Central to the author's approach seems to be the question of how the seven tribal dynasties of the federation of the United Arab Emirates have escaped the fate that Daniel Lerner, Karl Deutsch, or Samuel Huntington had predicted, namely, that the processes of economic and social modernization would invariably create new social groups, which would succeed in challenging the existing leadership. Davidson calls this “the shaikh's dilemma.” This is one of several newly coined terms that, although facilitating the analysis of some developments, tend to be overused in order to accommodate a particular theoretical construct.
The book's table of contents demonstrates the disciplined structuring of the various topics but also reflects the author's propensity to categorize and pass judgment. The well-documented first chapter, “Historical Background,” and the third chapter, “Socioeconomic Development and the Diversification Efforts,” are flanked by the headings “Survival of the Monarchy” and “Domestic Pathologies and the Political Process,” which promise an outsider's view. The final chapter is “Globalization and the Prospects for Civil Society.”
The seven rulers who, with the help of the British Foreign Office, agreed to establish a federation in 1971, probably did not realize at the time that this political construct—among other functions—guaranteed the continuation of their own positions as rulers, nor could they have anticipated that securing these positions for themselves and their successors for decades to come in the face of a worldwide trend away from hereditary rule of any kind would represent a formidable achievement. Davidson looks at the ways these developments came about. Although always testing the various modernization theories of Huntington and others, he cites instances when a ruler voluntarily yielded portions of his authority. In his view, the establishment of consultative assemblies, both on the federal level as the Federal National Council and at the level of the individual emirates, which he calls “institutionalising coexistence,” has “remained extremely limited” (p. 68). In this chapter and elsewhere, the author explains that there has never been a heavy reliance on coercion in order to maintain leaders' positions. He makes the point that in all regions of the United Arab Emirates, political authority is highly personalized and remains a matter of traditional recognition of the ruling families' legitimacy as well as gratitude for the guidance and modernizing initiatives that individual rulers have provided for their people and the country as a whole. In particular, the role of the late president Shaikh Zayed bin Sultan is given as an example of strong leadership through his highly personal and very popular rule.
The means of exercising control by way of a great variety of privileges granted to UAE citizens and the ways most expatriates participate in the country's economic bonanza are described within the categories of “rentierism” and “client dependencies.” Here and elsewhere in the book, developments that have become obvious in hindsight are being called “strategies” as if the “modernizing monarchs” were themselves aware of the choice of political science theories that form the backbone of the author's argument (p. 295). Nevertheless, the author's analysis is often more understanding and sympathetic than the somewhat patronizing style and unnecessary jargon suggest.
Testing the theory that modernization leads to replacement of traditional rule by newly powerful groups, Davidson asks to what extent globalization may help empower citizens in an unprecedented way. He describes how the United Arab Emirates has been connected economically and culturally with neighboring regions throughout history, in particular with the Indian subcontinent. Yet, there are two trends at work now, one that sees globalization as a threat to the society's identity and culture. In contrast, there is the multitude of links, which a multiethnic, urbanized, mobile society in this extremely wealthy economy is bound to develop as a matter of routine and without asking for governmental sanction or societal approval. Dubai's government and citizens have already embraced globalization as an instrument for developing this community's future. Davidson dedicates much space to these signals of economic growth, which can be gleaned in particular from statistics, publications, and interviews obtained in Dubai. In the author's view, the United Arab Emirates represents the liberalizing spirit of the “new rentiers” seeking to boost foreign investment (p. 285).
The author possibly overstates the connection between globalization and the formation and practical role of civil society. He finds a lot of evidence on paper for the emergence and existence of professional, cultural, charitable, and societal associations, but this may distort reality. The majority of the local people still have the strongest links within the extended family, and they do not look outside it for meaningful associations. He concludes this chapter by writing, “Finally, and perhaps most significant, certain external bodies may be capable of motivating the UAE government to free up civic space from above,” bodies such as “global NGOs and major international players” (p. 287). However, contrary to what might be expected, this chapter on globalization and civil society does not provide any further reference to the key question of whether, among this nascent civil society, there are new groups motivated or capable of unseating the powers in the land, as postulated by the political science modernization gurus.
