Philip Lambert's To Broadway, to Life! The Musical Theater of Bock and Harnick marks the first “comprehensive look at Bock and Harnick's accomplishments and a full assessment of their contributions” (xi). The book is organized in a straightforward chronological manner, with its first two chapters devoted to the early lives and musical/theatrical training and experiences of Jerry Bock and Sheldon Harnick. In the following six chapters (3–8) Lambert considers the seven musicals written by the duo between 1957 and 1970—The Body Beautiful, Fiorello! (both in Chapter 3), Tenderloin, She Loves Me, Fiddler on the Roof, The Apple Tree, and The Rothschilds; in the final chapter he looks at the work they each created after their partnership dissolved. Two appendixes, detailing the major productions of each musical as well as media resources, and a bibliography are also useful inclusions.
In each of the chapters focusing on the musicals created by the pair, Lambert provides a short plot summary of a show and outlines its history from inception to subsequent revivals. He considers the original sources upon which Bock and Harnick based their works, and traces the differences between those originals and Bock and Harnick's treatment, sometimes detailing how a particular source inspired specific lyrics, libretto passages, or musical numbers. Lambert explores the process of creating a musical across these six chapters, including consideration of the significance of contributions from other members of the creative team (notably librettists such as Joseph Stein or Joe Masteroff, and directors such as Harold Prince and Jerome Robbins), and the changes made throughout that process (such as the addition and deletion of songs in pre-Broadway tryouts, and how these changes affect the overall musical structure and dramatic arc of a given piece). Lambert allocates significant space in these chapters to a detailed analysis of each show's musical score in support of his argument that Bock and Harnick furthered the integration of book, music, lyrics, and drama in a post–Rodgers and Hammerstein Broadway theatre era. These six chapters all end with a consideration of the Broadway premiere of the show(s) in question, a summary of the major critics’ reactions, and, when applicable, an overview of its revivals and any subsequent revisions made to its book, lyrics, or score. Especially when discussing the initial critical response to a show, or the reasons that a particular show was not as successful as expected, Lambert deftly weaves together quotes from initial reviews as well as from previous scholarship and commentary, such as work done by Ethan Mordden and Ken Mandelbaum; however, he often stops short of offering his own extended analysis and commentary in these situations. Given that the book jacket promises “interpretive critical analysis,” I sometimes felt let down by Lambert's restraint.
Likely to prove of great interest to many readers are Lambert's detailed descriptions of Bock and Harnick's creative process, which are constructed of material derived from the original interviews and excellent archival research Lambert conducted for the book, as well as from previously published interviews and other books, articles, and reviews. For instance, in describing the pair's working process, from their initial meetings to periods of working first alone and then together again, Lambert notes that Bock and Harnick estimate they actually wrote two or three songs for every one that was ultimately retained in a show's final version. Also of interest will be Lambert's brief mentions of some of the lesser-known works created by the pair (these mentions appear in the chapters into which the works chronologically fall), from “music for beer commercials” (184) or ads promoting the Ford Motor Company's “new line of tractors and implements” (62), to made-for-TV musicals such as The Canterville Ghost, to uncredited additions to other musicals such as Baker Street. Given how much ground Lambert has to cover, however, occasionally these portions of his book read rather dryly as a series of lists.
It is unfortunate that it was not possible for Lambert or his publishers to include a CD with this book, or—as Raymond Knapp did for The American Musical and the Formation of National Identity (Princeton University Press, 2006)—to provide in the text a link to an associated Web page with musical clips. Short descriptions such as “[t]he style of the song [“Ooh, Merci Beaucoup,” written for but ultimately cut from The Body Beautiful (1958)] is reminiscent of an up-tempo arrangement by Glenn Miller or Benny Goodman” (55) to illustrate Bock's skill in creating authentic-sounding period music are probably easily accessible for most readers; but more complex musical analysis that points, for example, to “[t]he tritones in the bass between the tonic E ♭ and the raised fourth A ♮, as well as the prominence of the raised fourth and other chromatic notes in the melody” (232) may be less so. Even though Lambert does an excellent job of explicating his analysis of the musical and textual antecedents and influences on Bock and Harnick, as well as of explaining in detail how the specific musical structure of a song advances the story by demonstrating its thoughtful combination of music with lyrics, such explanations (even when accompanied by excerpts from the musical score laid out on the page for comparison) may not fully suffice for readers with little background in music theory or lacking a wide knowledge of other Western compositions. Additionally, Lambert generally places more emphasis on analysis of Bock's score than Harnick's lyrics, which results in a perhaps unintentional minimization of the importance of lyrics and book to a completely integrated musical.
Despite the small quibbles noted above, Lambert's book is an excellent and much needed addition to the history of musical theatre in general and to the work of Bock and Harnick in particular, as well as an overall enjoyable read in itself. To Broadway, to Life! paves the way for future research and analysis into the memorable musicals of this team.
