I. INTRODUCTION
The publication of John Locke’s Two Treatises of Civil Government (1690) and the Letter concerning Toleration (1689) may have laid the foundation for what would be called “political liberalism,” and would go on to irrigate large parts of political thought in the eighteenth century. However, with the publication of most of his economic works by Patrick Hyde Kelly, including his Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest, and Raising the Value of Money (1692), new questions have arisen concerning the thought of this author.Footnote 1 Many commentators have analyzed the monetary policies Locke defended. We can distinguish four types of discussions among scholars. First, some commentators debate the existence of the quantity theory of money in Locke’s work (Walter Eltis Reference Eltis and Blaug1995; Arthur Leigh Reference Leigh1974). Second, other scholars analyze the influence of Locke’s monetary policies on the exchange rate mechanism (Richard Kleer Reference Kleer2004; James Morrison Reference Morrison2008), and criticize the consequence of Locke’s plan not to devalue in 1695 (Joyce Appleby Reference Appleby1976; Eltis Reference Eltis and Blaug1995; François Velde and Thomas Sargent Reference Velde and Sargent2002; Daniel Carey Reference Carey, Carey and Finlay2011). Third, we find many papers aiming at explaining Locke’s monetary policies through the socio-political context (Constantine Caffentzis Reference Caffentzis1989; Kelly Reference Kelly and Kelly1991), Locke’s theoretical foundations (Kepa Ormazabal Reference Ormazabal2012),Footnote 2 or Locke’s philosophical ideas and his semantic and language theory (Caffentzis Reference Caffentzis1989, p. 7; 2003; Carey Reference Carey and Carey2014).Footnote 3 Fourth, some commentators focus their analysis on the concept of money in Locke’s essays: its definition, its origin, its separation from political form (John Weymark Reference Weymark1980; Carey Reference Carey2013; Christine Desan Reference Desan and Desan2014).Footnote 4
This article is directly related to this last discussion on money. Based on the Lockean conception of money, the aim of this article is to highlight that the introduction of money leads to a new type of conflict in the state of nature: it occurs within the owners’ class between what Locke calls the “moneyed men” (Locke Reference Locke and Kelly1692, p. 291), who accumulate money, and the “landed men” (ibid., p. 224), who accumulate land.
If the idea of a class conflict in the Lockean state of nature is not new (Caffentzis Reference Caffentzis2003, Reference Caffentzis and Parigi2010; Crawford Macpherson Reference Macpherson1962; Karen Iversen Vaughn Reference Vaughn1980), the usual depicted class conflict is between owners and non-owners. For instance, Constantine Caffentzis (2010, p. 64) believes that Locke relies on his philosophical theory to support and justify his economic propositions. For him, the appearance of a class conflict occurs between the rich and the poor (1989, pp. 66–67).Footnote 5 The existence of this class conflict was also analyzed in detail by Crawford Macpherson (Reference Macpherson1962) and by Karen Vaughn (Reference Vaughn1980). Vaughn also believes that the conflict is between the rich and the poor. Macpherson expresses the idea that the conflict is between owners and non-owners—which is not very different from the conflict between the rich and the poor. Note that the Lockean state of nature is initially stable: it is a state of peace. So one can wonder why, according to Locke, individuals want to leave this state of nature. Actually, in his Second Treatise of Civil Government, we find some evidence explaining how individuals leave this state of nature (chapter eight), which is not necessarily stable, but there is nothing clear about why it is not stable and why individuals leave it.Footnote 6 In his fifth chapter Locke explains that the introduction of money modifies the state of nature. However, he does not discuss this modification. All we know is that once money is introduced, commentators agree, a conflict arises.
However, the aim of this paper is to demonstrate that the conflict is not mainly between the rich and the poor or between owners and non-owners. In order to support and understand this idea of a class conflict between the landed men and the moneyed men, I have established a link between Locke’s philosophical and economic essays; and particularly his Second Treatise of Civil Government (1690) and Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest, and Raising the Value of Money (1692, henceforth Some Considerations), since in his following economic essay—Further Considerations Concerning Raising the Value of Money—he does not mention this conflict. Even if commentators concentrate their analysis either on Locke’s philosophical writings or on Locke’s economic writings, in his book Patrick Kelly (Reference Kelly and Kelly1991) explains the importance of tying these two aspects together. According to Kelly, it allows for better understanding of Locke’s thought. He also explains that there is a link between the chapter on property of the Second Treatise of Civil Government and Locke’s economic essays. For Kelly, even if this link is relevant, it is not obvious and the connection must be done cautiously (1991, p. 3). This may be the reason why Kelly does not analyze and discuss this link: he concentrates his analysis on the economic writings in order to show Locke’s influence on economic policy decisions and the influence of the context in which Locke expresses his ideas.
