In 1922, the Committee of Reference and Counsel of the Foreign Missions Conference of North America published a detailed report based on a survey of Christian education in China, which strongly urged mission schools in China to become ‘Chinese’ as soon as possible:
The Christian schools must also as rapidly as possible divest themselves of their foreign character … . It must be remembered that Chinese Christians are Chinese as well as Christian, and that the very patriotism which Christianity tends to produce will draw them away from a school whose atmosphere is foreign and to one that is Chinese. It is not wise to compel them to choose between these alternatives … .
Thoroughly Christian in its character and thoroughly Chinese in its atmosphere, raised to a high level of efficiency, it can render a service which a school lacking any of these characteristics cannot at all perform.Footnote 1
In the same year, the Anti-Christian Movement broke out in response to a conference of the World Student Christian Federation on 4 April at Tsinghua University, Beijing. This movement brought Christianity under serious attack. Provoked by political disintegration resulting from conflict between warlords, and by the unfavourable position of the country internationally, a result of Western interference, a new ideological conception of nationalism arose among Chinese intelligentsia and soon spread nationwide. Under the influence of Lenin's theory of imperialism, this modern nationalism dramatically changed the image of Christianity: from being viewed as a positive factor in China's modernization, it began to be rejected as a hated cultural imperialist encroachment.Footnote 2 The period from 1924 to 1927 featured demands for the restoration of educational rights as well as customs rights and extraterritorial rights, and the identity of mission schools began to fuel the hatred of nationalists in republican China. In its survey of Christian education and the socio-political context in China, the American Committee of Reference and Counsel seems already to have sensed the uneasy tension between mission schools and Chinese nationalists, and its recommendation can be seen as an attempt to turn the tide before the conflict was exacerbated still further.
This article takes Tientsin Anglo-Chinese College (TACC) of the London Missionary Society (LMS) as a case study.Footnote 3 It examines how the TACC authorities responded to nationalist sentiments emerging during this period, and how they reacted to the forced registration of schools and the subsequent removal of compulsory religious education. Particular attention is paid to the tension between the identity of mission schools and the quest for strong national sovereignty in Chinese society, and to the conflict between two divergent trends of Christianizing and nationalizing education in early twentieth-century China. The college self-identified as the representative of British education in China; its image as foreign, together with that of other Christian colleges and schools, became one of the major sources of Chinese nationalist resentment. This article argues, however, that other factors, such as the college's location, its local social network and the composition of its student body, also played a part in the college's negotiations with the nationalist government. The case of TACC reflects the complexity of the experiences of Christian schools in the midst of nationalist challenges. This has not been thoroughly explored in scholarship on the interaction between Christian schools and Chinese nationalism.Footnote 4
British Identity meets Chinese Sovereignty: TACC during the Anti-Christian Movement
A by-product of the LMS's mission work in north China, the forerunner of TACC was founded by Jonathan Lees (1835–1902) in Tianjin in 1863, under the name ‘Theological Institute in Tianjin’ (天津養正聖經學院), with the purpose of training native Christian workers.Footnote 5 During the 1890s, it underwent a process of reconstruction and enlargement under Samuel Lavington Hart (1858–1951), and developed into a college equipped with advanced Western facilities.Footnote 6 When it reopened in 1902 after the Boxer Uprising, the college adopted the name ‘Tientsin Anglo-Chinese College’ (天津新學書院) in response to Hart's vision. It aimed ‘to meet the desire for Western Learning’ and ‘to give a liberal education, based on Christian principles, to the class of Students who would otherwise be out of touch with ordinary Missionary effort’.Footnote 7 TACC was opened up to large numbers of non-Christian families and moved towards becoming a college of higher education. It thus differed from most Christian universities and colleges in republican China, which had their origins in nineteenth-century mission schools aiming to provide students with both knowledge of the Bible and a general education. The college's development from a theological seminary, whose specific purpose had been to train native church workers, to a modern college reflects an exceptional case in the history of Christian education in China.Footnote 8 In 1918, however, the collegiate department of TACC, which offered degree courses in arts, science and engineering, was transferred to the newly established Yenching University in Beijing. From that point on, TACC existed as a middle school.Footnote 9 During the 1920s, when the Anti-Christian Movement broke out, TACC ranked prominently amongst the educational institutions in Tianjin, with an enrolment of 555 students.Footnote 10 Its graduates proved competitive in the job market, and a considerable number worked in the customs service, in the postal service, on the railways and in the bureau of mines in Tianjin and elsewhere, while others pursued further study overseas or taught in TACC and other Christian schools and colleges.Footnote 11
Hart successfully turned the institute into a modern college of higher education. However, faced by the appeal to all Christian schools in China to ‘become as rapidly as possible thoroughly Chinese’,Footnote 12 the TACC authorities seem to have failed to meet this call. The origins and development of the college, for Hart and other TACC missionary staff, had given it a symbolic significance, and in particular a ‘unique position’ as representing British education:
The TACC … stands alone as the representative of British education in the North of China, excluding Peking and Mukden … .