The author maintains a political science approach throughout the study, which may qualify it as a textbook for development studies but does not necessarily help further a deeper understanding of the complexities of this multiethnic society and its relationship with the country's rulers and enduring political traditions. Yet, when he is not discussing the veracity of political science theories in light of this country's structures and developments, he presents a vast amount of supporting material, the result of extensive field research. Throughout the book but particularly in the third chapter on socioeconomic development, this material is presented as text as well as in the form of tables and graphics. Because reliable statistical sources are so difficult to come by, it is tempting to rely heavily on the neatly presented figures issued by various governmental agencies, particularly in Dubai. However, in the case of the UAE reliance on too many of such one-sided references may distort the picture for the entire country. In addition, such graphs only help to date a book, and the sensitive explanation of trends and their reasons and origins would continue to help the reader to appreciate the relevance of a particular topic. However, that is a matter of approach.
It is regrettable that some graphs are simply wrong. For instance, the percentages of ownership of the Abu Dhabi Company for Onshore Oil Operations adds up to more than 100 percent (p. 94); the same goes for figure 2.2, the ownership of the Zadcum Development Company (p. 95). There are several more factual errors, which need not be demonstrated in detail. What might be useful would be to point out that such mistakes demonstrate it may not be enough to find a source and quote it. This quoted authority may have fed on a source that—although local—may not have had the chance to obtain a reliable picture either.
It also appears that too many statistics can cloud the obvious. Reporting on the country's truly amazing human development achievements, the author seems to be mesmerized by available figures such as, for instance, the numbers of schools, students, teachers, graduates, etc. However, he does not discuss the lack of quality in the education provided by state schools throughout the United Arab Emirates, which has been a matter of much public debate. The role of private education, especially in tertiary education, needs to be part of this picture; the hundreds of private schools teach not only the children of expatriates, who do not qualify for a place in government-provided education, but also a large percentage of nationals who want to have a better choice and prefer to pay for private school. It seems relevant to socioeconomic development that private universities and colleges, which use English as a medium for teaching, are being established in ever growing numbers. Their students are the children of the expatriate population, as well as students from neighboring countries, such as Iran, while more and more nationals also join this multinational student body. The author's somewhat uncritical reproduction of statistics also leads him to accept without further comment a government statement that the United Arab Emirates “managed to reach 83% sufficiency in vegetables” (p. 130). This may be the case on paper, but one only needs to visit any of the extensive vegetable wholesale markets to find that importing vegetables from anywhere in the world is a huge business in the United Arab Emirates and that only a fraction of the local produce is actually marketed and consumed.
This reviewer's strongest criticism of the book is reserved for its tone. Starting with the subtitle “A Study in Survival,” and including the use of the term “pathologies” when analyzing the characteristics of the United Arab Emirates' political and social development, the book conveys an attitude of censorship, allocating praise or criticism depending on whether the rulers or other planners of strategies have followed political scientists' theories and rules. This is not to say that such overarching theories, which were developed with different societies and other ages in mind, are not helpful. However, their prominence in this book gives the impression that the author prefers to remain a critical outsider even though he has the opportunity to demonstrate that he does indeed appreciate the many facets that are making the United Arab Emirates' transition to modernity such a special case.
This book only partially provides the comprehensive analysis of the current state of the country's development process. One might expect this largely because it shares the characteristic of theory overload with many other political science books that were first written as PhD dissertations. Students know that the supervisor will judge a thesis largely on the treatment and analytical use of the theoretical apparatus taught to them. As for the subject matter, a supervisor may never have time to sufficiently inform himself to judge a candidate's research results in the detailed treatment of a geographically remote society. However, because there are so few academic studies of the Gulf, this book is a welcome addition, maybe in particular because of its “outsider” approach and the somewhat trendy theoretical postulations. As a textbook it is well presented and “user friendly” with rarely less than 250 endnotes for each chapter; a very comprehensive bibliography; and a useful glossary, index, list of acronyms, and the aforementioned tables and figures.