I will support and develop the following thesis: the introduction of money in the state of nature justifies economic policy. A monetary conventionFootnote 7 gives a value to gold and silver. This allows endless enrichment, leading to a conflict over money within the owners’ class in the state of nature. The conflict then requires the establishment of a civil government. Consequently, the aim of the government is to ensure that the conflict does not turn into civil war, by ensuring an appropriate quantity of money in the country.
In the first part, I focus my analysis on the Lockean state of nature. I point out that there are two stages in this state of nature, separated by the introduction of money. I will explain that in the first stage before the introduction of money, Locke grounds property on labor. Then I will analyze how money causes a disruption of the peaceful state of nature. With money, accumulation is now possible, leading to the appearance of inequalities. Consequently, I will explain how the state of peace ends.
I analyze in the second part the Lockean conflict, which appears after the introduction of money in the state of nature. I begin with an explanation of the usual interpretation of this Lockean conflict: Macpherson (Reference Macpherson1962), Vaughn (Reference Vaughn1980), and Caffentzis (Reference Caffentzis1989, Reference Caffentzis2003, Reference Caffentzis and Parigi2010) describe a conflict between owners and non-owners. Then, I will show how Macpherson’s, Caffentzis’s, and Vaughn’s analyses are called into question by Locke’s Some Considerations. In particular, I will shed new light on the status of money, bringing out some notable differences from the theories of previous commentators. Indeed, I will show that the conflict in the state of nature also takes place within the owners’ class: between those who own money and those who own land. In this case, the aim of the “civil government” is to avoid an escalation of the conflict between these two classes of owners. This original interpretation of Locke is critical since it has a strong impact on the understanding of the aim of the state. In fact, using Locke’s theory of the establishment of money described in the Second Treatise, and by using Some Considerations, I will point out that he assigns to government a social responsibility concerning the monetary policy it must conduct: it must ensure there is enough money to deal with the conflict between the two classes of owners.
II. THE LOCKEAN STATE OF NATURE: FROM A STATE OF PEACE TO ITS END
In this section, I demonstrate that in his Second Treatise, Locke distinguishes two stages of the state of nature: before the introduction of money, when individuals do not interact with each other; and after its introduction, when exchanges are made possible. But first let us review the first stage of the Lockean state of nature.
The Possibility of a Peaceful Appropriation
First of all, goods are given in common to individuals, thanks to “God, who hath given the World to Men in common.… The Earth, and all that is therein, is given to Men for the Support and Comfort of their being” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, §26, p. 286).Footnote 8 In order to own goods people have to use their labor, since it removes “them out of that common state they were in” (ibid., §28, p. 289). Let us develop Locke’s appropriation theory. One of the first questions to be asked is: If individuals have no relation in the state of nature, how can a man become the owner of a good? As Locke puts it: “I shall endeavour to shew, how Men might come to have a property … without any express Compact of all the Commoners” (ibid., §25, p. 286). To answer this question Locke begins by explaining that individuals have the property of themselves. As a consequence all goods that are removed from the state of nature by their works become their property.
[E]very Man has a Property in his own Person. … The Labour of his Body, and the Work of his Hands, we may say, are properly his. Whatsoever then he removes out of the State that Nature hath provided, and left it in, he hath mixed his Labour with, and joyned to it something that is his own, and thereby makes it his Property. (ibid., §27, pp. 287–288)
According to Locke, then, an individual becomes the owner of a good as soon as his labor removes it from the common pool of resources. So, for Locke, it seems that labor is a measure of value. Indeed, he explains that labor creates wealth.
For ’tis Labour indeed that puts the difference of value on every thing; and let anyone consider, what the difference is between an Acre of Land planted with Tobacco, or Sugar, sown with Wheat or Barley; and an Acre of the same Land lying in common, without any Husbandry upon it, and he will find, that the improvement of labour makes the far greater part of the value. (ibid., §40, p. 296)
This is one of the reasons why Locke is sometimes perceived as the first classical economist.Footnote 9 However (and surprisingly), in his Book Four of the Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith blames Locke for his measure of wealth. Smith believes that, according to Locke, gold and silver are the measure of wealth.
