This vigorously argued, even polemical study brings together a heterogenous collection of relatively marginal literary works of the Roman imperial period under a strong claim: texts that do not have the contextual credentials to enter historicist scholarly discourses can and should be read in a different way. In other words, it's not them, it's us. The monograph proposes ‘anonymity’ as a broad hermeneutic that explores the absence of names as both a historical and literary feature of a text. Pursued through a series of case studies, the argument ultimately presents a polarity of naming in opposition to suppressing or obscuring proper names as an index of a work's relationship to temporality. Anonymity, then, is a concept that cuts across two different dimensions. The first is authority: granting or withholding names in a text illuminates power dynamics; the second is time: how a text deploys proper names (historical or fictional) reveals a ‘time management’ strategy, that is, granting or denying its legibility as a temporal artefact to a variety of ends. Although weakly attested works have tended to become marginal in our scholarly practices, or restricted to debates about periodicity, Geue proposes a new understanding of an imperial literary system that consistently utilises anonymity as a powerful literary intervention and double-edged weapon of memory.
While rejecting narrowly historicist philology as ‘discursive cul-de-sacs’ (5), Geue identifies Augustus’ Res Gestae as the programmatic text for subsequent imperial discourses. This brings together previously isolated texts stranded without enough historical scaffolding for interpretation into a post-Augustan collective. Geue analyses each as responding to the foundational polarity of naming and un-naming established by Augustus in the Res Gestae, which he sees confirmed in Suetonius’ subsequent depiction of the princeps as a dedicated graphomanic (ch. 1). Thus the precise dating of these texts matters less than their consistent attention to a distinctively Augustan ‘technology’ of ‘antonomasia’ (28): on the one hand, suppressing the names of enemies through periphrasis, and on the other, strategically withholding his own name to generate a field of potential ubiquity, ‘a megalomaniac move to bring everything and more under his name, a centripetal anonymity’ (29).
This first chapter establishes an effective paradigm for the rich, sometimes unwieldy and even contorted definitions of ‘anonymity’ that follow. Ovid's Ibis (ch. 2) and the pseudo-Senecan Octavia (ch. 3) thus illustrate how withholding names and antonomasia within the works reproduce and appropriate Augustus’ own authorial/authoritative strategies. While each of the chapters pursues close readings to elucidate the work's approach to naming and especially un-naming, the strongest chapters reveal an unexpected and distinctive literary function or effect of anonymity, broadly construed. To this reader, the two readings that most persuasively shift the scholarly debates from the historicist/prosopographic to make an intriguing case for re-reading are the chapters on the Laus Pisonis (ch. 5) and Calpurnius Siculus’ Eclogues (ch. 6). Both of these chapters examine ambiguity in nomenclature (also apparently a form of ‘anonymity’) caused by a proliferation of homonyms (the multiple Pisones) or by the confusion of speakers in Calpurnius Siculus’ amœbic pastoral exchanges. In the anonymous Laus Pisonis, the prosopographical uncertainty about which Piso is the addressee is neatly sidestepped by reading this text as a sample by an unknown poet using ‘Piso’ as a generic, conveniently plural example for an important literary patron. If the specific Piso cannot be identified by the seemingly universal qualities he possesses, this tells us something about the poet's marketing strategy and the poem as display product. This hypothesis takes anonymity as mutual: unknown poet creates generic panegyric for prospective patrons (145), and the close readings focus convincingly on repeated semantic themes of multiplicity and variability as advertising buzzwords demonstrating the poet's own adaptability to any potential patron's needs. This thought experiment leads us to a radically new scenario, unexpectedly supported by the most traditional philological methods of close reading.
The readings of ‘Calpurnius Siculus’ go beyond allusion tracing to show how the Eclogues create a pastoral world entirely resistant to political allegory: Geue suggests that the collection actively obfuscates any reader's ability to pin down a specific period or contemporary referent by constructing thematics and imagery of indeterminacy and the obscure. Geue calls this technique ‘future proofing’: as an infinitely reusable poetic template for any Caesar, any future poet, the Eclogues can never become obsolete or dated.
This is a provocative, lively read. Some readers may be put off by the polemics, or the hipper-than-thou style; others may, like me, find the work insightful and stimulating. But will today's idioms be ‘future proof’, or will they drag the very worthy ideas down when they sound dated to future readers?