Returning to the unique position which the TACC must take up as the representative of British Education, the need to increase the present diminished staff is evident.Footnote 13
Twenty years after its establishment, therefore, the college was still proudly emphasizing its British identity.Footnote 14 This contradicted the increasingly nationalist tone of Chinese society, and would be seriously challenged by the Anti-Christian Movement.
During its first stage in 1922, this movement developed into a broader campaign to oppose all religions and to achieve social progress through the advancement of science.Footnote 15 According to A. P. Cullen, a member of the TACC staff, in this period there were elements ‘distinctly hostile to Christian influences’ among the students.Footnote 16 A magazine was issued, in which students criticized foreign missionaries as being ‘Government propagandists’ of the West, whose intention was the ‘ultimate enslavement and destruction’ of China.Footnote 17 Nonetheless, for Cullen and other TACC missionary staff, this anti-Christian tide seemed to have died down very quickly.Footnote 18 It thus attracted little of their attention.
A sudden change of circumstances occurred after 1924, when churches and mission schools were denounced as agents of foreign cultural aggression. According to Hart's annual report to the LMS, not only students but also staff and teachers in several schools in Tianjin became ‘active agents’ during the disturbance. A good number of them were influenced by Soviet propaganda on imperial cultural aggression, as well as Sun Yat-sen's nationalist cry, ‘China for the Chinese’.Footnote 19 Christian school authorities and their Christian influences became the main targets of challenge and resistance.Footnote 20 Statements made during a number of meetings of Chinese educational institutes criticized Western ‘interference’ in China's educational policy. Some of the institutes passed resolutions attempting to condemn missionary educational methods and to abolish religious instruction in schools. Even at a conference of Christian educators in Beijing in 1924, criticism of Western education and mission schools in China could be heard.Footnote 21
The Anti-Christian Movement was pushed to its climax by the ‘May Thirtieth Incident’ in 1925, the death of thirteen Chinese students fired on by British policemen in Shanghai.Footnote 22 This sparked off the spread of anti-foreign sentiment throughout the country. While students and other young people became increasingly politicized after the incident, leftists successfully transformed the anti-Christian sentiment into an anti-imperialist one. Chinese nationalists turned their attention to the issues of the unequal treaties between China and its international partners and to the educational rights of mission schools. A large number of urban Chinese Christians, particularly mission school students, took part in patriotic campaigns and protests.Footnote 23 Hart regarded 1925 as ‘the most anxious of all the years in the history of the College’.Footnote 24 There were strikes at TACC in June, when students refused to take classes and demanded that the college authorities issue a statement expressing solidarity with the Chinese. Some students left to join Li Ming (Dawn) School, a newly established college in Beijing, which took an oppositional stance against TACC and other Christian schools.Footnote 25 TACC, like all other Christian schools and churches in China, experienced an identity crisis in the face of these nationalist challenges.
During this period, Christian education was condemned as an intrusion on ‘national sovereignty’ and religious freedom.Footnote 26 In October 1923, the Young China Association, a key promoter of nationalist campaigns, issued a declaration advocating ‘nationalist education’ aimed at fostering patriotic sentiments amongst the Chinese. Christian education was rejected as a type of cultural invasion or ‘de-nationalization’, leading to the loss of national consciousness and identity among students.Footnote 27 Education was thus viewed as an inseparable aspect of ‘national sovereignty’. Jessie Lutz argues that a fundamental factor behind this mentality was the concept that the main function of education, including Christian education, was to ‘serve the state’.Footnote 28 Christian education, therefore, needed to be under Chinese control in order to serve national purposes. To reclaim educational rights from foreign educational establishments was, in nationalist thinking, equivalent to defending national sovereignty. They began, therefore, to call for Christian schools to be registered with the government.
