The history of South Asians in East Africa is neither part of the mainstream national Indian history nor that of East African history writing. In most cases, this history is also omitted from colonial and imperial histories of East Africa. This oversight is surprising in light of demographic conditions, because at times South Asians outnumbered Europeans ten to one. Moreover, in some ways South Asians outpaced the colonizers in their economic and political contributions to the region. Therefore, it is notable how little we know about the histories of South Asians in East Africa. Of course, there are writings on the Indian expulsion from Uganda by General Idi Amin in the early 1970s, and others have written about South Asian railway workers and portrayed South Asians as ‘middlemen’ or ‘settled strangers’. But overall, the Indian presence in East Africa is not properly acknowledged in the historiography.
I warmheartedly welcome this academic volume that focuses on one of the most neglected groups within the Asian community in East Africa; that is, Indian doctors. The authors, Anna Greenwood and Harshad Topiwala, make two additional and valuable claims in writing this book. First, they rightly argue that most books on Asians in East Africa are not written by Asians themselves, but by Europeans. Topiwala is the Kenyan-born son of one of the Asian doctors mentioned in this book. Second, the authors place the economic, cultural, and social position of Indian doctors in East Africa within the wider framework of empire, race, and medicine. That contextualization emerges from Greenwood's expertise.
In the lengthy introduction to the first four chapters, the authors frame the role of Indian doctors in the context of the popular literature on diaspora studies, writings on race and medicine, as well in the context of empire studies. These four chapters thoroughly summarize the existing literature. Chapters Five and Six explore the history of the early Colonial Medical Service (CMS) focusing on the contribution made by Indian doctors. These chapters show the fragile prospects of medical institution building in the colonial context. The demands on the CMS, however, were extraordinary, as the number of casualties and deaths during infrastructural projects like the building of the Uganda railway were high. Chapters Seven and Eight, finally, emphasize the personal lives and sometimes political struggles of the Indian doctors themselves. Some of them were not just doctors, but they engaged in larger political and social projects as well. Some worked to improve the cleanliness and sanitation in the suburbs of East African cities while others became involved in the Kenyan independence movement. These chapters show the ambivalent relationship between the Indian doctors and their colonial superiors in an East African context. On the one hand, the two groups complemented each other in a segregated society while, on the other hand, they rivaled and competed with one other. What is missing, especially in this section, are the results of oral histories and interviews.
Oral history and ethnographic observations could have added fascinating detail and personal experiences that extend beyond the records of the British Empire. Moreover, some South Asian doctors built long-term relationship with African families. These Africans, like those students who were taught in schools by Indian teachers, are less likely to see these professionals as ‘strangers’. And if the doctors as well as their patients were interviewed, a picture of South Asian history in East Africa would emerge that is less dominated by European perceptions. I am aware that such evidence would help to illuminate only the latest period of the research under review, such as the decades after the 1930s. Nevertheless, oral sources would have made even more complete this fascinating history.
Overall, this study is well written and embedded in a rich variety of records. The authors have seen the available sources in London, the British Library, India Office Records, National Archives in Kenya, as well the Kenya National Archives in Nairobi and the Maharashtra State Archives in Mumbai. In addition, they make extensive use of newspapers, like the East African Standard and the East African Chronicle and The Times. The result is a painstakingly well-researched and detailed description of the history of Indian doctors in East Africa. The book aims at an academic audience, but I am convinced that it will be similarly well received by the professional classes in East Africa as well.