God gives earth and land in common to all individuals; however, Locke writes, individuals have a “right to their Preservation” (ibid., §25, p. 285). This is why in the state of nature individuals do not need the consent of others to appropriate goods, because “if such a consent as that was necessary, Man [would have] had starved, notwithstanding the Plenty God has given him” (ibid., §28, p. 288). Before the introduction of money, then, individuals are alone in competing against nature.Footnote 10
Moreover, Locke adds that needs are limited.
It will perhaps be objected to this, That if gathering the Acorns, or other Fruits of the Earth, makes a right to them, then any one may ingross as much as he will. To which I answer, Not so. The same Law of Nature, that does by this means give us Property, does also bound that Property too. (ibid., §31, p. 290)
With this quotation Locke explains that property is then limited by waste, although the desire for property remains insatiable. Therefore, we are in a state of abundance: there is no scarcity, and exchange does not exist except accidentally. God gave natural resources in sufficient quantity to humanity, whose needs are limited. Indeed, without money, a man can only acquire goods. Consequently, individuals stop working as soon as their needs are fulfilled.Footnote 11 We are thus facing a state of peace since there is no economic relation between individuals. This explains why the state of nature is stable: “the same Rule of Propriety, that every Man should have as much as he could make use of, would hold still in the World, without straitening any body, … had not the Invention of Money, and the tacit Agreement of Men to put a value on it, introduced (by Consent) larger Possessions” (ibid., §36, p. 293).
Indeed, we pass to the second stage of the state of nature when a conventionFootnote 12 gives an imaginary valueFootnote 13 to gold.
Disruptions Caused by the Introduction of Money
In the state of nature, the monetary convention occurs between individuals as a tacit agreement. Giving an imaginary value to gold and silver changes their status: before, as metals, they had a private utility; but, once given this imaginary value, they not only are useful goods (jewels), but they acquire a social utility.Footnote 14 We will come back to this issue later. With the introduction of money, individuals can enlarge their possessions: it is a way for them to “fairly possess more than he himself can use” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, §50, p. 302) without harming others, since the limit of waste disappearsFootnote 15 with the possibility to keep money. Let us explain here what Macpherson (Reference Macpherson1962) says about what he calls the “sufficiency limitation.” His idea is that the increase in the productivity of appropriated land compensates for the scarcity of land that other individuals suffer. For Macpherson, this is due to the fact that the increase of the total product is allocated without harming those who face land scarcity. This analysis finds its root in Locke’s comment that “a King of a large and fruitful Territory there feeds, lodges, and is clad worse than a day Labourer in England” (ibid., §41, p. 297). But he does not offer any conclusions regarding the distribution of resources, and a man can accumulate as much as he likes, provided that “there is enough, and as good left in common for others” (ibid., §27, p. 288). However, we must underline that this condition holds only before the introduction of money in the state of nature, since appropriation of goods is the only way for individuals to survive. Locke does not seem to think that, once money is introduced, individuals need to apply this proviso, since quantities no longer matter. Indeed, an individual can accumulate money without depriving someone else of the means of subsistence.
[I]f he would give his Nuts for a piece of Metal, … and keep those by him all his Life, he invaded not the Right of others; he might heap up as much of these durable things as he pleased; the exceeding of the bounds of his just Property not lying in the largeness of his Possession, but the perishing of anything uselessly in it. (ibid., §46, p. 300)
In fact, my interpretation is here similar to Vaughn’s (Reference Vaughn1980) in that I accept that people are covetous before the convention of money, but cannot accumulate useful goods beyond their needs because it would be both useless and wasteful. In this framework covetousness cannot develop. Indeed, according to Locke, reason makes us leave enough goods to other people even if the desire to accumulate exists: “especially keeping within the bounds, set by reason of what might serve for his use” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, § 31, p. 290; my emphasis in bold). Locke insists that “nothing was made by God for Man to spoil or destroy” and “if they [goods] perished, in his Possession, without their due use … he offended against the common Law of Nature, and was liable to be punished” (ibid., §31, p. 290; §37, p. 295). Consequently, in the state of nature before the invention of money, individuals need to moderate their accumulation. Moreover, according to Locke:
What would a Man value Ten Thousand, or an Hundred Thousand Acres of excellent Land, ready cultivated, and well stocked too with Cattle, in the middle of the in-land Parts of America, where he had no hopes of Commerce with other Parts of the World, to draw Money to him by the Sale of the Product? It would not be worth the inclosing, and we should see him give up again to the wild Common of Nature, whatever was more than would supply the Conveniences of Life to be had there for him and his Family. (ibid., §48, p. 301)
So, as long as an individual is alone with nature, covetousness seems meaningless. However, unlike Vaughn, I do not think that in Locke’s essay covetousness develops purely because gold becomes a medium of exchange. In my opinion, in order for an individual to acquire more than he needs, it is necessary that the object of his desire be deprived of any notion of private utility.Footnote 16 Otherwise, we are in the situation previously described in reference to Robert Nozick. Since, when gold and silver are used as currencies, they lose their private utility, the issue of waste is no longer at stake, and neither is the issue of depriving others of the means of life. So, contrary to the claims of Macpherson, Vaughn, and Locke himself, the issue is not reducible to the question of the durability of gold. When individuals give an imaginary value to gold, then it has only a social utility because it becomes the medium of exchange. That is why covetousness makes sense. This convention gives a social utility to gold, and since money does not satisfy any needs, the desire for gold as money is insatiable. Moreover, before the introduction of money, individuals have to work for their survival. They estimate the disutility of work based upon its exhaustion: “For as a Man had a right to all he could imploy his Labour upon, so he had no temptation to labour for more than he could make use of” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, §51, p. 302).
