generally characterised by suspicion of the state and cynicism about the power of institutions to meet our goals:
‘In this historical moment, therefore, we can observe how gay rights – as a movement and as an emergent mode of law – help to naturalize a conception of history in which the state is seen as the legitimate mediator of minority freedom and satisfaction, a moment in which rights are seen as the primary resource for sexual, gender and racial liberation.’ (p. 152)
Ferguson instances marriage as one of the problematised areas, quoting lesbian-feminist scholar Nancy Polikoff: ‘At the time, marriage was part of the problem, not the solution’ (p. 156).
Part 1 of the book (‘Care and justice under neo-liberalism’) deals with an issue of the greatest social and political significance today, one which prompts Jonathan Herring to call for a new focus for family law. He notes how family law textbooks concern themselves with sexual relationships and children, to the exclusion of friends and eldercare, though these are central players in contemporary families, and the state has an interest in including them since, if care is not given by the private sphere, the state must provide. Thus Herring is able to sell the idea of valuing care as a political imperative, not simply (as feminists have done for a good hundred years) as a matter of justice for women, who do most of it. Susan Boyd's critique of British Columbia's Family Law Act 2011, which follows, illustrates Herring's point about the tunnel vision of family law while revealing its ‘uncomfortable fit’ for children of same-sex parents. In the context of lesbian parenting disputes she shows how the patriarchal state finds it impossible to see two women as other than ‘mothers’ of equal standing, or to ignore the claims of a donor father, whatever the content of any agreement or the role he has actually played in the upbringing of the child.
Richard Collier's chapter on fathers' rights movements examines what it means to be a ‘good dad’ in post-equality England, and how differently fathers are judged from mothers. One of the frustrations for scholars in this field is the strength of the perception, held by legislators and judges as well as the general public, that fathers fare badly in disputes over children on relationship breakdown, and the uncritical acceptance of the idea (again articulated in courts and Parliament) that a child's need for a father transcends concerns about domestic violence or quality of care. In fact, as Collier points out, our current law and legal processes bend over backwards to accommodate the claims of fathers, though ‘[i]t is mothers, not fathers, who face the harshest consequences of the neo-liberal redrawing of the market state’ (p. 67).
Janet R. Jakobsen's contribution proceeds from the perspective of the US, where a primary motivation for marriage is access to transferrable health-care benefits. Again bearing out Herring's observations about the narrow focus of family law, Jakobsen shows how gays and lesbians have traditionally assembled alternative networks in the absence of family support – networks which are not, of course, recognised as ‘family’ for the above privileges. ‘In the end,’ she concludes, ‘[p]erhaps the better question is not whether to marry, so much as under what conditions marriages take place, and whether those conditions support only those who are married or whether they equally support everyone in society’ (p. 91).
One welcome feature of this book is the appearance in Part 2 (‘States’ reach’) of two chapters by tax lawyers, both engaging with the often overlooked financial consequences of relationship regulation. Claire Young demonstrates how spousal tax provisions privilege the better-off and the heteronormatively constructed couple, while Kim Brooks shows how couples (heterosexual and same-sex) live in a range of relationships and communities that defy easy pigeonholing within those provisions, which in Canada also apply to ‘common-law’ spouses. In the UK, common-law marriage is not recognised in law, and difficulties encountered by unmarried cohabitants on relationship breakdown have long been a matter of concern. Helen Reece's analysis of the failure of the Advicenow campaign, the UK government's effort to educate cohabitants into making appropriate arrangements around property ownership, flies in the face of mainstream critique in its conclusion that maybe we should be celebrating rather than deploring cohabitants' recalcitrance. Reece carefully unpicks the many begged questions in the campaign's approach, not least its conflation of information and normative advice and its assumption that ‘fairness’ is easy to achieve, and examines the real (and indeed rational) reasons why couples might not choose to negotiate a cohabitation agreement.
Part 3 (‘Sex and love’) presents articles by three eminent British scholars of sexuality and law. Catherine Donovan, drawing on the findings of a large empirical study, demonstrates that notwithstanding the professed greater equality of lesbian relationships (being unfettered by gendered roles), power imbalances and domestic violence and abuse do arise and may indeed be facilitated and ‘institutionalised’ in legally-ordered relationships like marriage, where heteronormative ideals continue to flourish. Rosie Harding, on the same theme, shows how same-sex relationships and parenting have been represented in Parliament and court in heteronormative terms that fail to see, or deliberately ignore, the fact that same-sex relationships and families are different. Daniel Monk offers two case-studies precisely illustrating these differences: a gay male couple, civilly partnered, who have been denied opportunities to foster a child because of their non-monogamous lifestyle, and a small survey of will-making solicitors who attested that gay and lesbian clients were very likely to make provision for ‘godchildren’, while heterosexuals rarely mentioned them. I venture to suggest that this feature of homosexual ‘families of choice’ (as Weeks, Heaphy and Donovan put it in their groundbreaking study of Reference Weeks, Heaphy and Donovan2001) will slowly decline with greater acceptance by blood families and greater adherence to heteronormative ideals by younger same-sex couples (see Heaphy, Smart and Einarsdottir, Reference Heaphy, Smart and Einarsdottir2013). This bears out Donovan's point and will make the ‘difference’ that Harding observes harder to sustain.
It is always difficult to review edited collections. While linked to a common idea, the chapters stand alone in their specific content, and a précis of each runs the risk of misrepresenting complex arguments. The product of a workshop held at McGill University in 2013, After Legal Equality bears the signs of fruitful discussion and cross-referencing among the authors; editor Robert Leckey has done an excellent job of drawing out the themes that run through this collection; and there is an index – a rare luxury. All of these chapters are valuable contributions to equality critique and, taken as a whole, the book offers a welcome response to the simplistic assumption that equality and rights are unproblematic and intrinsically and unarguably positive.