Sinicization and De-Christianization: TACC's Process of School Registration
On 16 November 1925, the Beijing Board of Education issued ‘Regulations Governing the Recognition of Educational Institutions Established by Funds Contributed from Foreigners’. This required mission schools to be registered: to do so, they had to have Chinese principals or vice-principals; the curriculum must conform to Ministry of Education standards; there should be no compulsion to attend religious ceremonies; and no course in religion should be included amongst the compulsory subjects.Footnote 29
The attitude of the TACC authorities in 1925 remained very suspicious towards registration, and the college seemed sceptical about the process and reluctant to engage with it:
Will there be room for a College such as ours when the Chinese take full control of the education in their country? There will not be room for many of our institutions; they will have to be absorbed in the general national scheme of education. First may come the necessity to undergo Registration, with such safeguards as can be agreed upon. Then will come the rivalry of Government institutions, and the favour shown to those who are learning in them. The next phase may be the difficulty in making ends meet, and finally the closing down of many of the schools that have done splendid work up to the present.Footnote 30
The college authorities were aware, however, of the fact that there would be a heavy price to pay for non-registration: ‘If the power of the Cantonese spreads northwards, we may have to face the alternative as to whether we accept the principles of Sun Yat Sun [Sun Yat-sen] and are willing to place him in the highest pinnacle of honour, or close our College for good.’Footnote 31
During the North Expedition of 1926–8, large numbers of Christian schools and colleges came under serious nationalist attack, and the government continued to urge schools to register in accordance with the regulations. At the 1926 annual conference of the National Christian Council of China (NCC), the committee on religious education emphasized the need for school registration:
The disadvantages of non-registration will be so serious for middle schools and colleges that every effort must be made to retrieve whatever loss in opportunity for religious education may be involved in registration. Manifestly an added responsibility will fall on the Church to meet this loss by providing a more adequate programme of religious education.Footnote 32
Under these circumstances, TACC was obliged to take action to prepare for registration. Its first step, in 1927, was to draft a new constitution, according to which the college was placed under control of a court of governors, consisting of prominent Chinese and British residents of Tianjin.Footnote 33 The court of governors then elected a management board to administer college affairs; this was composed of six Chinese and five British members.Footnote 34
Anti-Christian sentiments lessened in intensity during 1927–8. However, measures to ensure state control over education had just begun. The National Government of the Republic of China in Nanjing, established in 1927, and the Chinese Educational Bureau, established in 1928, both made school registration mandatory and accelerated its pace. Although in the early 1920s there had been strong nationalist appeals for mission school registration and two separate governments to apply this policy, in the north (the Beiyang Government) and the south (the Guomindang [GMD] Government), there was no centralized governmental authority which could have enforced a unified implementation of registration.
