This is an unusual book. It opens by stating what it is not and closes with a deliberate lie, announced plainly in the introduction, by the way. It is not a textbook, it is not a biography and, I am afraid, it is not a piece of history of science either. It is, by the author's own admission, a popular book, for better or worse. Most significantly, I think, it is a courageous booklet. It embarks on the arduous enterprise of giving an intelligible and maths-free picture of Boltzmann's abstruse statistical mechanics, not only a commendable task in itself, but a badly needed one. After more than 110 years from his demise, Boltzmann remains more respected than read and, often, more read than understood. In light of the momentous importance of Boltzmann's statistical conception of entropy for the scientific thought of the twentieth century, any attempt to make such conception more widely known is surely welcomed. In addition, this is a successful attempt. The author does a great job of explaining the conceptual intricacies of statistical mechanics and his witty language helps comprehension greatly. However, the book makes some slips as far as history is concerned. The author has clearly researched the matter zealously, but some of his judgements are too harsh, as I show below.
The book consists of twenty-five chapters, most of them brief, and it is equally divided between discussing the physical content of the theory and telling the peculiar story of its author. The plot starts, so to speak, from the end; that is, from the inconvenient truth of Boltzmann's tragic suicide in Duino. Johnson disposes quickly of the sad story of Boltzmann's end and eventful burial, but this tragedy lingers on in the remainder of the book as an inexorable epilogue. The reader must only wait until Chapter 5 (which is merely eight pages away) to discover the reason. Johnson introduces the ominous theme of Boltzmann's psychical instability as an entry point not only to the closing years of his life but also to his science. The equation – Boltzmann's equation – is certainly related to anxiety, although the author never completely solves the metaphorical tension between a direct connection, with the chaotic microworld of kinetic theory depicting Boltzmann's magmatic psyche, and a reversed one, with the Austrian physicist seeking in the crystalline purity of mathematics a shelter from his innermost ghosts. Be that as it may, the suggestion is intriguing, although, as I maintain below, not fully convincing.
Chapters 6 to 9 are dedicated to explaining some of the basic concepts of Boltzmann's statistical mechanics and here Johnson's talent for popularization is displayed in full swing. He starts easy with two atoms and full-page pictures to increase the level of complexity all the way up to octilions of particles. The strategy eventually pays off. Johnson's discussion is as clear as the objectively complicated topic allows. After another short foray into anxiety (Chapters 10 and 11), the author comes back to introduce the notion of probability, the famous symbol W that appears on Boltzmann's gravestone (Chapters 12 and 13). Once again, the discussion avoids mathematical symbols and makes the best of Boltzmann's own models to illuminate the difference between micro- and macrostate.
In the second half of the book, Johnson concentrates on two specific anxieties that troubled Boltzmann's late years: his increasing fear to teach (Chapters 14 to 16) and his frustration in debates on his work and its philosophical implications (Chapters 20 and 22). Here is where post-mortem psychoanalysis used as interpretive device shows its limits. Johnson ascribes Boltzmann's unstoppable fall into the abyss partly to his ‘oversensitivity’, partly to his taking too personally purely scientific disputes, and partly to the influence of an evil genius called Ernst Mach. Like an algebraic transformation, Johnson's narrative projects onto the one-dimensional Boltzmann's psychological space what is in fact a multidimensional vector. Historians such as Martin J. Klein (Paul Ehrenfest: The Making of a Theoretical Physicist, 1970), Deborah Coen (Vienna in the Age of Uncertainty: Science, Liberalism, and Private Life, 2007), Carl E. Schorske (Fin-de-siècle Vienna: Politics and Culture, 1979) and Allan Janik and Stephen Toulmin (Wittgenstein's Vienna, 1979), not to mention novelists such as Robert Musil and Joseph Roth, have made abundantly clear that anxiety and desperation were dismayingly common in the cultural elite of the capital of the Habsburg Empire. Like in a less-than-ideal gas, Boltzmann's personal trajectory was so tightly entangled with the rest of a world running at full throttle towards self-destruction that the author's cursory diagnoses (‘Boltzmann might have fared better personally had he not engaged his criticism directly’ or ‘he should have remained focused on his physics’ instead of toying with philosophy, pp. 115–116) sound empty, not to say futile.
Johnson's account of the role of Ernst Mach is even less historically accurate and sometimes dangerously borders on open mockery. After vaguely suggesting that Mach was a mediocre scientist whose shift to philosophy was ‘a wise career move’ (p. 116), he states that, had Planck or Einstein taken Mach as seriously as Boltzmann did, they would have never moved beyond the roles of humble schoolteacher and patent office clerk respectively. Of course, these gross judgements fly in the face of a large scholarship showing the importance of Mach's thought on the physics of his time.
After discussing the famous recurrence argument against the H-theorem (not without some historical inaccuracies), Johnson closes the book with a reverie: perhaps in one of the universes made possible by a fluctuation of the H-curve Boltzmann died peacefully in his armchair after a good dinner, accompanied by Schubert's music.
Despite its shortcomings, the book makes enjoyable and useful reading. Physics teachers, students and the general public can certainly profit from this intelligent survey of the microscopic world.