But with the introduction of money, individuals no longer need to work to amass goods: they make other people work for them and give money in exchange. This leads me to hypothesize that such enrichment without the corresponding labor is the reason why there is no more rational limit to accumulation and that covetousness can occur: “this Invention of Money gave them [individuals] the opportunity to continue and enlarge them [possessions]” (ibid., §48, p. 301).
Since money can be acquired only through trade, it provokes individuals to interact.Footnote 17 Indeed, resources are purchased or borrowed from those who have more than they need and who agree to transform stored goods into currency. Economic disparities naturally arise insofar as goods and hence currency are unevenly distributed. Therefore, with the introduction of money, the state of peace ends at this stage and a conflict appears. Two parts of Locke’s writings strengthen this idea.
First, as previously mentioned, properties would have been made “without straitening any body, … had not the Invention of Money … introduced (by consent) larger Possessions” (ibid., §36, p. 293). So once money is introduced, accumulation can straiten individuals. “Straiten” has a different meaning in Locke’s time (see Oxford English Dictionary) and means “to narrow.” In the eighteenth century it was understood as “to limit” or “to bother.”Footnote 18 That is to say, the introduction of money can create a limitation to the individual’s appropriation since it depends on others’ appropriation. It can then become difficult to obtain life necessities. So accumulation means the end of the state of peace, as Locke defines the “state of war” (ibid., p. 278) as the situation where a man “has exposed his Life to the others’ Power to be taken away by him” (ibid., §16, p. 278). A possible interpretation is that others’ appropriation limits, narrows, and even harms my own appropriation to a certain extent in which I may not survive.
Second, labor is the reason why there is no conflict about properties: “So that there could then be no reason of quarreling about Title, nor any doubt about the largeness of Possession it gave … as a Man had a Right to all he could imploy his Labour upon. … This left no room for Controversie about the Title, nor for Incroachment on the Right of others” (ibid., §51, p. 302).
But, as we have previously seen, money removes the need to work to amass goods. Indeed, the introduction of money changes the relation between labor and property.Footnote 19 Consequently, after the introduction of money, a conflict can appear. In his Second Treatise Locke does not clearly describe this conflict but only mentions it: “Though in the state of Nature he hath such a right, yet the Enjoyment of it is very uncertain, and constantly exposed to the Invasion of others” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, §123, p. 350).