One of TACC's chief concerns in 1928 was its application for registration. The new government regulations had made it impossible for the college to send graduates to Yenching University unless it was registered with the Chinese Educational Bureau.Footnote 35 The process of registration as reported by Hart was not pleasant. The Chinese Educational Bureau was determined to force the college to change some of its educational methods and amend a number of its regulations. Above all, it demanded that the college abandon its ‘foreign headship’, a requirement of all mission school registration.Footnote 36 Nationalists intended to use school registration to achieve the twin goals of the ‘sinicization’ and ‘de-Christianization’ of mission schools.Footnote 37 Ideological control over mission schools was high on the agenda. Hart reported that the Educational Bureau required full information about all teaching members of the college, including information about where they had been trained, and whether they had been trained according to the principles of the GMD, the ‘Three Principles of the People’.Footnote 38 It also assigned teachers who had been trained under the ‘Three Principles of the People’ to teach in the college, and Chinese drill sergeants to provide students with military training.Footnote 39
Registration only proved possible after Hart's retirement, which obliged the college to find a successor and enabled it to appoint a Chinese principal, thus fulfilling the registration requirements. However, Hart and other TACC missionary staff believed that the principal should be a ‘British-trained’ Christian, who would preserve the college's British traditions and spirit.Footnote 40 Moreover, the TACC missionaries were convinced that to ‘take the place of Dr. Hart was a manifest impossibility’. They therefore intended to ‘satisfy Chinese feelings’ by appointing an honorary principal or president, who would have no share in the ordinary internal affairs of the college, but would be held in high esteem by society.Footnote 41 In 1929, after Hart's retirement, Huang Rongliang (Y. L. Hwang, 黃榮良) accepted the invitation to serve as honorary principal. According to Cullen, Huang had not only been educated in universities both in China and overseas, but had also served since 1909 as the Chinese minister (equivalent to ambassador) to New Zealand, Australia and Austria.Footnote 42 There can be no doubt that Huang's experience met the criteria set by the TACC missionaries. The college's registration was completed in April 1930, soon after Huang took up the position of honorary principal at the beginning of the 1929–30 academic session.Footnote 43 However, Huang tendered his resignation in September 1930, only a few months after registration was completed. The college failed to find ‘another gentleman willing to act’ as honorary principal, and Ma Shanggong (S. K. Ma, 馬尚功), the vice-principal, was appointed acting principal of the college.Footnote 44 It was not until 1942, after the outbreak of the Pacific War, when foreigners were interned by Japanese troops, that the Chinese principal really took charge of college affairs.Footnote 45 The exact reason behind Huang's resignation remains unclear from the available sources. According to C. H. B. Longman, a LMS missionary and a member of the TACC staff, the position of honorary principal ‘demands more time and attention than Mr. Hwang [Huang] felt able to give, if he is to be well acquainted with the working of the College and have real authority’.Footnote 46 However, Cullen's confidential report to the LMS in 1929 may reveal Huang's real concern:
He [Huang] is not altogether satisfied with the arrangement … . He feels that he is not sufficiently ‘Principal’ to be in a position to cope with these things [knotty college affairs], and not sufficiently ‘Honorary’ to be able to disregard them or delegate them to those more intimately acquainted with the ordinary methods of procedure.Footnote 47
One alumnus recalls that Huang's resignation was rather a response to a contretemps with Longman.Footnote 48
As discussed above, besides the aim of sinicizing Christian schools, the other important objective of the nationalist government was to de-Christianize them through forbidding compulsory religious activities and classes. According to the report of the China Christian Educational Association in 1926, Christian school authorities and Chinese Christian educators generally agreed that schools should accept the regulations and register with the government. However, they had deep reservations about the regulation which made religious education and practice optional in schools.Footnote 49 The cost of acceptance was that the distinctively Christian characteristics of the schools would be much weakened and even lost. It therefore became a central concern for Christian educators.
In this area, however, TACC seems not to have encountered as many obstacles as most other Christian colleges and universities, for most of its religious activities had been on a voluntary basis for some time.Footnote 50 Hart had reported that voluntary ‘Bible Circles’ (Bible classes) were held in almost all year groups, with a total enrolment of 173 students. The daily assembly for morning prayers was voluntary in theory, but had full attendance in practice. As a college open to non-Christians, in 1930 the percentage of Christian students in the college was recorded as 10.4 per cent. In some year groups, however, the percentage of Christian students was as high as 46 per cent.Footnote 51
On the whole, TACC's registration, although undertaken reluctantly, met no major obstacles. The college was not as seriously affected by the anti-Christian campaigns as other Christian schools and colleges, some of which – such as Nankai University in Tianjin, St John's University in Shanghai and Holy Trinity College in Guangzhou (Canton) – found themselves the targets of nationalist attack. Even in 1925 when the Anti-Christian Movement was at its peak, the majority of TACC's graduating students attended the diploma and university entrance examination. When the September semester started that year, an enrolment of 350 was recorded. By March 1927, the total enrolment had reached 500, its maximum capacity.Footnote 52 One reason for this may have been the college's location in the French concession, where the power of the Chinese authorities and nationalists was more limited, and certain liberties were guaranteed.Footnote 53 Within the college, apart from the discord between Huang and Longman noted above, a friendly relationship between missionaries and Chinese staff generally manifested itself, even during this time of trial. Longman and Hart both affirmed their Chinese colleagues’ ‘magnificent loyalty’.Footnote 54 This may have reflected the homogeneous nature of the college staff, but also the fact that many Chinese members of staff were recruited from the college. According to the records, TACC's first five graduates all stayed to take up positions as college faculty members.Footnote 55 Two-thirds of the Chinese staff were college alumni and were therefore likely to have similar views and values to their missionary colleagues.Footnote 56 In addition, and perhaps even more importantly, the social network which TACC developed in North China greatly aided the college in its negotiations with the educational authorities. A good number of prominent politicians and businessmen, both Chinese and foreign, had been closely related to TACC since its establishment. Some served as its sponsors or belonged to the court of governors, others sent their children to the college, such as Yuan Shikai (袁世凱), former president of the Republic of China, and Liang Yanqing (梁燕卿), Comprador (Chinese manager) of Jardine Matheson Holdings Limited in Tianjin.Footnote 57 A large number of TACC students came from the more ‘wealthy and influential’ classes of Chinese society,Footnote 58 while most of its graduates were recruited by commercial associations, banks, customs offices and the railways, all key to the region and vital to China's modernization. Situated in Tianjin, one of the major commercial ports in modern China, TACC's strong ‘foreign’ identity and educational features may to some extent have been ‘tolerated’ by a good number of students and the social elite, owing to the pragmatic benefits it brought them.
