Performing Herself is a slim volume that packs a big punch. In little over two hundred pages, Gilli Bush-Bailey not only provides a concise biography of her subject Fanny Kelly – a biography that re-examines evidence used to inform others’ accounts of the actress's life alongside a wealth of new material drawn from the author's painstaking research at a number of different archives – but also rewards readers with a carefully prepared edition of Kelly's remarkable work Dramatic Recollections. This second text is, as Bush-Bailey suggests, ‘not only a tour de force for the female performer, it is also a very personal theatre history which, like all the best stories, informs our understanding of a broader set of social and cultural constructs’ (p. 101). If this were all that Performing Herself delivered, it would be a welcome contribution to our knowledge of drama in the first half of the nineteenth century and a particularly useful addition to a growing collection of modern editions of works written by women for the stage. But the author has also written a powerful introduction (some fifteen pages) that confronts, smartly and productively, ‘a key moment in the writing and reception of theatre history; a moment when the cloak of methodological authority threatens once again to mask the radicalism of women's theatre history’ (pp. 4–5).
Bush-Bailey's introduction takes on the complexities of engaging past dramatic work in ways that might speak to women making performances in our own time. She addresses, too, how contemporary ideas about history (especially what Tom Postlewait has promoted as microhistory) might be stretched, or at least interrogated, by the specificities of her project on Kelly. Furthermore, the introduction looks at the relationship between biography (what the author was, among other things, undertaking) and autobiography (what Kelly performed in Dramatic Recollections). This connects with a seam of theatre history scholarship that attempts to recover and engage the work of actors/actresses so as to reformulate those premises in more conventional theatre history-making that still rely on plays and the buildings in which they were staged as the cornerstones of their narratives. The first fifteen pages of Performing Herself should immediately become required reading for any historiography class.
The core of this project is described as ‘A Performance Biography’ by the author. In other words, she eschews any notion of definitive coverage and signals an intention to focus on Kelly's performance contexts. Discussion of theatre business – everything from wages to ticket pricing – is especially interesting, as is the thoughtful examination of Kelly's ultimately failed attempts to launch a Royal Dramatic School that would prepare the nation's actors. Dramatic Recollections (a show that lasted some 3–4 hours in performance) offers another version of the life and times. Both biography and script deserve extended study, and together they provide a suggestive model for other theatre history projects that hope to challenge rather than sediment the historiographical protocols with which they work.
