In their edited volume titled A History of Scottish Economic Thought Alexander Dow and Sheila Dow present a collection of essays on a range of economic thinkers who exemplify the so-called Scottish tradition of economic thought.
After a short introduction, one can read about John Law, Francis Hutcheson, David Hume, Sir James Steuart, Adam Smith, James Mill, John Ramsay McCulloch, Thomas Chalmers, John Rae, J. Shield Nicholson, William Smart, William Robert Scott, and Alec Cairncross. One then learns about the application of the Scottish tradition in the late nineteenth and twentieth century and, in the postscript, its legacy for the future. The main message of the volume is, as far as I understand it, twofold. First, despite the differences among the works of Scottish origins, there is enough in common among them to differentiate them for other traditions of thought and from other schools. Second, there is more to Scottish thinking than Adam Smith and David Hume.
In the opening and closing chapters, the editors bring out what is implicit in the essays. The Scottish approach is “profoundly influenced by Scottish philosophy, and the fact that philosophy was core to the university curriculum” (p. 3). The familiarity with philosophy, even when only in the background, leaves the door open for recognizing the relevance of several other disciplines, as well as the relevance of practical issues and experience in the analysis of economic questions. All the contributions indeed show this presence.
From the contributions, it also emerges that Scotland has more to offer the economic community than simply Smith and Hume. That said, Smith and Hume remain two enormous pachyderms that cannot be ignored, Smith being the more imposing of the two. Predecessors, contemporaries, and successors all bear the challenge of comparison, and anything that has to do with Scottish economics must resign to live somehow in the shadows of these two giants. On the other hand, the constant presence of Smith and Hume generates a continuity and affinity among disparate authors, allowing the Scottish tradition to persist more vividly.
Another thread common to the various Scottish authors described in the volume is their cross-cultural breath. Despite being Scottish, all of them have been exposed to and influenced by the greater international intellectual world. In a sense, it seems that part of Scottish intellectual strength, at least until the late nineteenth century, derives from this openness to other countries, to other traditions, to other cultures. All the authors presented have either studied, traveled, worked, or lived outside Scotland at various times of their lives. Both essays on the greatest of the Scots highlight how Adam Smith was influenced by an Englishman—Isaac Newton. Smith's teacher and prominent exemplar of the Scottish enlightenment is Francis Hutcheson, an Irishman, who, as Andrew Skinner describes in his essay, was influenced in turn by Samuel Pufendorf, a German.
Alexander and Sheila Dow in their introduction and Alexander Dow and Alan Hutton in their chapters on economics in the Scottish universities in the late nineteenth century and the twentieth-century applications of the Scottish tradition indicate what seem to be two opposing trends. On the one hand, there seems to be a sort of closure of Scottish economists on their glorious past as well as an institutionalization of the tradition in educational arrangements. The international cross-fertilization so fruitful in the past is no longer as evident as in previous centuries. On the other hand, there seems to be an inevitable contagion of non-Scottish trends in economics, in particular with the increasing “internationalization” of the discipline under the auspices of American scholarship and mathematics. But this exposure to “others” seems to be described and feared more as a swallowing of the tiny Scottish tradition by the mighty international orthodoxy than as a fertile exchange of ideas.
Sheila Dow in her Postscript brings out hope for the future. The Scottish tradition is still visible outside today's orthodoxy. Marxists, neo-Austrians, and many forms of reactions to the “formalist, rational-economic-man approach” provide a fertile ground for the rediscovery or a second bloom of the illustrious Scottish tradition.
This otherwise worthy volume leaves me ponder on two related questions. First, why Scotland? Would it have been possible for the conditions under which the Scottish tradition emerged and flourished to be present elsewhere, in time and place, or are they exclusively linked to Scotland? Second, and most importantly, how much is the Scottish economic tradition really dependant on the Scottish “national identity” as the two Dows declare it to be? And if it does, can we really expect the persistent success of a “national” approach in a world, like today's, that is increasingly blurring “national” differences?
