Scholars who work on Islam's origins have long recognized that the reliability of the Islamic narrative sources for the history of early Islam represents a major problem. Tayeb El-Hibri has now written a detailed and important new contribution to this debate as it relates to the history of the so-called rāshidūn caliphs: Abu Bakr, ʿUmar, ʿUthman, and ʿAli—with a kind of epilogue dealing briefly with Muʿawiya. Parable and Politics argues, for the most part convincingly, that the extensive reports about the rāshidūn caliphs found in the Islamic historiographical tradition are largely shaped by later—in particular, Abbasid period—narrators who succeeded in creating a coherent, unified story that frequently included allegories and other kinds of parallels. These parallels established associations (often implicit) between various individuals of the rāshidūn era and other people, including Muhammad and earlier prophets such as Abraham and Moses. As the author notes, “The story preserved in the early Islamic narratives was neither real in its details nor intended to be factual. Rather, it played with classical biblical imagery to communicate a parable on the folly of religious zealotry . . . the folly of political Puritanism . . . and the detrimental role that pride and heroism play in shaping certain religious conflicts” (pp. 237–38).
El-Hibri describes the literary image of each of the rāshidūn by means of a very close reading of many individual reports, in which he elucidates both the political and religious axes that are being ground, and the specific parallels between various figures and their actions. Some of these close readings struck me as very revealing, and one comes away from the book with a much greater appreciation of the difficulty of using the narrative sources to understand “what actually happened” and of the ways in which later narrators constructed the “master narrative.” Particularly interesting, for example, is the degree to which the figure of ʿUmar is central to the whole story, with important implications for the depiction of the reign not only of his successor, ʿUthman, but also of ʿAli, Muʿawiya, and the Umayyads generally.
The basic point of Parable and Politics is not entirely new, of course. A number of earlier scholars have explored the literary shaping of various figures in early narrative reports in an attempt to work out how much is “fact” and how much is literary invention. Tor Andrae's Die Person Muhammads in Lehre und Glauben seiner Gemeinde (Stockholm, Sweden: Nörstedt & söner, 1918), Erling Ladewig Petersen's ʿAli and Muʿawiya in Early Arabic Tradition (Odense, Denmark: Odense University Press, 1964), Uri Rubin's The Eye of the Beholder: The Life of Muhammad as Viewed by the Early Muslims (Princeton, N.J.: Darwin Press, 1995), and most recently, Khaled Keshk's The Historian's Muʿawiya (Saarbrücken, Germany: Verlag Dr. Müller, 2008) are a few salient examples. As for the presence of parallels between figures in the nascent Islamic community and earlier prophets, this idea too was at least adumbrated long ago in an article by P. Jensen, “Das Leben Muhammads und die David-Sage” (Der Islam 12 [1922]: 84–97). But El-Hibri's treatment is vastly more detailed and convincing than any so far dedicated to the rāshidūn and represents a quantum leap in our ability to appreciate just how important this kind of literary modeling of the key players in early Islamic history was. Moreover, he shows how this literary modeling drew parallels between, for example, the sīra of Muhammad and that of ʿAli (p. 211) as well as between the community of ʿAli's followers and earlier communities (pp. 234–41)—parallels that had been until now almost completely overlooked. This is a volume that is definitely worth the time of anyone who is concerned with the study of early Islamic history or with the development of Islamic historical writing.
It must be said, however, that this book is not an easy read. El-Hibri's prose is unfailingly clear and direct, but his discussion of the conflicting reports about, for example, the shūrā that led to ʿUthman's recognition as ruler is often as labyrinthine as the reports themselves: it is frequently difficult to see the wood for the trees, and one often simply gets lost in the detail. Readers who lack a very secure familiarity with the events, or at least the stories, of early Islamic history will not have much luck following most of the discussion.
There is also, I think, a more serious problem raised by El-Hibri's presentation. As we have known for a long time, and as Parable and Politics makes clearer than ever, the narrative sources for early Islam constitute a literature shaped by later (mainly Abbasid period?) political and religious concerns. But do these sources also contain any actual historical information about the early Islamic period? El-Hibri seems to waffle on this question. In a footnote on p. 354, he criticizes Patricia Crone because she views the sources as containing “the wreckage of past tradition that was tidied up later in the eighth and ninth centuries rather than being a back-projection of a coherent tradition from that period, as the present study argues.” This sounds, to me, a lot like saying there is no salvageable historical information in the narratives—only literary tropes and parables of later manufacture. Yet at many other places in the book, El-Hibri seems to be making comments not merely on the literary depiction of various actors but also on what they actually did, said, or thought in the early 7th century; or, at least, it is not clear to the reader whether El-Hibri is saying “this happened” or “this is what the narrators say happened” (e.g., pp. 96, 192, 238, 251, 277–78). But on what basis can he make pronouncements about what people did or how they behaved if there is no factual content in the narratives at all? In this regard, I wonder whether an approach such as that employed in Antoine Borrut's Entre mémoire et pouvoir: L'espace syrien sous les derniers Omeyyades et les premiers Abbassides (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 2010), with its vision of older materials that are successively reshaped at various political junctures, does not offer us a better chance of identifying the “seams” between historical/factual information and literary confection than does El-Hibri's more stark vision of wholesale literary back-projection. Pinning down these “seams” for particular groups of traditions, however, will doubtless long remain the Holy Grail of the study of early Islamic historiography. El-Hibri's Parable and Politics will help us get there by making us more clearly aware than ever before of the rich and highly creative allegorical and politico-religious arguments that are embedded so deeply in these traditions. It is unfortunate that the volume, with El-Hibri's meticulous and sometimes brilliant treatment of hundreds of particular narratives, does not include an index of traditions discussed, listed by primary source and page reference to a standard (i.e., accessible) edition, because the book might then serve, and serve well, as a kind of commentary on them. Perhaps a second printing could include this helpful addition.
