Julia Allen's Swimming with Dr Johnson and Mrs Thrale sets out to explore how sport was practised in eighteenth-century Britain through the perspective of Dr Samuel Johnson and his close friend, the writer Hester Thrale. This is the second time Allen has tackled Dr Johnson: her Samuel Johnson's Menagerie (2002), about eighteenth-century notions of exotic quadrupeds, built on his Dictionary of the English Language (1755). In both publications she draws heavily on her expertise as a lexicographer. On this occasion, Allen aims to drag Johnson out of his study and show him in an outdoor context, while he either practises physical exercise or observes his contemporaries doing so. Mrs Thrale is a key source of information, not only because she recorded in her diary anecdotes concerning Johnson's relationship with sport activities, but also because she provides some female insight into a world which was mainly dominated by men.
The book opens with a general introduction shedding light on eighteenth-century notions of the body and its components; it then discusses the medical reasons put forward for exercising and how sport engaged with recreation in daily life. Afterwards, Allen goes on to discuss the topic in greater detail, devoting eight chapters to eight different ways that eighteenth-century men, and sometimes women, exercised: boxing, cricket, dancing, foot-racing, riding, skating, swimming and, finally, coach travel. Allen argues that these sports have not substantially changed much since then; what has changed is the physical, practical, social and cultural conditions in which they are undertaken. Through consideration of wide-ranging primary sources, including newspaper articles, diaries, treatises, manuals and medical texts, we learn that women did not run, occasionally played cricket, were highly encouraged to take dance classes, and were constantly struggling against the constraints of tight lacing. Dancing also played an important role in the formation of the perfect gentleman as it was believed to enhance manliness. Foot-racing was very popular, but there was no interest in the athletic performance; a race was usually organized because a bet had been made and the major concern was to see whether the terms of the wager had been met. Races run by men with wooden legs were very popular events; these competitors were usually former soldiers seeking a way to make money. Allen shows that one of the elements of continuity between today and the eighteenth century is the idea that physical activity kept the mind free of melancholy. Johnson, after returning from Oxford without a degree, used to walk sixty miles every day from Lichfield to Birmingham to fight depression. On the other hand, horse riding could produce depression, as it was a very dangerous and tough experience characterized by unstable weather conditions, uneven roads, dust, solitude and desert landscapes. Through the eyes of the protagonists, we are able to visualize how Johnson used to skate, on skates of his own design that allowed him to strike poses and stop efficiently, and feel Mrs Thrale's dismay at the view of a woman riding a horse with her legs entirely revealed, except for her stockings. It is noted that sport was necessary for the upper classes; rich people did not use physical strength in daily life, whereas people working in the fields were constantly doing hard physical labour. We do not read much of people who could not afford to get a pair of shoes, let alone shoes with iron to skate.
As Allen herself states, this book is not intended to serve as a comprehensive history of sport. Rather, it presents how sport was perceived by some of those eminent Georgians who participated in it. In particular, it illustrates how sport entered everyday conversation through the words of Dr Johnson and Mrs Thrale. Due to the methodology employed by Allen to give insight into eighteenth-century sporting life, the narrative can appear fragmented. She makes extensive use of long quotations extracted from different narrative genres, such as poems, anecdotes and private journals. At the beginning of each chapter there stands a series of dictionary entries and etymological notes relating to the subject at hand. A lexicographer may understand very well the story behind a word entry, but other readers might see this just as a display of information that is difficult to relate to any argument. And the inclusion in the body of the text of primary sources of many different types makes it hard to read, as the reader has to constantly adjust his or her eye to different writing styles. The advantage of this study is that provides particular accounts of sporting episodes for times when weather, physical conditions and clothing were very different. The disadvantage is that the standpoint is narrow. The suggestion to the reader is to try to avoid looking for a complete picture; rather, let yourself be pulled out of the present, resisting the temptation of interpreting the long quotations, and enjoy the pleasure of lingering amidst the images and poetic thoughts provided by the characters. They will illuminate you on the funny operations of mounting or dismounting a horse, or induce you to look at ice skating as a metaphor for the boundary between death and life.