Conclusion
The competitiveness of TACC graduates in the job market demonstrates that in general, Christian education in China had played a positive role in spreading Western learning and technology in China and contributing to the construction of a modern society. However, questions may be raised as why, during the 1920s, Christian schools were regarded rather as an obstacle to China's modernization. The tension between Christian education and Chinese nationalism reveals a number of issues which Christianity – and with it Christian education – was facing in the semi-colonial Chinese context.
Firstly, Christianity in China had failed to respond adequately to China's desire for national unity, strength and sovereignty. One of the most important themes in modern Chinese history was the desire to seek a path towards ‘national salvation’ (Jiu Guo, 救國). Yip Ka-che identified two dimensions of ‘national salvation’: the ending of foreign domination in China and the establishment of a strong centralized state equipped to facilitate socio-economic modernization.Footnote 59 Christianity was unable to offer solutions for the first dimension owing to its apparently inseparable relationship with foreign countries.Footnote 60 In the quest to establish a powerful state, the possibility of establishing a liberal Western social and political model for Christian China was discredited when China's interests were neglected at the Paris Peace Conference of 1919.Footnote 61 In addition, with the widespread introduction of Western science, technology, thought and learning into Chinese society, the majority of Chinese intellectuals and the social elite increasingly distinguished Christianity from Western civilization, considering it irrelevant to the process of modernization.Footnote 62
Secondly, a new type of nationalism matured in the 1920s; influenced by Lenin's theory of cultural imperialism, it relocated Christianity on the political map of China.Footnote 63 Education came to be viewed as a vital part of national sovereignty, as a means of instilling a sense of national identity and ideals, and control over the educational rights of Christian schools was thus brought onto the agenda of the nationalist campaigns. The case of TACC reveals the twofold approach of the nationalist government to national education during the first half of the twentieth century: nationalization (sinicization) and secularization (de-Christianization) of mission schools. It further demonstrates that the nationalization of Christian education took priority. TACC was regarded by missionaries as a key representative of British education in China. This, to some extent at least, validated the intent of the Chinese nationalists to make mission schools Chinese by appointing Chinese heads: the sinicization of Christian schools could never be fully realized as long as school affairs remained in the hands of missionaries. The case of TACC also reflects the complexity and ambiguity of the interaction between Christian schools and Chinese society, in which its practical role and its local social network had an important effect. Mission schools did not all share the same fate during the Anti-Christian Movement. This complexity deserves closer examination.
The nationalist government endeavoured to de-Christianize mission schools through enforcing patriotic education (‘party transformation education’).Footnote 64 Military training was made compulsory in all registered middle schools, replacing compulsory classes in religion, where they existed.Footnote 65 The tension between Christian education and nationalist education or, to put it more precisely, the process of incorporating Christian education into the national educational system in order to serve the parties’ political purposes, continued throughout the 1930s, 1940s and 1950s. It led ultimately to the demise of Christian schools in communist China in 1952, when foreign missions were expelled from the mainland.Footnote 66