One can see that Locke does not give any clue of who the opponents are. The answer is found in his economic writing Some Considerations, which he first developed in 1668 and extended in 1674 (Kelly Reference Kelly and Kelly1991, p. 3).Footnote 20
III. THE LOCKEAN CLASS CONFLICT OVER MONEY
We now turn to the nature of the conflict that arises from the end of the state of peace. In my analysis of Locke’s Second Treatise of Civil Government, I have explained that the scarcity of land implied by the introduction of money leads to a conflict. Indeed, money allows endless enrichment (possible without working) and then inequality. But Locke does not say more about this conflict in his Second Treatise. However, we find evidence of this conflict in Locke’s economic writing in Some Considerations. Macpherson, Caffentzis, and Vaughn describe a conflict between owners and non-owners. However, I will demonstrate that, according to Locke’s economic essays, a conflict occurs between owners.Footnote 21
The Usual Conflict: Owners versus Non-owners
According to Macpherson, what is at stake in Locke’s works is a class conflict between individuals who are owners and individuals who are not.Footnote 22
Macpherson explains that in the Second Treatise of Civil Government (1690), Locke eliminates the idea of limiting property: money makes it possible to obtain and to keep larger amounts of property since “[g]old and silver do not spoil; a man may therefore rightfully accumulate unlimited amounts of it” (Macpherson Reference Macpherson1962, p. 204). In order to understand this point, let us first briefly recall Macpherson’s analysis of Lockean appropriation. Macpherson explains that it is the state of ownership in which we stand with respect to our own bodies and our own labor that makes appropriation possible.Footnote 23 But he sees some limitations: first, appropriation is defensible as long as the individual does not spoil resources; and, second, a person can appropriate goods and lands as long as she leaves some for other individuals in enough quantity and quality. Macpherson names this limitation the “sufficiency limitation” (ibid., p. 211). The consequence of such limitation is that, in Macpherson’s opinion, before money existed, individuals did not desire more than they needed.Footnote 24 However, with the introduction of money, these limitations no longer hold: accumulation can occur. The equality between individuals that exists in the Lockean state of nature disappears with the inequality of possessions made possible with the appearance of money. Even when money is introduced, Macpherson believes, not all individuals are covetous. According to him, industrious accumulation needs to be protected from covetousness.Footnote 25 Those who are engaged in industrious appropriation are not covetous, whereas the “[q]uarrelsome and contentious” (ibid., p. 237) are. But since some individuals are covetous, government has to be established to protect property.Footnote 26
According to him, once the civil state is established, the desire for accumulation can fully develop. Thus, Macpherson comes to see Locke as a supporter of a capitalist appropriation of land and money.Footnote 27 Seeing the terms “money” and “land” as two forms of capital, Macpherson does not differentiate the landowner from the money owner. He thus describes the development of two social classes: the “labouring class” and the “property class” (ibid., p. 222). Macpherson states that those two classes are distinguished by the notion of rationality—where he defines rational behavior as “industrious appropriation.”Footnote 28 Without quoting Locke, Macpherson hypothesizes that the laboring class is not rationalFootnote 29 because they “are in too low a position to be capable of rational life” (ibid., p. 224). However, he cuts short any argument about the nature of rationality as it is presented in Locke’s treatise.Footnote 30 According to his interpretation, Locke’s view is that individuals without property chose to “alienate” their labor for a wageFootnote 31 in order to survive.
In this framework, government is set up to maintain the inequality between these two classes, and to protect the property class against its consequences. Indeed, he writes, “civil society is established to protect unequal possessions, which have already in the state of nature given rise to unequal rights” (ibid., p. 231).
Vaughn develops an account that turns on the conflict between the rich and the poor. She thinks that economic activity and the relationship of employment exist before the introduction of money.Footnote 32 According to Vaughn’s reading of Locke, individuals have to work because “it is the activity by which men fulfil God’s charge to survive” (Vaughn Reference Vaughn1980, p. 96). Money, then, allows the efficient pursuit of this pre-existent economic imperative. However, one must underline that she does not provide any evidence for this reading of Locke’s essay. According to her, individuals look for a way to store their surplus, and hence the introduction of money follows in order “to overcome a limitation [which] nature [has] placed on their economic activity” (ibid., p. 93). Indeed, the introduction of money makes accumulation of wealth easier, since the conservation cost of gold is lower than that of other goods: gold does not spoil.Footnote 33 Nevertheless, Vaughn does not see any major changes being triggered by the introduction of money—something that constitutes a major difference from my analysis.
Even if individuals are free and equal in terms of political power, she underlines, there will be an unequal accumulation of wealth, since individuals do not have the same abilities.Footnote 34 Actually, I could not find any textual evidence in Locke’s Second Treatise about individual abilities. Locke remains quite evasive about why some individuals become owners whereas others do not. He bypasses this question, mentioning two types of individuals: on one side, the “industrious and rational”; and, on the other side, the “quarrelsome and contentious” (Locke Reference Locke and Laslett1690, pp. 34, 291). But he does not introduce the idea of some individuals’ being more industrious than others. Nonetheless, Vaughn proposes that individuals with better capabilities will increase their ownershipFootnote 35 compared with those who are less industrious or less talented. The consequence is a scarcity of land,Footnote 36 and this leads to envy and covetousness that, in the end, triggers a conflict. In order to handle this conflict, individuals decide to delegate matters of policing and justice, hence the birth of civil government. Note that the establishment of civil government is also due to “the development of economic institutions”Footnote 37 (Vaughn Reference Vaughn1980, p. 81), which are no longer compatible with the state of nature. Vaughn considered this situation to be a breaking point in the Lockean conception of the state of nature.Footnote 38 Thus, according to her, the aim of government in Locke’s work is to protect and regulate property and then to help to maintain economic development.Footnote 39 Since nothing prevents those who earn a wage from becoming landowners thanks to their savings, the conflict should not be considered as a class conflict.
We find the same opposition between the rich and the poor in Caffentzis’s analysis. However, the reason for this opposition is quite different from Vaughn’s. According to him, the existence of crime leads to the creation of civil government. Let me explain his argument.
In the Lockean state of nature there is a state of abundance, which implies no temptation and no robbery. Property being limited in time, there is an absence of surplus. However, with the introduction of money, individuals can accumulateFootnote 40 more than they need to survive. Caffentzis explains that the introduction of money has two effects: first, it stimulates the “ambitious and industrious” individuals (Caffentzis Reference Caffentzis1989, p. 65) to accumulate wealth; second, it also stimulates “evil” individuals subject to crime. For Caffentzis, money simplifies theft: the thief is no longer stuck with an object because he can trade this object for money.Footnote 41 He then hypothesizes that this possibility of crime linked with scarcity and accumulation creates a division between rich and poor (ibid., p. 67).Footnote 42 Consequently, Caffentzis explains, crime is “the Father of Civil Government” and money is “the Mother of Civil Government” (ibid., p. 70).
For him, once money is introduced, individuals face a state of war between two characters: on the one hand, “Ambition and Luxury”; and, on the other hand, “Despair, Anger and Envy” (ibid., p. 68). From this state of war, Caffentzis imagines two paths. The first one consists of a collapse of money and a return to the previous state of nature. However, he does not provide any textual evidence from Locke concerning a possible return to the state of nature. The second path consists of making a social contract leading to the creation of the government, which aims at “annihilat[ing] the criminal” (ibid., p. 71).
Evidence of a New Class Conflict: “Landed Men” versus “Moneyed Men”
According to my interpretation of Locke, the introduction of money implies scarcity of lands because individuals are covetous. Individuals can now acquire more than they need, and since they are covetous, this leads to endless enrichment. Thus, money will be widely desired, and this is the basic reason why it is accumulated.Footnote 43 The introduction of money leads to the emergence of two non-working classes distinguished by their wealth. In Some Considerations Locke identifies two ways of becoming rich, and this contributes to the appearance of two types of owners who will enter into conflict in order to obtain money. A first way to become rich is through trade and industry: individuals can accumulate money and receive interest payments from it. This gives rise to the class of “moneyed men” (Locke Reference Locke and Kelly1692, pp. 228, 291). The moneyed man is a merchant or a broker. However, Locke notes that there is a second possible route to enrichment: individuals can accumulate land and receive a rent from it. This gives rise to the class of “landed men” (ibid., pp. 224, 291). Locke names some of the landed individuals: “landed gentlemen” (ibid., p. 272). This distinction is important since, according to Locke, the landed gentleman lives at court and consumes more than his revenue. This is why he borrows money: to buy luxury goods such as “Claret, Spice, Silk, and other Foreign Consumable Wares” (ibid., p. 291). And it is “the merchant who furnishes the improvident landholder” (ibid., p. 271). So the conflict over money occurs in the loan market, and if the landed man is in debt, then he has to sell his land to repay his debt: “There is scarce one of an hundred, that thinks of Selling his Patrimony, till Mortgages have pretty well Eat into the Freehold; and the weight of growing Debts force a Man, whether he will or no, out of his Possessions” (ibid., p. 270).
Note that land and money are both imperishable goods.Footnote 44 Land being limited in quantity, individuals will face land scarcity. This appropriation also takes place in the state of nature through labor that gives rights to ownership. Locke explains that the earth is at the disposal of “Industrious and Rational [individuals] (and Labour)” (1690, § 34, p. 291). Due to the ownership in the state of nature and the finite amount of land, once money is introduced, we have a situation wherein lands become scarce and then acquire more value. However, Locke does not explain why a person would choose to accumulate money rather than land or vice versa.Footnote 45
Individuals who get rich by these different routes thus confront each other: landed men appropriate more land than they need and buy luxury goods, but they need money; whereas the moneyed men appropriate money and lend it. As a consequence, “The usual struggle and contest, … is between the Landed man and the Merchant, with whom I may here join the Monied Man. The Landed man finds himself aggrieved, by the falling of his Rents, and the streightning of his Fortune; whilst the Monied Man keeps up his Gain” (Locke Reference Locke and Kelly1692, p. 291; my emphasis in bold).Footnote 46 This quotation gives us a clue to one possible reason for this conflict over money: it is due to covetousness linked with jealousy, since these two owners are “apt to be jealous one of another” (ibid., p. 290). This hypothesis is strengthened by the fact that we have an asymmetric relationship between these two types of owners. Moneyed men are mainly lenders, whereas landed men are mainly borrowers: they “must gather it [money] up by degrees … or borrow it of those, who have it lying by them” (ibid., p. 238). As a consequence, once money is introduced in the state of nature, there is conflict and inequality of possessions.Footnote 47 Then, in his economic essay Some Considerations, Locke explains this conflict: it occurs between owners due to the existence of two ways towards enrichment. This conflict,Footnote 48 based on money, is exacerbated by this different status between these two types of owners: “When a Nation is running to decay and ruin, the Merchant, and Monied man, do what you can, will be sure to starve last: Observe it where you will, the decays that come upon, and bring to Ruin any Country, do constantly first fall upon the Land” (ibid., pp. 271–272).
This conflict between landed men and moneyed men developed by Locke can be linked to the philosophical context in which Locke was writing. He probably had in mind the distinction between the two English political parties at that time: the Whigs and the Tories. Steve Pincus (Reference Pincus2009) explains that one of the main differences between these two parties is their conception of property. The Tories believe property comes from a natural creation, whereas the Whigs explain that property is the result of human labor (Pincus Reference Pincus2009, pp. 397–398).Footnote 49 From this definition, it is easy to understand why the Tories were perceived as partisans of the landed interest and the Whigs were perceived as advocating the moneyed interest. However, this clear distinction, which developed during the eighteenth century, is not particularly relevant at Locke’s time. Indeed, in the seventeenth century, the Whigs (which is still a unified party) supported the idea that the government should maintain an equilibrium between landed interest and moneyed interest.Footnote 50 This political issue about landed interest and moneyed interest probably influenced Locke, especially as he was quite close to Lord Shaftesbury, head of the Whig party.
Based on Locke’s works, it is because this conflict emerges that it is necessary to find a way to avoid a state of war. Thus, he introduces civil government, tasked with dealing with the conflict (by maintaining an appropriate amount of money in the country and between each class).Footnote 51 But in order to understand the aim of the government, we must refer to Locke’s economic writing, specifically Some Considerations.
In Some Considerations, Locke uses a metaphor to express the idea that there is an appropriate quantity of money. This question of the appropriate amount of money is raised because money changes the state of nature. Locke explains that (i) if we were in a country isolated from the world, (ii) money (not necessarily gold or silver) would consequently have no value outside the country and neither could it be increased, and (iii) then “any quantity of money … would serve to any proportion of trade” (Locke Reference Locke and Kelly1692, p. 82). But the situation in Locke’s state of nature is very different from that scenario. Indeed, money is introduced by a universal consent. Money then acquires an international value and is used in international trade. This is why in the Lockean state of nature—and it holds in the civil state—any quantity of money does not suffice. Locke acknowledges this point: “these three last [(i), (ii), (iii)], being built on suppositions that are not likely to be found in the practice of mankind” (ibid.). This appropriate quantity of money is precisely connected to the legitimate aim of the civil government: namely, to handle the conflict between the moneyed men and the landed men.
Indeed, People not perceiving the Money to be gone, are apt to be jealous one of another; and each suspecting anothers inequality of Gain to rob him of his share, every one will be imploying his skill, and power, the best he can, to retrieve it again, and to bring Money into his Pocket in the same plenty as formerly. But this is but scrambling amongst ourselves, and helps no more against our want, than the pulling of a short Coverlet will, amongst Children, that lye together, preserve them all from the Cold. Some will starve, unless the Father of the Family provide better, and enlarge the scanty Covering. This pulling and contest is usually between the Landed man and the Merchant. (ibid., pp. 290–291; my emphasis in bold)
This quotation confirms what we encounter in Locke’s Second Treatise: a conflict exists. It occurs between the landed men and the moneyed men. We can understand this quotation as follows: the coverlet is money; the small coverlet is a metaphor for a lack of money. The “Children” are both the landlords and the moneyed men, while the “father of the family” represents the State. Regarding the working class, Locke does not write very much:
For the Labourer’s share, being seldom more than a bare subsistence, never allows that body of Men time or opportunity to raise their Thoughts above that, or struggle with the Richer for theirs, (as one common Interest) unless when some common and great Distress, uniting them in one universal Ferment, makes them forget Respect, and emboldens them to carve to their Wants with armed force: And then sometimes they break in upon the Rich, and sweep all like a deluge. But this rarely happens but in the mal-administration of neglected or mis-manag’d Government. (ibid.)
Locke considers them to be unable to perceive themselves as a class with a common interest;Footnote 52 as a consequence, they are not considered one of the “children.” However, we see here an opposition to Macpherson concerning the impossibility of the laboring class’s undertaking a revolution. This quotation from Locke does suggest that sometimes workers can rise up, even if this is rare.
The State must “provide” a better coverlet: it must ensure that the coverlet is large enough, otherwise the landed man thinks that the moneyed men “steal his Income into their Pockets, build their Fortunes upon his Ruin, and Ingross more of the Riches of the Nation than comes to their share” (ibid., p. 291). It must also ensure the distribution of the coverlet. That is to say that the aim of the State is to allow class’s coexistence. Locke is explicit: if the State does not intervene and enlarge the monetary coverlet or ensure a better monetary distribution, some children (either the landed man or the moneyed man) will die.Footnote 53 Hence, a meaningful interpretation of the metaphor is that the State must ensure there is enough money in circulation in the kingdom to deal with the conflict; that is to say, to avoid a civil war. Indeed, Locke explains that one of the children will die if he does not have a coverlet to protect him. His life is then “exposed” (1690, §16, p. 278) and can be taken by the other child fighting for the coverlet. This is precisely the definition of Locke’s state of war (ibid.). The situation in which there is no more “contest” between the “children” (landlords and moneyed men), represents a situation in which there is an appropriate quantity of money. Linking this quotation to chapter five of the Second Treatise, we can explain the reason why individuals leave the state of nature once money is introduced. It is not only because of a conflict between the rich and the poor, as hypothesized by Caffentzis and Vaughn, or a conflict between the laboring and the property classes, as suggested by Macpherson. On the contrary, linking Locke’s economic essays and his Second Treatise, I highlight a new type of conflict: the end of the state of nature is also triggered because of a conflict within the class of owners between the moneyed men and the landed men.
IV. CONCLUSION
By setting out the relation between Locke’s Second Treatise of Civil Government and his essay Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest, and Raising the Value of Money, I have explained that the class conflict in Locke’s work also occurs within the class of the owners. In his economic essay, the conflict is neither between those who have property and those who do not, as suggested by Macpherson, nor between the rich and the poor, as suggested by Vaughn. The conflict is between the landed men and the moneyed men, and, as a consequence, government is instituted to ensure there is an appropriate quantity of money. That is to say that there must be enough money in England to satisfy the money demand of both the landed men and the moneyed men and that money must not be held by one class.
Locke believed that variation in the quantity of money was the best way to measure wealth variation, a common idea in the seventeenth century, which was related to the belief that international trade is a zero-sum game (wherein, for example, a kingdom gets richer only at the expense of another). In this situation, Locke notes, there would be only two ways to become richer: to produce gold and silver, or get it from foreign countries. Locke is interested in this last possibility, since, according to him, owning mines has a disastrous effect upon a country, for, in this view, mining countries would have no incentive to develop wider economic activity.Footnote 54 He writes that there are, in fact, three ways to obtain money: “The way of getting from Foreigners, is either by force, borrowing, or trade” (Locke Reference Locke and Kelly1692, p. 299). We must underline that one way to attract foreign money is through an interest rate policy. This issue is all the more important in that it is also necessary to have an appropriate quantity of money in circulation, such that the conflict between the landlords and the moneyed men be manageable by the government. This means that politicians must be careful about the balance of trade: if we have a trade deficit, then the country faces a lack of money, which will worsen the conflict between the landed men and the moneyed men.
Locke’s analysis, as presented here, raises a new question: the conflict between landlords and moneyed men focuses on the monetary “coverlet”—e.g., that each man wants to increase his quantity of money. But when Locke wrote his economics essays, England was in a position of a lack of money.Footnote 55 As a consequence, the new issues that are at stake, and that should be addressed in future discussions, are: What is the appropriate quantity of money? How does the State obtain and maintain it?
